is this a school theater 

I'm actually hyped about another SM girl group. I hate the idea of aespa being the sole gg for a few years as RV goes into that "one comeback every few years" phase after the 10th year

2 minutes ago, katyberry said:

You are delusional 

If we go by sales alone then yeah, aespa STOMPS, but if we take everything into consideration then I'm not that far fetched. And I'm saying this as an aespa stan 

Just now, Pluto2022 said:

If we go by sales alone then yeah, aespa STOMPS, but if we take everything into consideration then I'm not that far fetched. And I'm saying this as an aespa stan 

aespa literally have a fandom 10x the size of the other ones combined 

4th Gen Success Overall:

1. ITZY

2. IVE

3. IZ*ONE

4. Aespa

5. (G)-IDLE

6. NewJeans

7. LE SSERAFIM

8. STAYC

9. Kep1er

10. NMIXX

 

Aespa, IVE and NewJeans are currently fighting for the top spot while LESSERAFIM is a solid fourth and (G)-IDLE are in fifth.

2 minutes ago, katyberry said:

aespa literally have a fandom 10x the size of the other ones combined 

A loyal one at that...something other 4th gen gg lack even with their tiny fandoms

Just now, katyberry said:

aespa literally have a fandom 10x the size of the other ones combined 

The same goes for ITZY though then. If aespa had better global streams then they would be way higher, but maybe they should switch places with GIDLE. 

 

1 minute ago, Eternium said:

4th Gen Success Overall:

1. ITZY

2. IVE

3. IZ*ONE

4. Aespa

5. (G)-IDLE

6. NewJeans

7. LE SSERAFIM

8. STAYC

9. Kep1er

10. NMIXX

 

Aespa, IVE and NewJeans are currently fighting for the top spot while LESSERAFIM is a solid fourth and (G)-IDLE are in fifth.

This is honestly the only correct way to look at it, just like how it's done in the West where they look at the overall numbers in terms of who's surpassed who and not who's the hottest artist right now 

 

 

11 minutes ago, Pluto2022 said:

The same goes for ITZY though then. If aespa had better global streams then they would be way higher, but maybe they should switch places with GIDLE. 

 

The only thing stopping aespa from those "global streams" is the type of music they make which is not gp compatible (like nobody is gonna stream a dubstep dance break that's 40 seconds long). Also aespa's fandom is double the size of Itzy's 

Karina's little sister, Irene's grandaughter, and Yoona's great granddaughter 

Edited March 13, 20233 yr by katyberry

Just learned that Sorry Sorry was apparently released 14 years ago today. Say what you want about the group but that was a KLASSIC!!

1 hour ago, Pluto2022 said:

4th gen ranking in terms of quality:

 

1. EVERGLOW (The best discography in KPOP idc)

1 minute ago, CandyCoatedClouds said:

Just learned that Sorry Sorry was apparently released 14 years ago today. Say what you want about the group but that was a KLASSIC!!

We only claim this version though >>>>>>>>>>>

 

 

2 minutes ago, oceans said:

Nobody comes close I fear

 

2 hours ago, Pluto2022 said:

4th gen rankings in terms of success in general right now:

 

1. NewJennies

2. IVE

3. LE SSERAFIM

4. GIDLE

5. aespa

6. ITZY

7. IZ*ONE

8. NMIXX

9. STAYC +1

10. Kep1er -1

 

 

 

4th gen ranking in terms of quality:

 

1. EVERGLOW (The best discography in KPOP idc)

2. aespa

3. ITZY

4. XG

5. NewJennies

6. LE SSERAFIM

7. IVE

8. GIDLE

9. STAYC

10. LOONA

Lol XG has 2 good songs you’re crazy for putting Loona last just delusional

 

 

23 minutes ago, Whatevaaaaa said:

Lol XG has 2 good songs you’re crazy for putting Loona last just delusional

You do know that they are hundreds of 4th gen ggs right? I like everyone's music in the top 10 

Edited March 13, 20233 yr by Pluto2022

2 hours ago, Pluto2022 said:

4th gen rankings in terms of success in general right now:

 

1. NewJennies

2. IVE

3. LE SSERAFIM

4. GIDLE

5. aespa

6. ITZY

7. IZ*ONE

8. NMIXX

9. STAYC +1

10. Kep1er -1

 

 

 

4th gen ranking in terms of quality:

 

1. EVERGLOW (The best discography in KPOP idc)

2. aespa

3. ITZY

4. XG

5. NewJennies

6. LE SSERAFIM

7. IVE

8. GIDLE

9. STAYC

10. LOONA

I think aespa should be higher in the success list, the rest I think it is ok.

The quality list is cleary subjective as far I can see...

9/11  

 

 

24 minutes ago, Pluto2022 said:

You do know that they are hundreds of 4th gen ggs right? I like everyone's music in the top 10 

You put a group with 4 songs and only two good songs in your top 5 that’s insane.

1 minute ago, Whatevaaaaa said:

You put a group with 4 songs and only two good songs in your top 5 that’s insane.

Not XG's fault that they keep releasing 10/10's 

I cant take "artists" who release nursery rhymes seriously 

 

and I can't believe korean netizens are stanning it  I'm guessing this nursery rhyme isn't very known in korea? 

Chile not the civil war in Once fandom atm  it’s I-Once vs K-Once (they want to boycott twice since they promoted in the US instead of Korea). And they just announced their tour 

 

 

Western Stan accounts promoting Twice to block that country singer.

 

and then miley stan accounts supporting BP (cause Twice predicted to beat her in BB200?)

 

And Japan is choosing the English version over the Korean one…

 

These promotions are so messy 

4 minutes ago, sunmimi imfurst said:

Chile not the civil war in Once fandom atm  it’s I-Once vs K-Once (they want to boycott twice since they promoted in the US instead of Korea). And they just announced their tour 

 

 

Western Stan accounts promoting Twice to block that country singer.

 

and then miley stan accounts supporting BP (cause Twice predicted to beat her in BB200?)

 

And Japan is choosing the English version over the Korean one…

 

These promotions are so messy 

a kiiiiiii

 

korea abandoned them 3 years ago and they wanna act offended they didn't launch promotions there.

35 minutes ago, katyberry said:

9/11  

 

 

So SM will still join Weverse without Hybe having to acquire them 

 

I need their negotiation skills pls

That Perfect All-Out achivement is kinda iconic

 

my poor fave can't relate