'It's Not That Deep'

 

Metacritic: 82

 

Reviews:

 

AllMusic: 80/100

https://www.allmusic.com/album/its-not-that-deep-mw0004620975

PopMatters: 80/100

https://www.popmatters.com/demi-lovato-not-that-deep

RS: 80/100

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-album-reviews/demi-lovato-its-not-that-deep-review-1235452540/

The Line of Best Fit: 80/100

https://www.thelineofbestfit.com/albums/demi-lovato-its-not-that-deep-is-what-weve-been-waiting-for

The Independent: 80/100

https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/reviews/demi-lovato-review-its-not-that-deep-charli-b2850691.html

Clash Magazine: 70/100

https://www.clashmusic.com/reviews/demi-lovato-its-not-that-deep/

Slant Magazine: 70/100

https://www.slantmagazine.com/music/demi-lovato-its-not-that-deep-album-review/

Edited November 1, 2025Nov 1 by thatsmydemi

inch resting! look forward to checking it out 

31 minutes ago, thatsmydemi said:

First review is out, by RS, which gave it a 80/100. Their biggest score to a Demi album ever ().

 

 

Album out on Friday!

Cause this album will be critically acclaimed and will reinvent her image

 

  

I'm sure it'll fall between 70-85 like practically *every* pop release these days since critics don't really serve an actual purpose anymore lol.

 

Here All Night is very underrated though, so I'm tuning in and streaming her this time.

oh acclaimi

paid like Showgirl? 

 

but congrats

RS gives that score to literally every album (except LOASG which they gave 100)

 

 

but I'm excited!

didn't RS also give Taylor's latest album 5/5? 

 

I guess the cheque hit! 

2 hours ago, limelight elixir said:

paid like Showgirl? 

 

5 minutes ago, ThousandMiles said:

I guess the cheque hit! 

the way the album is not even out and y'all heard it already?? 

2 hours ago, Cain said:

RS gives that score to literally every album (except LOASG which they gave 100)

 

 

but I'm excited!

Everyone except Demi. This is the highest score they've ever given to any of her projects. 
 

It was always funny to read people saying this while stanning Demi because RS has panned most of her releases, and they didn't even bother with the rock album 

 

"It's Not That Deep" — 80.
"Confident" — 70.
"Here We Go Again" — 60.
"Demi" — 60.
"Tell Me You Love Me" — 60.
"Dancing With The Devil…" — 60.
"Unbroken" — 40.
 

we need mass acclaim demi 

From Rolling Stones who usually despise Demi, this is BIG!

 

and SAY IT sounds like a bop! Ghost will have me crying too. Demetria get my streams 

2 hours ago, Cain said:

RS gives that score to literally every album (except LOASG which they gave 100)

 

 

but I'm excited!

They hate Demi lol

 

Anyways this is good

Godmi  

3 hours ago, thatsmydemi said:

Demi" — 60.
"Tell Me You Love Me" — 60.

This is ruthless & so unacceptable. 

3 hours ago, Kern said:

the way the album is not even out and y'all heard it already?? 

Really like damn if they have it they should share with the class

They need to retroactively give HOLY **** an 100

Not yall saying Demi paid for an 80 score and not 100…though i kind of would believe it considering her other scores 

More reviews have been published!

 

The Independent: 80/100

The Line of Best Fit: 80/100

Slant: 70/100

 

 

 

I will update the thread later today! 

Debuts with 82 on metacritic

Great album one of the best albums of 2025 in mainstream music 

a slightly above average and derivative effort like this getting 80s metacritic just shows how sad it is when certain other high profile pop releases actually get some pans

 

70 from Clash  

Acclaimi <3