Both are currently smashing with Vampire and Cruel Summer.

 

Are they the next IT producers?

 

 

 

Making continuous threads about Olivia and Taylor 

Jack is the main producer on CS 

2 minutes ago, ugo said:

Jack is the main producer on CS 

And his last mega-hit without the help of Annie?

I would LOVE more St. Vincent produced songs!! she was sooooo close to becoming a pop girl back in 2017 with Los Ageless almost breaking through to the mainstream, I feel like if tiktok had been big back then that song would've blown up more  Masseduction could've been one of the best pop girl eras of all time if promoted that way tbh, it sounds like a pop bible whenever I return to it! Los Ageless, Sugarboy, Savior, and Fast Slow Disco all had smash hit written all over them 

 always trying to insert yourselves on everything.

 

Anyway, no. These songs are MID

25 minutes ago, Taylor fanboy said:

And his last mega-hit without the help of Annie?

Anti hero 

1 hour ago, Taylor fanboy said:

And his last mega-hit without the help of Annie?

Anti Hero. 

5 hours ago, ugo said:

Jack is the main producer on CS 

And yet no Jack Antonoff produced St. Vincent album is as good as Strange Mercy from 2011 or St. Vincent from 2014.

Annie didn’t produce Cruel Summer 

3 minutes ago, Letemtalk said:

And yet no Jack Antonoff produced St. Vincent album is as good as Strange Mercy from 2011 or St. Vincent from 2014.

This is true, but again, John Congleton produced those albums, not Annie (which is no comment on Annie’s abilities obv).

Edited June 30, 20233 yr by Headlock

1 hour ago, Letemtalk said:

And yet no Jack Antonoff produced St. Vincent album is as good as Strange Mercy from 2011 or St. Vincent from 2014.

This is more about commercial appeal since the thread says "smashing" 

 

No St Vincent album were more commercially successful than the one produced by Jack.

 

Also Strange Mercy and St. Vincent are both produced by John Congleton and not Annie. 

 

Edited June 30, 20233 yr by ugo

2 minutes ago, ugo said:

No St Vincent album were more commercially successful than the one produced by Jack.

But the Jack Antonoff produced albums were worse and her increasing popularity was happening already following the success of her Grammy winning self titled album. Jack starting working with Annie as she became more successful, he didn't make her more successful.

3 hours ago, Letemtalk said:

But the Jack Antonoff produced albums were worse and her increasing popularity was happening already following the success of her Grammy winning self titled album. Jack starting working with Annie as she became more successful, he didn't make her more successful.

I mean you can say what you want but in the end it's his tracks and albums that were more popular in her discography 

Edited June 30, 20233 yr by ugo

12 hours ago, ugo said:

I mean you can say what you want but in the end it's his tracks and albums that were more popular in her discography 

Perhaps the OP didn't word things are well as he could of (Annie not having official production credits on albums), but Jack appears to be good at finding artists that are popular or becoming popular and uses them to enhance his reputation. Also St. Vincent (album) had a higher US chart peak than Daddy's Home, so it's somewhat debatable how much her newer albums are more popular. Jack certainly hasn't helped with the critics, she used to get 40 eligible critic reviews for an album and she would often have one of the highest rated albums of a given year.

 

Is there any artist he has actually helped turn into a Grammy winner, other than himself/fun at the 2013 awards?

Aren't all of his post 2013 wins with existing Grammy winners, Taylor (and 1989 was mostly Max Martin and Folklore was mostly Aaron Dessner) and St. Vincent.

 

He might have done some good work in the 2010s, but is there any artist making better music with Jack in the 2020s than they were making in previous decades?

 

Dan and Annie on the other hand, appear to have enhanced the reputation of the people they work with.

3 hours ago, Letemtalk said:

Perhaps the OP didn't word things are well as he could of (Annie not having official production credits on albums), but Jack appears to be good at finding artists that are popular or becoming popular and uses them to enhance his reputation. Also St. Vincent (album) had a higher US chart peak than Daddy's Home, so it's somewhat debatable how much her newer albums are more popular. Jack certainly hasn't helped with the critics, she used to get 40 eligible critic reviews for an album and she would often have one of the highest rated albums of a given year.

 

Is there any artist he has actually helped turn into a Grammy winner, other than himself/fun at the 2013 awards?

Aren't all of his post 2013 wins with existing Grammy winners, Taylor (and 1989 was mostly Max Martin and Folklore was mostly Aaron Dessner) and St. Vincent.

 

He might have done some good work in the 2010s, but is there any artist making better music with Jack in the 2020s than they were making in previous decades?

 

Dan and Annie on the other hand, appear to have enhanced the reputation of the people they work with.

All the stuff you're saying don't make sense or are unrelated to the topic. The question was : "Are Dan & Annie the next IT Producers?" 

 

And the answer is simply no for Annie since she didn't really handle the production for Cruel Summer. It's not about critical acclaim, it's not about Grammys, it's not about reputation. Jack has more hits  than Annie clark. 

 

Edited July 1, 20233 yr by ugo

Calm down.

This thread is wild

On 7/1/2023 at 9:28 AM, ugo said:

All the stuff you're saying don't make sense or are unrelated to the topic. The question was : "Are Dan & Annie the next IT Producers?" 

 

And the answer is simply no for Annie since she didn't really handle the production for Cruel Summer. It's not about critical acclaim, it's not about Grammys, it's not about reputation. Jack has more hits  than Annie clark. 

 

 

On 7/1/2023 at 10:53 AM, Letemtalk said:

Calm down.

These two back to back replies made me laugh out loud