16 minutes ago, aesthetic bih said:

The lyrics made national news back then. Ugh, she was SO CONTROVERSIAL AND I LOVED IT

That’s our GaGa. Fearless. 

7 hours ago, Almodusa said:

I’m really gonna hear Shallow live in August

 

girl same 

 

in a stadium no less 

 

2 hours ago, Monster Megamind said:

GAGA  MUST perform at least 3 songs from ASIB especially always remember us this way in the Tour... I know that I'll never love again could be a difficult and draining song live so it can be left out, but she should definitely perform look what I found at least.

she has to! we have to get the next Jizz&Piano crowd to chant Always Remember Us This Way! inb4 she doesn't even know how much of a smash it is lolk

11 years since Jewdust derailed Gar’s career. It’s a banger but it’s release as a single was one of the worst decisions she ever made

 

she really ******* ATE last night Cant believe we were watching a livestream by a BTS fan of all people

 

 

1 hour ago, Mariano said:

Yeah if GodGa skips ARUTW, she deserves to get canceled tbh! I understand her not performing it at Enigma/Jazz etc. but at this point she has to be aware that ARUTW is a classique of hers and people DEMAND it!

 

 

she should perform her spotify top 10 + SC/911/FW/Alice.. these are the most commerical GP'd tracks. GP want SHALLAH. GP Want ARUGODTW. GP want MGODR.

 

15 minutes ago, State of Grace. said:

she really ******* ATE last night Cant believe we were watching a livestream by a BTS fan of all people

 

 

Wow she sang 4 pop songs in her Jazz show 

It would really DUMB not to perform ARUTW when its constantly perched in her Top 5 most streamed songs daily  

 

I'm not setting myself up and I can totally see her doing only Shallow from ASIB, but yeah

1 minute ago, State of Grace. said:

It would really DUMB not to perform ARUTW when its constantly perched in her Top 5 most streamed songs daily  

 

I'm not setting myself up and I can totally see her doing only Shallow from ASIB, but yeah

I'm going to riot if she doesn't perform her best ballad 

3 minutes ago, Monster Megamind said:

Wow she sang 4 pop songs in her Jazz show 

nnn yes sis she's been doing that for years

7 minutes ago, State of Grace. said:

It would really DUMB not to perform ARUTW when its constantly perched in her Top 5 most streamed songs daily  

 

I'm not setting myself up and I can totally see her doing only Shallow from ASIB, but yeah

A valid explanation provided by the iconique TheFameMonster below

47 minutes ago, TheFameMonster said:

She has a whole unperformed album to do, plus the hits, plus a fan fave or two, what makes you think she will do music that she doesnt even claim as hers?

 

12 minutes ago, Mr. Stratus said:

she should perform her spotify top 10 + SC/911/FW/Alice.. these are the most commerical GP'd tracks. GP want SHALLAH. GP Want ARUGODTW. GP want MGODR.

 

Enough. She needs to perform the whole Chromatica album plus Shallow and some fan faves. We don’t care about what the gp wants, nor does she. Why do you care? Lmao.

Edited April 15, 20224 yr by DonnieDarko

Does any one feel a boiling rage when you realize Replay could've been a huge first single....instead of stupid love 

12 minutes ago, DonnieDarko said:

A valid explanation provided by the iconique TheFameMonster below

 

The underperformed album is only 13 tracks though  and watch her skip a song or two (1000 Pigeons & Fun Tonight you in danger girls). Add the old hits (Bad Romance, Shallow, Just Dance, Alejandro, Poker Face, Born This Way, Paparazzi, Telephone, LoveGame, Applause) and she still has enough space for 1-3 fan faves. The ballad section can have Shallow/ARUTW/Million Reasons for example.

 

Tours aren't Little Monster shows after all. She can manage satisfying both her fanbase and the GP. Also, ARUTW is both a fan favorite AND a GP smasha.

Edited April 15, 20224 yr by State of Grace.

For the chromatica ball my chosen songs would be 

Rain on me, stupid love, Alice, 911, replay, free woman, plastic doll remix, sine from above, babylon, sour candy, 

Shallow, ARUTW, Look what I found / is that alright, why did you do that 

Bad romance, Just dance Indian remix, poker face, I like it rough, monster, paparazzi, 

You & I, EOG, GUY, Joanne Piano version, Manicure, Americano (instead of Alejandro)

2 minutes ago, State of Grace. said:

The underperformed album is only 13 tracks though  and watch her skip a song or two (1000 Pigeons & Fun Tonight you in danger girls). Add the old hits (Bad Romance, Shallow, Just Dance, Alejandro, Poker Face, Born This Way, Paparazzi, Telephone, LoveGame, Applause) and she still has enough space for 1-3 fan faves. The ballad section can have Shallow/ARUTW/Million Reasons for example.

