Who is the better performer?

Edited February 4Feb 4 by Parallel

they are both great and have different styles to offer

Tate

Tate commands the stage all to herself. She was classically and professionally trained as a dancer and a perfomer so this comparison is verryyyy unfair to Addison

Tate

Addison 100%. She has more charisma, stage presence and makes more facial expressions. Tate always has a blank face when performing 😐

Tate is a good dancer but feels like a PCD member with the label pushing to be a pop star. I do like a couple of Tate songs but they don't really stand out to me at all.

There styles of dancing is completely different btw.

Edited February 4Feb 4 by Plasticdoll

100% Tate. Addison doesn't seem to know what to do on the stage

Tate. She's got a crazy stage presence, seems confident and commands the stage. Addison is cute but you can tell she's just starting.

I high key can't stand that morgan wallen apologist and it's still tate. She's born to perform

None of them can sing, only Tate can dance

3 minutes ago, thatsmydemi said:

Tate. She's got a crazy stage presence, seems confident and commands the stage. Addison is cute but you can tell she's just starting.

Well yeah Tate is on her 5th album/era and has had about 4 tours!

idk how this thread is even a thing.. comparing a debut artist to someone who's been doing this for literal years.

Edited February 4Feb 4 by Plasticdoll

Tate by default since she can dance. Addison can't dance, sing and has the charisma of a brown paper bag.

Both are talented but i think Tate is a better performer.

At least tate can dance.

Neither can sing sadly

I truly love them both but if they had Potara earrings and fused into a beautiful pop girl with great taste that can dance but not really sing, they would be…

Tate was the most acclaimed performance of the VMAs

Addison is a CIA psyop to see how tasteless gays can be

Addison lacks stage presence, I think she needs to stop looking for inspiration in Britney because chasing after that type of performance is a mismatch.

Tate in comparison has perfect stage presence, fantastic choreo and alright vocals. She plays to her strengths unlike Addison. Let's face it, Addison is not a good dancer and keeps trying to pull off sex via a Britney choreo. NO!, she needs to focus on her visuals, vocals and be an entertainer. Hell, pull a Sabrina Carpenter and be theatrical.

Also, Fame is A Gun was horrible for a Grammy performance.

Edited February 4Feb 4 by Phaunzie

There is nothing good about Addison. Her album was praised by critics because of payola. The hype around her will die soon.

Tate.

Addison is a decent dancer but that's it. Tate is a more skilled dancer, even vocally where she's pretty average she's still better than Addison.

59 minutes ago, Cheers said:

There is nothing good about Addison. Her album was praised by critics because of payola. The hype around her will die soon.

Everything is payola for some of you when it doesn't fit your own narrative/opinion.

Tate McRae is currently the best performer we have right now. Both being heavily inspired by Spears though

Edited February 4Feb 4 by Erreur2 La Nature

1 hour ago, Phaunzie said:

Addison lacks stage presence, I think she needs to stop looking for inspiration in Britney because chasing after that type of performance is a mismatch.

Tate in comparison has perfect stage presence, fantastic choreo and alright vocals. She plays to her strengths unlike Addison. Let's face it, Addison is not a good dancer and keeps trying to pull off sex via a Britney choreo. NO!, she needs to focus on her visuals, vocals and be an entertainer. Hell, pull a Sabrina Carpenter and be theatrical.

Also, Fame is A Gun was horrible for a Grammy performance.

You talk like Tate doesn't try to be like britney herself.

Tate has the same mono tone voice in all her songs. mumbling/whispering.

I'm still waiting for a catchy pop banger from her. when?

1 minute ago, Plasticdoll said:

Everything is payola for some of you when it doesn't fit your own narrative/opinion.

😂 you'll see soon enough. This girl will not have lasting power.

10 minutes ago, Cheers said:

😂 you'll see soon enough. This girl will not have lasting power.

I've seen her live front row myself and I can tell you she will sis.

you're a Tate fan so ofc you'd say that.

We'll see.

Edited February 4Feb 4 by Plasticdoll