2 minutes ago, AlexStexaul said:

yes its so bad. they use intro instrumental over the song as well. it is so bad. 

its a miracle it even went Top15 on pop radio 

 

never again i hope!

 

and her vocals doesnt fit in streaming era. 

she should keep screaming for live performances not studio versions. 

 

 

There's nothing wrong with it though. It's a 5 second intro literally who cares. 

 

And her vocals are fine on Chromatica. What are you even going on about. She sounds good across the entire album, and her voice is especially great on Stupid Love and ROM. 

 

Like her vocals here are no different than they were on Bad Romance. But whatever you say

ARTPOP falls apart after the first few songs tbh. 

Just now, luckythisway said:

I Wanna Be With You is an Adele wannabe song that sonically had no business being on ARTPOP. Maybe if it had Dope’s production, but the comedown of Dope following the high of MJH is one of the best moments on the album. I mean it’s Rick Rubin for crying out loud, he’s a legend. Gar should work with him for LG7 

 

Ugh I've always wanted more of Rick Rubin. He should've produced Joanne tbh. 

47 minutes ago, TheFameMonster said:

Obviously. SC would've been THEE girlboss summer 2020 anothem

Interscope HATES Godga

Just now, luckythisway said:

I Wanna Be With You is an Adele wannabe song that sonically had no business being on ARTPOP. Maybe if it had Dope’s production, but the comedown of Dope following the high of MJH is one of the best moments on the album. I mean it’s Rick Rubin for crying out loud, he’s a legend. Gar should work with him for LG7 

 

I was talking about vocals/delivery, this why I edited/highlighted the outsold part.

 

---

 

ARTUW and Love Me Right are her best studio vocals in years.

 

 

 

 

Are we back to rating?

 

4 hours ago, SOSOxoxo said:

Stupid Love is actually a bop, it's just NOT LEAD SINGLE material 

I have said for a long time that if Stupid Love had remained an album track liddos would stan it and say Gaga is insane for not making it a single

2 hours ago, DoctorIce said:

ARUTW is her biggest solo hit in over a decade, she would be tripping not to include it in the setlist.

 

This "but she wrote if for Ally!" narrative makes no sense given that she often performs covers of songs by other artists at her shows anyway, meanwhile she literally wrote ARUTW herself.  It's just a straightforward and universal love song without any overt references to the characters or film and it makes perfect sense on its own without context. 

 

There is no good reason to exclude it.

That’s a cute lil explanation. You’re forgetting one thing - she had PLENTY of occassions to perform ASIB songs, yet she didn’t. There’s more - she’s constantly performing those other covers whenever she’s having a gig and surprise surprise, no mention of ASIB whatsoever. Therefore your whole point is invalid.

 

It makes perfect sense not to perform those songs and she proved it again and again ever since 2018. 
 

Don’t get me wrong - I agree with what you’ve said, ARUTW is def one of her best ballads but again, her approach to this music, is a clear indication she closed this chapter

long time ago.

 

However, I am willing to wait until the tour and see how this will play out. I do wonder if she will maybe sing at least some lines of ARUTW in Paris, since France was def the biggest market for this soundtrack out of the countries in which she’s about to perform. 

Edited April 15, 20224 yr by DonnieDarko

31 minutes ago, The Witch said:

dark popGa been long gone ever since she started dating basic "good guys" tbh. A*sholes like Luc Carl were the ones that inspired those type of bops

 

sad but true

1 hour ago, WildAmerican said:

Diamond Heart is the best song on Joanna (by far ) why?

Sinner's Prayer says hi. 

Welcome back to the base @IronFist1994. 

18 minutes ago, charot said:

I was talking about vocals/delivery, this why I edited/highlighted the outsold part.

I see your point. But Dope as a whole is still better 

 

 

22 minutes ago, nick4bty said:

Ugh I've always wanted more of Rick Rubin. He should've produced Joanne tbh. 

Yeah she needs to work with him again. On another note, Joanne top 3 remains Perfect Illusion, Diamond Heart, and Sinner’s Prayer 

 

1 minute ago, PlERRE said:

Welcome back to the base @IronFist1994. 

screaming at them changing their avi again

22 minutes ago, Universo said:

Interscope HATES Godga

Billie has been sabotaging Gaga behind the scenes. Payback for Gaga's sabotaging of Natalia Kills.

The Cure is literally her most radio friendly song. Is it crack?

