Would it have flopped or smashed?

I think she could have pulled it off.

 

 

Discuss 

Smash

I feel like it's very uniquely Kesha, hard to imagine someone else singing it

ATRL would (pretend to) hate it, but it could be a cute hit. 

Gaga wouldn't serve a song like this justice like Kesha could. I wish Gaga dropped a song like this tbh:

 

 

The song reminds me a little bit of the type of music Lady Gaga was making during TF(M). It's a bit extravagant, weird, all over the place… but it works.

I can totally imagine her voice on it and I would enjoy it as much as Kesha's version.

 

When it comes to commercial success, I feel like it could have been bigger than all of her « recent » solo singles. Could have been a cute hit. (A remix with gaga could be cute too).

Wasn't there a rumor that GàR was working on a polka album a few years ago? 

 

 

people have crazy standards for Lady Gaga, they wouldn't abide her doing something 'unserious' because she has cultivated an image of taking herself seriously for so long 

 

That's why her only chance at hits is making heterosexual music, the gays can't be trusted 

 

 

It would smash. It's already doing pretty well for Kesha standarts so with the huge exposure that a Gaga comeback brings I think it could've be a smash out of the gate. However I agree with users here that mentioned this being a very uniquely Kesha song. 

it would tank even harder 

1 minute ago, shyboi said:

it would tank even harder 

gaga releasing anything

hard to imagine these days

It would be one of the worst songs ever. 

I just can't imagine Gaga making something this fun and irreverent and GAY anymore, everything is about pain and trauma, not to mention about awards and being taken ~seriously. I wish though. 

20 minutes ago, Jay07 said:

I just can't imagine Gaga making something this fun and irreverent and GAY anymore, everything is about pain and trauma, not to mention about awards and being taken ~seriously. I wish though. 

Well that's exactly what Kesha's last three albums were mostly about too. Chromatica and Joanne had a couple of irreverent fun songs (Babylon comes to mind). But I get what you mean, hopefully  there's a wider variety of themes for her next era.

It depend on when it was released

As the secone single from artpop. It could work.

Now it makes no sense. She worked hard to be considered a serious artist to release this

I think the song is so intrinsically Kesha that I have a hard time imagining a solo Gaga version. However, a remix would be ******* dope tho 

it would sound horrible with her obnoxious nasal voice