Every time I open this base there’s a Stupid Love debate. Everyone just needs to accept it is her worst single ever and wasted all the ASIB momentum and didn’t introduce the Chromatica era at all given the mood board was for house music.

 

Hope this clears it up.

15 minutes ago, kwek_kwek said:

what’s this? Will she be producer and actor for this film? 

Is it a mistranslation? Her buying the rights? That is strange.

But a comedy drama?? Queen of expanding her acting skills.

 

Just now, AidanUnderYou said:

Every time I open this base there’s a Stupid Love debate. Everyone just needs to accept it is her worst single ever and wasted all the ASIB momentum and didn’t introduce the Chromatica era at all given the mood board was for house music.

 

Hope this clears it up.

There was no "ASIB" momentum. You guys just make this narrative up. Nobody who loves ASIB was clamoring for new Gaga music.  Her overall stature in the industry was boosted which is what helped her. The only thing that will help or or helps any popstar, is good music that connects with people.

Edited January 24, 20242 yr by Sannie

Perfect Illusion made me physically cringe when I first heard it, unlike Stupid Love.

Stupid Love > Perfect Illusion me thinks. 

1 minute ago, Album Leak said:

Perfect Illusion made me physically cringe when I first heard it, unlike Stupid Love.

Stupid Love > Perfect Illusion me thinks. 

ou- that's not-

Stupid Love could be a good song if the weird baby noises were removed from the production and the chorus was completely replaced (with a real chorus).  The verses and pre chorus actually sound great 

Stupid Love is pop perfection and you guys will accept it in 10 years, when gaga only releases jazz covers

And if I said that the best version of Stupid Love is the Riverdale Cast version...

 

11 minutes ago, Album Leak said:

Perfect Illusion made me physically cringe when I first heard it, unlike Stupid Love.

Stupid Love > Perfect Illusion me thinks. 

Your guessing game is weak, way too false to be right 

Perfect Illusion's production is godly, but the vocals and chorus were a letdown.

 

Stupid Love's pre-chorus is godly, but the production and lack of a chorus were a letdown. 

 

Maybe she'll learn and give us a lead with a PI-level instrumental, SL-level pre-chorus, and the type of lyrically and melodically strong chorus that she's absolutely nailed so many times 

Spoiler

Or she'll give us a lead with noisy production and no good pre-chorus or chorus that's Dope vocal'd to high hell. And to add insult to injury, there will be at least three other songs on the album that would've smashed as the lead had she picked them instead 

 

 

“All I ever wanted was love” is a highlight of the album tbf 

 

The rest of the song…is not!

Also based on the (Bad Romance) -> Perfect Illusion -> Stupid Love nomenclature pattern, I can't wait for Idiotic Affection to be released next month 

2 minutes ago, Bamboo said:

Reckless Devotion is coming 

Wait this would actually EAT  especially since the only results for Reckless Devotion I saw when I looked the phrase up was a book written by some white savior missionary lady, so Gar please release this dark electro-rock bop we're begging you  

7 minutes ago, Aston Martin said:

Also based on the (Bad Romance) -> Perfect Illusion -> Stupid Love nomenclature pattern, I can't wait for Idiotic Affection to be released next month 

this made me think that Applause is the lead with the best theme, followed by BTW of course.

I remember the line "I overheard your theory nostalgia's for geeks, I guess sir if you say so some of us just like to read" and the lyrical content in general being deemed as pretentious back then but critics would praise it to the heavens for its campiness if it were released now hihi 

3 minutes ago, hypocrateen said:

this made me think that Applause is the lead with the best theme, followed by BTW of course.

I remember the line "I overheard your theory nostalgia's for geeks, I guess sir if you say so some of us just like to read" and the lyrical content in general being deemed as pretentious back then but critics would praise it to the heavens for its campiness if it were released now hihi 

The way she sent a song about wanting to be applauded to #4 with over 5 million units in the US is iconic TBH. And that song is an example of a godly chorus, pre-chorus, bridge, and production overall.  

