1 minute ago, anklebiterrs said:

Honestly don’t know what y’all are stanning if you think she’s a bad songwriter who “needs the guidance of a songwriter”. Is she in grade school? Does she need someone to hold her hand? Just unstan if you think can’t write a damn song herself tbh. 

Seeing people say that one of the best pop songwriters of all time "needs help with songwriting" is a ******* joke. Giving co-writers all the credit when they know damn well it is Gaga who's coming up with the melodies and lyrics, is pathetic. They can never give Gaga herself the credit.

 

1 minute ago, Giorgoc said:

A few thoughts:

 

There's something about the song that makes it not easy to remember for me. Are there too many different lyrics? Is it the melody? IDK.

The production (minus the horrible intro) is FLAWLESS.

Her vocals might just be the best they've ever been.

 

All in all, cute song. Not nearly as catchy as Shallow but that's fine. The fact that she's excited about her own music is enough for me to be happy for her. I hope this succeeds so the few people dragging her and the song will finally stop. This base gets more and more tiring by the day.

 

1 minute ago, Giorgoc said:

A few thoughts:

 

There's something about the song that makes it not easy to remember for me. Are there too many different lyrics? Is it the melody? IDK.

The production (minus the horrible intro) is FLAWLESS.

Her vocals might just be the best they've ever been.

 

All in all, cute song. Not nearly as catchy as Shallow but that's fine. The fact that she's excited about her own music is enough for me to be happy for her. I hope this succeeds so the few people dragging her and the song will finally stop. This base gets more and more tiring by the day.

It's just not catchy at all.. i also love the production and the vocals.. the melody is the weakest link 

The part which you guys seems to like, the post bridge hold my hand, my hand... Reminds of Hair from BTW( my hair, my hair), which was my least fave song from BTW...SO that's triggering me a lot ???

The intro reminds me back when we had to carry cd  players and when my mom would hit a bump in our mini van and the song would start skipping  

Many liddos admitted YESTERDAY they were underwhelmed by Shallow when they first heard it, now people trying to rewrite history to make themselves feel better I wish the old base still exists and I can find counteless drags about Shallow being boring

Edited May 3, 20224 yr by jijie101

1 minute ago, Sombre said:

Whether this fanbase adores it or loathes it, one thing that's for sure it that it will be critically acclaimed. 

 

the civil war in here, just make sure yall streaming the song 

 

dont serve like yall did with L4S, dragging it and being proud not listening to it then few months later boast about the grammy noms/wins

3 minutes ago, Monster Megamind said:

Of course this song is better than TIHTY.... But it kinda reminds me quality wise to Rise by Katy perry... Lots of words but a bland chorus...

I thought the same

2 minutes ago, Marry Illusion Glory said:

 

This fanbase not liking something means the GP will actually enjoy it. Let's wait for 2-3 more and then we should thread them to drown out that OGH'd Sl*nt one

i screamed at how fast they could come up with a new article  they're truly obsessed 

4 minutes ago, OreGuy said:

girl i was explaining that to someone saying the chorus has no melody

I knew that.  

2 minutes ago, Monster Megamind said:

The part which you guys seems to like, the post bridge hold my hand, my hand... Reminds of Hair from BTW( my hair, my hair), which was my least fave song from BTW...SO that's triggering me a lot ???

Wait a minute... I think you're onto something with the 'Hair' comparison. 'Hair' also pulls from big 80s stadium rock so this is a comparison that actually makes sense. And I love 'Hair' so maybe that's why this song has me.

At least we can all agree that the CHORUS is not memorable at all 

Just now, truthteller said:

i screamed at how fast they could come up with a new article  they're truly obsessed 

The Madonna fan clicked submit before any of us heard it sis asdfgh 

and about the Hair comparison, the first Hold My Hand belt during the last part sounded like "This is my praaaaaayerr" which is a slay

2 minutes ago, Cryptique said:

At least we can all agree that the CHORUS is not memorable at all 

Yeah I can agree with that. 

That said, I do have the song on repeat and I enjoy it quite a lot!

yeah its kinda right song is little forgettable, u cant remember its words or melody after listening to it

would fit as an album closer or track #13 

We all know that obsessed loser over at Sl*nt had the article typed AND reviewed AND approved since April 2020 when RideOrDie teased a Top Gun soundtrack single. 

3 minutes ago, OreGuy said:

and about the Hair comparison, the first Hold My Hand belt during the last part sounded like "This is my praaaaaayerr" which is a slay

Why did I not pick up on this. I have failed as a 'Hair' stan.

Most #1s on iTunes for OST songs by female pop artists in 2020’s

31 - Hold My Hand
23 - No Time to Die
15 - Beautiful Ghosts
0 - Just Look Up

In other news, Hair is perfect. What a song!

3 minutes ago, Bang Up said:

Why did I not pick up on this. I have failed as a 'Hair' stan.

it is soooo good one of the best parts of Hair

Edited May 3, 20224 yr by OreGuy

the more i listen the more it feels right 

maybe the successica stans of the liddos can get onboard now

 

Just now, Sugden said:

the more i listen the more it feels right 

It took me five listens to be like, "yeah, this is so good". 

 

------

 

There is no way y'all are trying to come for the lyrics, though? These lyrics are top notch?

 

My favorite thing is how she ends some of the verses with words that lead to the next. She's done that before but I can't remember the song. I find it very melodically pleasing.

 

Hold my hand, everything will be okay

I heard from the heavens that clouds have been grey

Pull me close, wrap me in your aching arms

I see that you're hurtin', why'd you take so long

 

To tell me you need me? I see that you're bleedin'

You don't need to show me again

But if you decide to, I'll ride in this life with you

I won't let go 'til the end

 

Raise your head, look into my wishful eyes

That fear that's inside you will lift, give it time

I can see everything you're blind to now

Your prayers will be answered, let God whisper how

 

I know you're scared and your pain is imperfect

But don't you give up on yourself

I've heard a story, a girl, she once told me

That I would be happy again

13 minutes ago, Monster Megamind said:

The part which you guys seems to like, the post bridge hold my hand, my hand... Reminds of Hair from BTW( my hair, my hair), which was my least fave song from BTW...SO that's triggering me a lot ???

That being said.... I did not like shallow initially as well. And I still feel ARUTW and I'll never love are better. But straights loved shallow because of the emotions attached to the movie. So may be after being charged up after seeing the enthralling ending of top gun, they could be swept up by the emotions of hold my hand. No wonder most of the movie critics were loving the song... So I expect this song to have an impact!

Did anyone try the House of Gucci? I thought the House of Gucci was lovely!