EDIT: I’m a flop and forgot a couple of songs so the order has changed  

 

FREAK (feat. YUNGBLUD) vs. Anyone

SKIN OF MY TEETH vs. Dancing With The Devil

SUBSTANCE vs. ICU (Madison’s Lullaby)

EAT ME (feat. Royal & The Serpent) vs. The Art Of Starting Over

HOLY **** vs. Lonely People

29 vs. The Way You Don’t Look At Me

HAPPY ENDING vs. Melon Cake

HEAVEN vs. Met Him Last Night (feat. Ariana Grande)

CITY OF ANGELS vs. What Other People Say (with Sam Fischer)

BONES vs. Carefully

WASTED vs. The Kind Of Lover I Am

COME TOGETHER vs. Easy (with Noah Cyrus)

DEAD FRIENDS vs. 15 Minutes 

HELP ME (feat. Dead Sara) vs. My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend (feat. Saweetie)

FEED vs. California Sober

4 EVER 4 ME vs. Mad World

Edited August 19, 20224 yr by Pink Ranger

tbh dwtdtaoso for all, the album was ahead of its time. Met him last night and melon cake are one of the Demi's highlights  

Edited August 19, 20224 yr by Souvenir

FREAK (feat. YUNGBLUD) vs. Anyone

SKIN OF MY TEETH vs. Dancing With The Devil

SUBSTANCE vs. ICU (Madison’s Lullaby)

EAT ME (feat. Royal & The Serpent) vs. The Art Of Starting Over

HOLY **** vs. Lonely People

29 vs. The Way You Don’t Look At Me

HAPPY ENDING vs. Melon Cake

HEAVEN vs. Met Him Last Night (feat. Ariana Grande)

CITY OF ANGELS vs. What Other People Say (with Sam Fischer)

BONES vs. Carefully

WASTED vs. The Kind Of Lover I Am

COME TOGETHER vs. Easy (with Noah Cyrus)

DEAD FRIENDS vs. 15 Minutes 

HELP ME (feat. Dead Sara) vs. My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend (feat. Saweetie)

FEED vs. California Sober

4 EVER 4 ME vs. Mad World

 

Holy - 11

Dancing - 5

 

 

Edited August 19, 20224 yr by Pink Ranger

Just now, Souvenir said:

tbh dwtdtaoso for all, the album was ahead of its time. Met him last night and melon cake are one of the Demi's highlights but it's so underrated  

MHLN I agree but melon cake is trash, the meaning is great obviously but it’s one of my least faves on the album  

1 minute ago, Pink Ranger said:

MHLN I agree but melon cake is trash, the meaning is great obviously but it’s one of my least faves on the album  

I love melon cake's lyrics so much. It was somehow relatable for me, the song really healed me during some dark times 

2 minutes ago, Souvenir said:

I love melon cake's lyrics so much. It was somehow relatable for me, the song really healed me during some dark times 

I’m glad the lyrics helped you, Happy Ending is destroying me with the relatability rn 

 

FREAK Vs Anyone

SKIN OF MY TEETH Vs (ICU) Madison’s Lullaby)

SUBSTANCE Vs Dancing With The Devil

EAT ME vs The Art Of Starting Over

29 vs Lonely People

HAPPY ENDING vs The Way You Dont Look At Me

HEAVEN Vs Melon Cake 

CITY OF ANGELS Vs Met Him Last Night

BONES Vs What Other People Say

WASTED Vs Carefully

COME TOGETHER  Vs The Kind Of Lover I Am

DEAD FRIENDS Vs Easy

HELP ME Vs 15 Minutes 

FEED vs My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend

4 EVER 4 ME Vs California Sober 

 

 

Toughest matchups were 29 vs. Lonely People and Happy Ending vs. The Way You Don’t Look At Me 

Edited August 19, 20224 yr by Rotunda

I am more of a DWTDTAOSO stan but both albums are incredible

 

FREAK Vs Anyone

SKIN OF MY TEETH Vs (ICU) Madison’s Lullaby)

SUBSTANCE Vs Dancing With The Devil

EAT ME vs The Art Of Starting Over

29 vs Lonely People ——-> tie

HAPPY ENDING vs The Way You Dont Look At Me

HEAVEN Vs Melon Cake —--> tie

CITY OF ANGELS Vs Met Him Last Night

BONES Vs What Other People Say

WASTED Vs Carefully —--> tie

COME TOGETHER  Vs The Kind Of Lover I Am —> tie

DEAD FRIENDS Vs Easy

HELP ME Vs 15 Minutes 

FEED vs My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend

4 EVER 4 ME Vs California Sober 

 

also Butterfly and Good Place are missing and are great on TAOSO. You also forgot HOLY ****, great song! 

out of these pair ups, 6 for HOLY ****, 5 for TAOSO, 4 ties. 

 

it depends what your taste preferences are, light indie yacht dream pop or dark hardcore southern rock. 
 

