Working once again with Aaron Dessner, the songwriter sticks to her signature blend of bulletproof pop and melancholic indie folk, but the few risks she takes result in her best songs yet.

x

They previously only reviewed Good Riddance, which received the exact same score (6.2): x

Shop & TicketsATRL earns a commission on purchases made through these links.

Taylor Swift

Albums

I Knew It, I Knew You (From "Toy Story 5") - Single2026

I Knew It, I Knew You (From "Toy Story 5") - Single2026

reputation2017

Taylor Swift (Bonus Track Version)2006

Taylor Swift2006

More on Amazon

generouz

deserved 10

1 minute ago, Escape said:

Shop & TicketsATRL earns a commission on purchases made through these links.

Taylor Swift

Albums

I Knew It, I Knew You (From "Toy Story 5") - Single2026

I Knew It, I Knew You (From "Toy Story 5") - Single2026

reputation2017

Taylor Swift (Bonus Track Version)2006

Taylor Swift2006

More on Amazon

Not Taylor blocking the other girls even on the ATRL Amazon commission earner banner

should be 0.2

3 minutes ago, Escape said:

Shop & TicketsATRL earns a commission on purchases made through these links.

Taylor Swift

Albums

I Knew It, I Knew You (From "Toy Story 5") - Single2026

I Knew It, I Knew You (From "Toy Story 5") - Single2026

reputation2017

Taylor Swift (Bonus Track Version)2006

Taylor Swift2006

More on Amazon

Taydaughter from Hell

1 minute ago, B-Luke said:

Not Taylor blocking the other girls even on the ATRL Amazon commission earner banner

To be fair the ATRL Commission feature had Olivia Rodrigo on threads that had nothing to do with her on multiple occasions.

the lead single was good but the rest of the album fell flat for me bar a few songs. idk maybe it's a grower.

14 minutes ago, punisher said:

deserved 10

on a scale of 500

okay tbh Hit the Wall is a great song but Look At My Life is so bland. I feel like the concept of this entire album is so self indulgent. Like you come from the most privileged place imaginable. What about your existence is hell? What did you do to your mother that is so beyond out of control for it to be worth writing an entire album about. Thats what I wanna know.

Same score as Confessions on a dance floor I

Watch out Madonna, Gracie is here!

Crying. She's so unoriginal this thread thinks she's Taylor Swift

Edited July 17Jul 17 by LustSpell

Way too high

She's so painfully mediocre and boring. Money can't buy you taste

38 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

okay tbh Hit the Wall is a great song but Look At My Life is so bland. I feel like the concept of this entire album is so self indulgent. Like you come from the most privileged place imaginable. What about your existence is hell? What did you do to your mother that is so beyond out of control for it to be worth writing an entire album about. Thats what I wanna know.

You clearly don't know what the album is about if you think that's what the premise of Daughter from Hell is the album is meant for critical thinkers and avant-garde consumption

The singles I listened to weren't very interesting so not surprised. Hard to take innovative, creative risks when daddy's safety net is right there

It's good for an artist that ATRL loves to hate

Her singles so far 3/3

Her lyrics are ok, the melodies are cute, but the productions fall short.

And she needs vocal training asap cause her tone is atrocious

1 hour ago, punisher said:

deserved 1.0

You missed the period

can anyone explain why atrlers hate her? I haven't listened to the album yet

6 minutes ago, CameraFlashes said:

can anyone explain why atrlers hate her? I haven't listened to the album yet

Communism me thinks

7 minutes ago, CameraFlashes said:

can anyone explain why atrlers hate her? I haven't listened to the album yet

She's a nepo baby without talent that got shoot up to stardom randomly because of Taylor's blessing and daddy's money

The mot interesting and most acclaimed Taydaughter being the one she abandoned and left up for adoption

69 on Metacritics despite the obviously bought RS review