14 minutes ago, sunbathinganimal said:

interested to hear the 'Chromatica jockstraps were tacky' ATRLers thoughts on Madonna's Grindr exclusive vinyl and tags

The jockstraps were the only thing that era that felt well made.

Just now, Graves said:

The jockstraps were the only thing that era that felt well made.

like from California is incoming but just know you're wrong

17 minutes ago, Pop said:

One of those Gays - 5/10

Teenage dream - 4/10

Prism - 4/10

Witness - 2/10

Smile - 7/10

142 - 1/10

What a disastrous career run. No wonder she is so over.

You stan Smile ? taste

5 minutes ago, sunbathinganimal said:

spill though Honey is her best song

I was gonna agree until I realized there are ALLAH ALL, ALLAH ROOF, AlLAHDOWN so maybe not

AllahRiah and AllahFLY yeah ALLAG

Chromatica is genuinely an abysmal album tho. I wouldn't say it's as bad as 143 (because nothing is) but it does occupy the same genre of soulless, zero effort dance pop made by a creator who had no interest in their own product. It was a few years shy of getting AI accusations, but it really feels like it sometimes. **** like Plastic Doll and Fun Tonight reek of being algorithm-made Gaga songs. Assembly line pop. The jockstraps were the least egregious part of that era.

Anyway, yes Honey is a bop. One of her few.

2 minutes ago, Kh-Loud said:

ALLAH ALL, ALLAH ROOF, AlLAHDOWN so maybe not

AllahRiah and AllahFLY yeah ALLAG

Why does this sound like you're going through a schizophrenic episode sisjdhdn

But yes, let's stan The Allah Roof

Smile >>>>>>> Coronatica

there it is

Cosmetica > Confessions Of A Pink Friday II

Why y'all even bringing up Chromie again? I thought Mayhem existing meant y'all didn't have to pretend to like it anymore?

can't believe i'm nodding in agreement to Katy praise. oh Chromesstica

5 minutes ago, Florence Belch said:

Why does this sound like you're going through a schizophrenic episode sisjdhdn

But yes, let's stan The Allah Roof

Every time I feel the need
I envision you caressing me
And go back in time
To relieve the splendor of you and I
On the rooftop that rainy night

You'll never catching me hating on Sciatica as a whole because at least it has Alice, 911, Replay, 1000 Doves and Babylon on it

However, you'll catch me skulldragging Sour Nurtec because THATSTINK are on it

Just now, Florence Belch said:

1000 Doves

don't piss me off

1 minute ago, Florence Belch said:

You'll never catching me hating on Sciatica as a whole because at least it has Alice, 911, Replay, 1000 Doves and Babylon on it

However, you'll catch me skulldragging Sour Nurtec because THATSTINK are on it

exactly exactly

even Replay lowkey aged

what a terrible album. and era.

Just now, California said:

don't piss me off

Ballads turned into Eurofag bangers are my guiltiest pleasure, I'm sorry babe

the Sour Pxssy remix was good but i don't want to summon the remix artist's #1 hater so let's just leave it at that

objective Katy albums ranking

One of the Boys - 7/10

Teenage Dream - 9/10

PRISM - 10/10

Witness - 8/10

Smile - 7.5/10

143 - 6/10

Are we listening? @Graves @Eeveelution @California @Démodé

the object in "objective" being a ball of crack

Just now, KatyPrismSpirit said:

objective

Smile - 7.5/10

143 - 6/10

""objective""

Katy Perry albums ranked but I mute Spotify and start playing Slayyyter on YouTube in the background

I hate the random orchestral interludes on Chromatica.