Headstrong. But Never Stop beats a lot of Headstrong.

I can only remember of Headstrong singles while Dignity had awesome singles and awesome album tracks too like the title track, Gipsy Woman and this SMASH

 

 

Dignity and it's not close.

Both are pop masterpieces tbh. But Dignity ushered in a new era for Disney bred popstars imo.

 

Stranger (as an album opener was crazy)

Gypsy Woman

Never Stop

Outside of You

Danger

No Work, All Play 

 

So many gems.

Love Headstrong, but Dignity is on another level.

Dignity is pop perfection and should be respected as such. 

Dignity is the best album released by a disney girl period.

Love both 

 

Even went to Ashley's CD signing and still have it  but Dignity is too powerful so she wins 

Dignity for both. Headstrong is great but Dignity is pop perfection.

Dignity, if only Hilary could acknowledge it and her music career again

I had to vote Headstrong for album, it was my first physical cd and i have very nostalgic memories about it. Dignity is sooo good so i gave the better singles vote to it. Love both albums

Dignity, no doubt about it!

Headstrong aged pretty badly compared to Dignity, so Dignity gets my vote 

Stranger and With Love are literally pop perfection so I'll go with Dignidad