9 minutes ago, Universo said:

screaming at them changing their avi again

 

the Kristen Stewart one had me dying, ngl

26 minutes ago, Universo said:

Interscope HATES Godga

Godga's useless team HATES godga

 

36 minutes ago, Almodusa said:

Paparazzi should’ve been submitted/nominated/won Best Female Pop Vocal Performance in 2010 

 

Omg! How can we overlook this? This was a huge miss. I always thought she put poker face as a submission... Even that song is better than hot N cold and you belong with me nominations.

This hits differently and at all the right spots   bless the creator and bless Godga!

 

 

The Cure & Heal Me still sound fresh af!  I love these dreamy-silly R&B bops 

Now seriously Perfec Illusion House version for the tour would be such a slay, i need at least two Joanne songs to be included 

8 minutes ago, Hot Volcano said:

 

the Kristen Stewart one had me dying, ngl

The fact that Glenn Close lost the Oscar in the end, and KStew didn’t win a single major award. The OGHs keep jinxing actresses. 

Spotify update / 14.04

 

 

Total 13.679.387.875 (+7.352.081) / +211k more than last Thursday

 

Monthly Listeners 38,628,642 (+105,993)

 

Applause - 330.700.072 (+156.704)

Judas - 187.361.561 (+181.601) / biggest 2022 update

Love Game - 165.481.588 (+191.343)

Paparazzi - 299.037.252 (+229.766)

Million Reasons - 611.537.354 (+260.352)

Telephone - 425.167.903 (+268.430)

Born This Way - 383.261.735 (+270.517)

Rain On Me - 783.659.811 (+469.948) / +12k more than last week

Always Remember Us This Way - 752.710.117 (+490.240)

Just Dance - 535.695.391 (+506.173) / +27k more than last week

Bad Romance - 718.139.690 (+534.459)

Poker Face - 688.681.316 (+558.331) 

Shallow - 1.772.626.118 (+799.139) / +26k more than last week

 

A Star Is Born - 4.197.453.509 (+1.820.897)

The Fame - 1.995.694.493 (+1.606.075)

The Fame Monster - 1.633.393.510 (+1.049.974)

Chromatica - 1.954.873.762 (+1.007.366)

Born This Way - 1.260.883.470 (+818.747) / biggest 2022 update

Joanne - 1.352.110.448 (+417.389)

ARTPOP - 758.328.980 (+329.843)

Dawn of Chromatica - 62.210.598 (+103.899)

Love For Sale  - 27.568.700 (+55.025)

Cheek to Cheek - 135.630.877 (+45.208)

 

 

Tomorrow update is gonna be REALLY good. Get ready!

 

Thanks to users Gagacharts and Fame Romance, from forum popa911, for the data!

Edited April 15, 20224 yr by Artur

BTW doing 1M daily would be such a dream. It's been getting bigger every year, but still a long way to go without any viral songs.

 

18 minutes ago, DonnieDarko said:

That’s a cute lil explanation. You’re forgetting one thing - she had PLENTY of occassions to perform ASIB songs, yet she didn’t. There’s more - she’s constantly performing those other covers whenever she’s having a gig and surprise surprise, no mention of ASIB whatsoever. Therefore your whole point is invalid.

 

It makes perfect sense not to perform those songs and she proved it again and again ever since 2018. 
 

Don’t get me wrong - I agree with what you’ve said, ARUTW is def one of her best ballads but again, her approach to this music, is a clear indication she closed this chapter

long time ago.

 

However, I am willing to wait until the tour and see how this will play out. I do wonder if she will maybe sing at least some lines of ARUTW in Paris, since France was def the biggest market for this soundtrack out of the countries in which she’s about to perform. 

Love ya but DonnieDarkondescending strikes again.  

 

She may have had occasion to but she had no reason to perform album tracks from the OST back in 2018/2019. The focus was on the movie and Shallow which was the single and the awards candidate.

 

It's now 2022, four years after its release and as I said ARUTW has become her biggest solo hit in over a decade. Correct me if I'm wrong but isn't it currently out streaming every song from Chromatica?  No one wants the tour to be a balladfest, but replacing Yoü And I/MR/Speechless with Shallow/ARUTW which are both more recent, well know and successful than the latter is logical.

 

You still haven't adequately explained with it makes "perfect sense" for her to continue disregarding it. "Because she's ignored it so far" is not a reason.