 

Tours aren't Little Monster shows after all. She can manage satisfying both her fanbase and the GP. Also, ARUTW is both a fan favorite AND a GP smasha.

Oh I know and I agree tho it’s clear ASIB is not regarded by her as a Lady Gaga album and her treatment of those songs minus Shallow clearly shows that the chances of her performing those songs are slim to none.
 

After all, those songs were written for a character she played in the movie and not for a Lady Gaga project and I totally get why she’s not performing them, I moved on from this years ago. 
 

 

Judas was the right thing for Gaga at the time; it was the most on brand choice after Born This Way was the perceived risk. It had that rah rah energy that turned her to a superstar in the first place. It was literally built as a single.

 

The problem was the Easter religious  controversy was not the helpful kind after an already controversial lead — it was the kind that leads to radio dropping you like a hot potato and people switching off, and Gaga was at peak exposure, so there weren’t much that could be done except keeping the foot firmly down on the promotional peddle. Then The Edge of Glory as a droplet hit that GP sweet spot and took off sooner than than the label expected, so tactics were changed and they moved on without Gaga even knowing and being in the middle of the promotional run.
 

That whole era really was 100mph holding on for dear life as a stan. And despite all that Judas was still the right call, the music video is her most viewed of the era, and it’s appreciated today for its nerve, its gall and its gumption. She didn’t have the next generation of artists stanning for no reason, and it’s **** like Judas heading up one of the buzziest pop albums of all time that did it. 
 

As an aside I think TEOG did what it needed to do and reached its max commercial success; Judas never happening wouldn’t have made it a #1. The big stadium torch songs had the best GP response; the ASIB seeds were already being sown. The image just needed to be changed to get there.

 

And now Hold My Hand is coming to (hopefully) carry on that legacy.

 

 

Just now, Jessie said:

Judas was the right thing for Gaga at the time; it was the most on brand choice after Born This Way was the perceived risk. It had that rah rah energy that turned her to a superstar in the first place. It was literally built as a single.

 

The problem was the Easter religious  controversy was not the helpful kind after an already controversial lead — it was the kind that leads to radio dropping you like a hot potato and people switching off, and Gaga was at peak exposure, so there weren’t much that could be done except keeping the foot firmly down on the promotional peddle. Then The Edge of Glory as a droplet hit that GP sweet spot and took off sooner than than the label expected, so tactics were changed and they moved on without Gaga even knowing and being in the middle of the promotional run.
 

That whole era really was 100mph holding on for dear life as a stan. And despite all that Judas was still the right call, the music video is her most viewed of the era, and it’s appreciated today for its nerve, its gall and its gumption. She didn’t have the next generation of artists stanning for no reason, and it’s **** like Judas heading up one of the buzziest pop albums of all time that did it. 
 

As an aside I think TEOG did what it needed to do and reached its max commercial success; Judas never happening wouldn’t have made it a #1. The big stadium torch songs had the best GP response; the ASIB seeds were already being sown. The image just needed to be changed to get there.

 

And now Hold My Hand is coming to (hopefully) carry on that legacy.

 

 

She should've opted for Scheibe instead...

4 minutes ago, DonnieDarko said:

Oh I know and I agree tho it’s clear ASIB is not regarded by her as a Lady Gaga album and her treatment of those songs minus Shallow clearly shows that the chances of her performing those songs are slim to none.
 

After all, those songs were written for a character she played in the movie and not for a Lady Gaga project and I totally get why she’s not performing them, I moved on from this years ago. 
 

 

I understand that yeah. It's just SAD because some of them are career highlights

1 minute ago, State of Grace. said:

I understand that yeah. It's just SAD because some of them are career highlights

Right. 

We need to start the ARUTW Campaign from now itself. We need to let Bobby know... My date will at the absolute end in San Francisco.... So lots of time to go.

the passion for her best song in here,

 

we should be stanning, one of the best songs of all time!

1 minute ago, WildAmerican said:

the passion for her best song in here,

 

we should be stanning, one of the best songs of all time!

Yup, Replay deserves all the love it’s gettin.

1 minute ago, DonnieDarko said:

Yup, Replay deserves all the love it’s gettin.

one of her best darhk bahps!

Just now, WildAmerican said:

one of her best darhk bahps!

We stan a versatile legend. ARUTW and Replay are truly masterpieces.

Just Dance / Poker Face / Paparazzi / LoveGame (can go tbh)

Bad Romance / Alejandro / Telephone (also can go)

Born This Way / The Edge of Glory (her best song but also can go )

Applause

Million Reasons

Shallow / ARUTW

 

These are the true essentials imo.  She really reached that point in her career where she has to let go of some hits. Or start doing mashups sis.

 

Wishlist includes: Marry the Night, Heavy Metal Lover, Venus