 

FREAK Vs Anyone

SKIN OF MY TEETH Vs (ICU) Madison’s Lullaby)

SUBSTANCE Vs Dancing With The Devil

EAT ME vs The Art Of Starting Over

29 vs Lonely People

HAPPY ENDING vs The Way You Dont Look At Me

HEAVEN Vs Melon Cake 

CITY OF ANGELS Vs Met Him Last Night

BONES Vs What Other People Say

WASTED Vs Carefully

COME TOGETHER  Vs The Kind Of Lover I Am

DEAD FRIENDS Vs Easy

HELP ME Vs 15 Minutes 

FEED vs My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend

4 EVER 4 ME Vs California Sober 

 

11 - HOLY ****

3 - DWTD…TAOSO

1 - TIE

40 minutes ago, Souvenir said:

tbh dwtdtaoso for all, the album was ahead of its time. Met him last night and melon cake are one of the Demi's highlights  

Met him last night?? 
 

Tea tho Melon Cake, Lonely People, and The Kind of Lover I Am are underrated! I love TAOSO sonically!! Amazing underrated album. 
 

 

Ummm what is this?  Part of the Dancing With The Devil… The Art of Starting Over track list was out of order and you forgot “HOLY ****” (the song). Unfortunately, “Butterfly” are “Good Place” left out as a result.

 

I FIXED it for y’all:

 

FREAK (feat. YUNGBLUD) vs. Anyone

SKIN OF MY TEETH vs. Dancing With The Devil

SUBSTANCE vs. ICU (Madison’s Lullaby)

EAT ME (feat. Royal & The Serpent) vs. The Art Of Starting Over

HOLY **** vs. Lonely People

29 vs. The Way You Don’t Look At Me

HAPPY ENDING vs. Melon Cake

HEAVEN vs. Met Him Last Night (feat. Ariana Grande)

CITY OF ANGELS vs. What Other People Say (with Sam Fischer)

BONES vs. Carefully

WASTED vs. The Kind Of Lover I Am

COME TOGETHER vs. Easy (with Noah Cyrus)

DEAD FRIENDS vs. 15 Minutes 

HELP ME (feat. Dead Sara) vs. My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend (feat. Saweetie) [this was so f**king hard]

FEED vs. California Sober (I truly can’t decide)

4 EVER 4 ME vs. Mad World

 

HOLY **** – 11

Dancing With The Devil… The Art of Starting Over – 4

Tied – 1

 

HOLY **** is perfection, the other is great 

1 minute ago, skwonderfactory said:

Ummm what is this?  Part of the Dancing With The Devil… The Art of Starting Over track list was out of order and you forgot “HOLY ****” (the song). Unfortunately, “Butterfly” are “Good Place” left out as a result.

 

I FIXED it for y’all:

 

FREAK (feat. YUNGBLUD) vs. Anyone

SKIN OF MY TEETH vs. Dancing With The Devil

SUBSTANCE vs. ICU (Madison’s Lullaby)

EAT ME (feat. Royal & The Serpent) vs. The Art Of Starting Over

HOLY **** vs. Lonely People

29 vs. The Way You Don’t Look At Me

HAPPY ENDING vs. Melon Cake

HEAVEN vs. Met Him Last Night (feat. Ariana Grande)

CITY OF ANGELS vs. What Other People Say (with Sam Fischer)

BONES vs. Carefully

WASTED vs. The Kind Of Lover I Am

COME TOGETHER vs. Easy (with Noah Cyrus)

DEAD FRIENDS vs. 15 Minutes 

HELP ME (feat. Dead Sara) vs. My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend (feat. Saweetie) [this was so f**king hard]

FEED vs. California Sober (I truly can’t decide)

4 EVER 4 ME vs. Mad World

 

HOLY **** – 11

Dancing With The Devil… The Art of Starting Over – 4

Tied – 1

 

HOLY **** is perfection, the other is great 

Oh **** my bad

I’ve edited and put the new version in the OP.. sorry gays  

FREAK (feat. YUNGBLUD) vs. Anyone

SKIN OF MY TEETH vs. Dancing With The Devil

SUBSTANCE vs. ICU (Madison’s Lullaby)

EAT ME (feat. Royal & The Serpent) vs. The Art Of Starting Over

HOLY **** vs. Lonely People

29 vs. The Way You Don’t Look At Me

HAPPY ENDING vs. Melon Cake

HEAVEN vs. Met Him Last Night (feat. Ariana Grande)

CITY OF ANGELS vs. What Other People Say (with Sam Fischer)

BONES vs. Carefully

WASTED vs. The Kind Of Lover I Am

COME TOGETHER vs. Easy (with Noah Cyrus)

DEAD FRIENDS vs. 15 Minutes 

HELP ME (feat. Dead Sara) vs. My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend (feat. Saweetie)

FEED vs. California Sober

4 EVER 4 ME vs. Mad World

 

7///6

Tie: 3

DWTDTAOSO, Holy **** isn't my cup of tea. Met Him Last Night, Carefully, Dancing With The Devil, ICU, Easy and Butterfly are all amazing songs, if we erased half of the tracklist it would be an A+ album tbh. 