Applause is her best lead single. Somehow it's still sounds fresh despite being early 2010s EDM. 

40 minutes ago, Aston Martin said:

Also based on the (Bad Romance) -> Perfect Illusion -> Stupid Love nomenclature pattern, I can't wait for Idiotic Affection to be released next month 

The way Gaga has so many songs with this title format tho.. 

1 hour ago, Album Leak said:

Perfect Illusion made me physically cringe when I first heard it, unlike Stupid Love.

Stupid Love > Perfect Illusion me thinks. 

Not to be overdramatic but I will never forget the feeling of disappointment I had after hearing Perfect Illusion the first time. She had never disappointed me until then (except for when she canceled things she promised, but anything she released was always top tier in my opinion), and the fact that PI was her supposed "comeback" single... it was awful. 

 

I've seen the light since somewhat, and I do enjoy it every now and then. But what a fumble when she needed a win most after ARTPOP.

 

also the fact that Gaga, Ronson, AND Tame Impala - three literal music geniuses - united on it and that was what they came up with... a crime.  

Edited January 24, 20242 yr by HeavyMetalAura

 

It's gonna get a new all-tme peak in a few weeks, maybe even days

 

 

Valentine's day classic

3 minutes ago, HeavyMetalAura said:

Not to be overdramatic but I will never forget the feeling of disappointment I had after hearing Perfect Illusion the first time. She had never disappointed me until then (except for when she canceled things she promised, but anything she released was always top tier in my opinion), and the fact that PI was her supposed "comeback" single... it was awful. 

 

I've seen the light since somewhat, and I do enjoy it every now and then. But what a fumble when she needed a win most after ARTPOP.

 

also the fact that Gaga, Ronson, AND Tame Impala - three literal music geniuses - united on it and that was what they came up with... a crime.  

They CAME up with one of Gaga's BEST songs of all time, probably top 3

Just now, Miracle said:

They CAME up with one of Gaga's BEST songs of all time, probably top 3

Many critics, fans, and members of the general public disagree 

9 minutes ago, HeavyMetalAura said:

also the fact that Gaga, Ronson, AND Tame Impala - three literal music geniuses - united on it and that was what they came up with... a crime.  

How can you listen to THIS and call it a crime? 

 

 

1 hour ago, kwek_kwek said:

what’s this? Will she be producer and actor for this film? 

 

1 hour ago, Bojana said:

oh? @Leptine thoughts? 

They say Gaga has been enthusiast about this Italian movie that had big success here in Italy in the past months and that she is interested in buying the rights to make an American version, however they say it's just rumors for now, the source is an italian site of movies not Repubblica that is reporting it.

 

There's no mention about her role in this, like if she will act on it or producing.

 

Personally I'm not sure if this is a good idea, nowadays American remake of foreign movies are pointless considering how people are getting used to watch with subtitles and the original versions remain always better than remake, this movie specifically is about the italian cultural-socio-economic situation specifically of women past second war.

 

Sure it would be interesting doing a period drama for Gaga as next movie but it shouldn't be a remake of a foreign movie imo.

 

the Perfect Illusion instrumental is so ******* good she did lowkey ruin it

Edited January 24, 20242 yr by sunbathinganimal

Just now, Leptine said:

 

They say Gaga has been enthusiast about this Italian movie that had big success here in Italy in the past months and that she is interested in buying the rights to make an American version, however they say it's just rumors for now, the source is an italian site of movies not Repubblica that is reporting it.

 

There's no mention about her role in this, like if she will act on it or producing.

 

Personally I'm not sure if this is a good idea, nowadays American remake of foreign movies are pointless considering how people are getting used to watch with subtitles and the original versions remain always better than remake, this movie specifically is about the italian cultural-socio-economic situation specifically of women past second war.

 

Sure it would be interesting doing a period drama for Gaga as next movie but it shouldn't be a remake of a foreign movie imo.

 

Let me add, it's like doing an American remake of 'Parasite', for me it wouldn't make sense and it wouldn't be the same, since for that movie is fundamental their cultural and socio-economic setting.