30 minutes ago, Taeyong said:

@private radio 

>\*]€|>|! omg

still iconic tbh

 

 

Is there a reason Loona didn't do Blue Moon (Hyolyn x Changmo)? One of them suggested it and it was a hit on the charts. It fits their "lunar" theme too.
 

To add to what everyone has said about the Shake It performance, Shake It is a very vocal forward song. The vocals and bouncy melody in the verses drive the song so breaking that up so much with skits and "acting" plus not really having someone capable of belting that last phase to give the song that added burst of energy and dynamics just made for a really flat, boring performance.

 

Blue Moon is one of Hyolyn's least vocally challenging songs tho I get it's probably still a reach for these girls. Also, it's a chill bop ala Loona's Butterfly. I think they could have done so much more with it and much naturally.

 

Last thing, I'm reading some translated articles from the original 2nd round recording and apparently someone from WJSN's voice cracked harsh in Navillera and Minyoung's voice cracked on her high note round one but Mnet cleaned it up for them. Yet Hyolyn's vocals seem pretty raw even when she is doing somersaults in the air. Is this the only way to bridge the gap? 

3 hours ago, Mr. Blue_Shirt said:

Brave Girls reaching their career highlight with this bop i could not believe it 

 

 

Oh it has the same sample as Fly from Momoland.

 

 

LOONA should have chosen a less vocally challenge SISTAR song like Alone or So Cool 

 

 

Like they could easily pull sth like this with Alone

35 minutes ago, Comedor said:

still iconic tbh

 

 

Not because they served SOTY but the audience said no talent doesn’t always win 

 

The way Korea let this song flop  

 

 

100M incoming  

 

-

 

Also I just realized how absurd it is to consider GIDLE 4th gen. They debuted in 2018, only 4 years after MAMAMOO/Red Velvet.

 

3rd gen essentially started in around 2013/2014 and yall are saying a group who debuted 4-5 years after is already a new gen?

 

2nd gen started in 2006/2007 but SISTAR/Apink etc. are not considered 3rd gen  

 

Peak of 3rd gen is 2017-2018 with RV, BP, TWICE, MAMAMOO, GFriend, Momoland, etc. all snatching big hits. How is that the start of a new gen??????

 

People going to be screaming 15th gen in 2025 at this rate  

Edited April 16, 20224 yr by Gaia

5 hours ago, Mr. Blue_Shirt said:

Brave Girls reaching their career highlight with this bop i could not believe it 

 

 

finally someone talking about this song!!! they really did THAT 

also the loona hate is unacceptable. their stage was so much fun, if you hate fun just say that instead 

2 hours ago, AbsynthPop said:

Is there a reason Loona didn't do Blue Moon (Hyolyn x Changmo)? One of them suggested it and it was a hit on the charts. It fits their "lunar" theme too.
 

To add to what everyone has said about the Shake It performance, Shake It is a very vocal forward song. The vocals and bouncy melody in the verses drive the song so breaking that up so much with skits and "acting" plus not really having someone capable of belting that last phase to give the song that added burst of energy and dynamics just made for a really flat, boring performance.

 

Blue Moon is one of Hyolyn's least vocally challenging songs tho I get it's probably still a reach for these girls. Also, it's a chill bop ala Loona's Butterfly. I think they could have done so much more with it and much naturally.

 

Last thing, I'm reading some translated articles from the original 2nd round recording and apparently someone from WJSN's voice cracked harsh in Navillera and Minyoung's voice cracked on her high note round one but Mnet cleaned it up for them. Yet Hyolyn's vocals seem pretty raw even when she is doing somersaults in the air. Is this the only way to bridge the gap? 

Soobin voice carcked in the second Navillera, which is funny because the online community seems to care way more than the audience that was in the actual venue because most of the present audience were praising Brave Girls performance, while the online community was trashing Minyoung for her voice crack. 

But we also have in perspective that Minyoung was literally coughing her lungs out right before and right after the performance as she was still having effects of covid for her breathing.

37 minutes ago, Gaia said:

 

The way Korea let this song flop  

Wait what I thought this smashed?

1 minute ago, AxelFox said:

Wait what I thought this smashed?

It did better in Japan as a Korean song than it did in Korea  

3 minutes ago, Gaia said:

It did better in Japan as a Korean song than it did in Korea  

Japan could not get enough of them ugh 

 

Mister started smashing in Japan first also if I'm not mistaken

 

But yeah I though Pandora was one of their biggest hits nnnn, maybe it's rose colored galsses cause it's one of my favorites lol

1 minute ago, AxelFox said:

Japan could not get enough of them ugh 

 

Mister started smashing in Japan first also if I'm not mistaken

 

But yeah I though Pandora was one of their biggest hits nnnn, maybe it's rose colored galsses cause it's one of my favorites lol

Surprisingly it’s essentially the start of their decline despite being one of their best tracks. Their last real hit was STEP in Korea.

46 minutes ago, Meteora said:

also the loona hate is unacceptable. their stage was so much fun, if you hate fun just say that instead 

The loona lashings here isn’t even comparable to when loona dropped PTT  

4 hours ago, Lalisa said:

 

No one is better at attending an event like Jennie Kim. The blueprint!

I swear Jaden put cracks in Loona's Butterfly or something, years later and i'm still addicted to the song, also their choreo, one of the best 4th gen kpop comeback ever

1 hour ago, Meteora said:

also the loona hate is unacceptable. their stage was so much fun, if you hate fun just say that instead 

yeah very odd behavior.

 

praising brave girls for making mask a totally different song but trashing loona for not going the bimbo route like the original shake it... make it make sense 

 

-----

 

perched for kelpers performance next week.

 

Spoiler

the leaks looked sooooo fun and ****** falling off the stage will be a kii. i know the edit will be hilarious 

 

Edited April 16, 20224 yr by Antunes

Teaching the youth about BIGBANG and leading them down the right path 

 

 

 

Does this thread know what a bimbo actually is  

People aren't criticizing how Loona "didn't go down the bimbo route" for Shake It, people are criticizing how the performance felt like a mediocre High School production of Grease and how it didn't show any of Loona's capabilities as a group, how the most entertaining parts of the performance were the gimmicks and how they failed to make the song their own. Trust  

50 minutes ago, Dialamba said:

The loona lashings here isn’t even comparable to when loona dropped PTT  

Wait PTT is amazing people here hate it?