 

 

FREAK (feat. YUNGBLUD) vs. Anyone

SKIN OF MY TEETH vs. Dancing With The Devil

SUBSTANCE vs. ICU (Madison’s Lullaby)

EAT ME (feat. Royal & The Serpent) vs. The Art Of Starting Over 

HOLY **** vs. Lonely People

29 vs. The Way You Don’t Look At Me

HAPPY ENDING vs. Melon Cake

HEAVEN vs. Met Him Last Night (feat. Ariana Grande)

CITY OF ANGELS vs. What Other People Say (with Sam Fischer)

BONES vs. Carefully

WASTED vs. The Kind Of Lover I Am

COME TOGETHER vs. Easy (with Noah Cyrus) 

DEAD FRIENDS vs. 15 Minutes 

HELP ME (feat. Dead Sara) vs. My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend (feat. Saweetie)

FEED vs. California Sober

4 EVER 4 ME vs. Mad World

 

Holy - 11

Dancing - 4

Tie - 1

FREAK (feat. YUNGBLUD) vs. Anyone

SKIN OF MY TEETH vs. Dancing With The Devil

SUBSTANCE vs. ICU (Madison’s Lullaby)

EAT ME (feat. Royal & The Serpent) vs. The Art Of Starting Over

HOLY **** vs. Lonely People

29 vs. The Way You Don’t Look At Me

HAPPY ENDING vs. Melon Cake

HEAVEN vs. Met Him Last Night (feat. Ariana Grande)

CITY OF ANGELS vs. What Other People Say (with Sam Fischer)

BONES vs. Carefully

WASTED vs. The Kind Of Lover I Am

COME TOGETHER vs. Easy (with Noah Cyrus)

DEAD FRIENDS vs. 15 Minutes 

HELP ME (feat. Dead Sara) vs. My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend (feat. Saweetie)

FEED vs. California Sober

4 EVER 4 ME vs. Mad World

 

Might be the fact that HF is new but it washes DWTD  

 

Edit: The Way You Don't Look At Me is better than almost every song on HF though

Edited August 19, 20224 yr by josesuxx

FREAK (feat. YUNGBLUD) vs. Anyone

SKIN OF MY TEETH vs. Dancing With The Devil

SUBSTANCE vs. ICU (Madison’s Lullaby)

EAT ME (feat. Royal & The Serpent) vs. The Art Of Starting Over

HOLY **** vs. Lonely People

29 vs. The Way You Don’t Look At Me

HAPPY ENDING vs. Melon Cake

HEAVEN vs. Met Him Last Night (feat. Ariana Grande)

CITY OF ANGELS vs. What Other People Say (with Sam Fischer) (both were trash)

BONES vs. Carefully

WASTED vs. The Kind Of Lover I Am

COME TOGETHER vs. Easy (with Noah Cyrus)

DEAD FRIENDS vs. 15 Minutes 

HELP ME (feat. Dead Sara) vs. My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend (feat. Saweetie)

FEED vs. California Sober

4 EVER 4 ME vs. Mad World

 

To be fair, Good Place wasn't in this ranking & that was 1 of my favs. I also liked bonuses like Change You. But overall, HF >>>>

FREAK (feat. YUNGBLUD) vs. Anyone

SKIN OF MY TEETH vs. Dancing With The Devil

SUBSTANCE vs. ICU (Madison’s Lullaby)

EAT ME (feat. Royal & The Serpent) vs. The Art Of Starting Over

HOLY **** vs. Lonely People

29 vs. The Way You Don’t Look At Me

HAPPY ENDING vs. Melon Cake

HEAVEN vs. Met Him Last Night (feat. Ariana Grande)

CITY OF ANGELS vs. What Other People Say (with Sam Fischer)

BONES vs. Carefully

WASTED vs. The Kind Of Lover I Am

COME TOGETHER vs. Easy (with Noah Cyrus)

DEAD FRIENDS vs. 15 Minutes 

HELP ME (feat. Dead Sara) vs. My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend (feat. Saweetie)

FEED vs. California Sober

4 EVER 4 ME vs. Mad World

Freak vs. Anyone

Skin of My Teeth vs. Dancing With The Devil

Substance vs. ICU (Madison’s Lullaby)

Eat Me vs. The Art Of Starting Over

Holy F*** vs. Lonely People

29 vs. The Way You Don’t Look At Me

Happy Ending vs. Melon Cake

Heaven vs. Met Him Last Night

City of Angels vs. What Other People Say

Bones vs. Carefully

Wasted vs. The Kind of Lover I Am (that hurt)

Come Together vs. Easy

Dead Friends vs. 15 Minutes 

Help Me vs. My Girlfriends Are My Boyfriend (feat. Saweetie)

Feed vs. California Sober

4 Ever 4 Me vs. Mad World

 

Holy: 10

DWTD: 6

 

Closer than I thought it would be but well, they’re both in her trinity of best albums