Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

K-Pop Thread: 2023 Archive

This is part 1 of the K-Pop Thread: 2023 Archive discussion.

Featured Replies

Itzy's new song is cute but forgettable. Def better than the previous turds though

  • Replies 131.8k
  • Views 10.9m
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • aespa #1!    MYs can have arts AND charts now No chart updates on Spicy from you then?   I think not. Nope. They're at #1 now. Consider your points deb

  • Also @Mel. now that thread banning is back your two week ban starts now. 

  • Antisocialites
    Antisocialites

    some of the new members not giving new at all 

bet on me is really nice and different :clap3:

i almost couldn’t recognize ryujin’s voice at the beginning bc she sounds so different (in a good way) :skull:

 

btw the song is still n/a on apple music (or spotify) :gaycat7: is it a youtube only release?

Edited by hallucinate

2 hours ago, Adama said:

Currently watching R u next and Jiwoo have a nice voice and is leader material! Plus she’s 21 ! I’m rooting for her! 
 


And Hybe better add a 7 member

 

also they didn’t mention Fromis_8! Are they disbanded ?

Please vote her on Weverse if you can There is only 2 days left 

If you didn’t pick your final 6 Please consider Jeemin, Jiwoo, Ruka and Yunah We have to help these beautiful talented ladies make it into the final group 

1 hour ago, Pluto2022 said:

Vocal:

  1. Seungmin
  2. Bang Chan
  3. Han
  4. Lee Know
  5. I.N
  6. Changbin
  7. Felix (+1)
  8. Hyunjin (-1)

I agree here from the most part. I think Han is more naturally vocally talented than Bang Chan, you can see when he projects his voice. But he ends up comminting more mistakes while singing due lack of trainning of how to use his strengths properly. Since he's more of a rapper, I suppose It's not really that important for him how It's for some members who hired a vocal coach apart from JYP (props to Seungmin and I.N, now Lee Know who said yesterday he's been working hard on his improvement) 

 

1 hour ago, Pluto2022 said:

Rap:

  1. Changbin
  2. Han
  3. Hyunjin
  4. Bang Chan
  5. Felix
  6. Lee know
  7. Seungmin
  8. I.N

I agree here 100%.

 

1 hour ago, Pluto2022 said:

Dance:

  1. Lee Know
  2. Hyunjin
  3. Felix
  4. Bang Chan
  5. Han
  6. Changbin
  7. Seungmin
  8. I.N

I agree here too. 

 

1 hour ago, Pluto2022 said:

 

Stage Presence:

  1. Lee Know (+2)
  2. Hyunjin (-1)
  3. Han (-1)
  4. Bang Chan
  5. Changbin
  6. Felix
  7. I.N
  8. Seungmin

It's hard here, cause Stray Kids members performance skills as a group aren't homogeneous. So It's really depend on what you value the most when It comes to stage presence.

 

Is It presenting a good technical dancing skill set? Then, yes, Lee Know would be #1. Is It commanding the stage and engaging with the audience to make them hyped? Then, 3RACHA absolutely slay on that departament. Is It the ability to play with your mannerisms, emotions, facial expressions/using body language while dancing as a form of tell a story? Then Hyunjin and Felix are really the best. 

 

I think being so different from each other on the stage is one of the things that makes them special and charismatic actually. Cause they can attract different type of tastes to stan the group. 

 

1 hour ago, Pluto2022 said:

Producing and writing skills:

  1. Bang Chan
  2. Han
  3. Changbin
  4. Hyunjin
  5. Seungmin
  6. Felix
  7. I.N
  8. Lee Know

 

I think Han is, by a reasonable marge, a better lyricist than Bang Chan and Changbin. But I think the latter two are more proeficient as producers. Chan works on every minimal technical aspect of their music that most idols have no knowledge. And Changbin is getting skilled at arraging. 

 

Then, there's a Gap. Hyunjin #4 since he really knows how to write and compose alone as he not only worked on his solos, but did whole demos for "Red Lights", "Taste" and "DMLU" before It was finished and Chan mentioned there was barely any change from Hyunjin's original versions.

 

Then there's another Gap and the other members seem to be really close in terms of skill. 

 

1 hour ago, Pluto2022 said:

Visual (according to Korean Beauty standards): 

  1. Lee Know
  2. Felix
  3. Hyunjin
  4. I.N
  5. Han
  6. Seungmin
  7. Bang Chan
  8. Changbin

I don't understand/care much about korean standards so I will just say my personal ranking is probably

 

1. Lee Know

2. Hyunjin

3. Bang Chan

4. Han

5. Felix

6. Seungmin

7. I.N

8. Changbin

 

1 hour ago, Pluto2022 said:

Most all rounded/versatile members (combining everything):

  1. Han
  2. Bang Chan/Lee Know
  3. Lee know/Bang Chan
  4. Changbin
  5. Hyunjin 
  6. Felix
  7. Seungmin
  8. I.N

Being honest, I'd say the only all rounder members of Stray Kids are Bang Chan, Changbin and Han. They are great to decent on all mentioned categories. The other members have major weakness on one or more categories. 

2 hours ago, Adama said:

Currently watching R u next and Jiwoo have a nice voice and is leader material! Plus she’s 21 ! I’m rooting for her! 
 


And Hybe better add a 7 member

 

also they didn’t mention Fromis_8! Are they disbanded ?

She knew she had to serve cvnt :jonny5:

Why she got into low level is a mystery to me

1 minute ago, Flomik said:

She knew she had to serve cvnt :jonny5:

Why she got into low level is a mystery to me

Please if you can go to vote Two days left Don’t let sis Jiwoo flop 

The gap between everyone else and Ruka's views :rip:

Fearnots are really getting her back :clap3:

HYBE knew what they were doing by not editing her out of Le Sserafim's documentary... We love strategy! :clap3:

 

 

ITZY song is a big improvement :clap3:

I got kinda emotional, I can’t stop imagining that scene with JYP when they told him about their doubts :chick3: I hope the girls are okay and will be back on the good track with this comeback! 

  • Author
  • ATRL Administrator

Itzy’s new pre-release is mid. The vocals sound like they recorded it on a bad day and everything sound flat. 

28 minutes ago, k4rmabutterfly said:

Lol but the fact that Taeyeon and IU never interact with each other is kinda sus :coffee2: especially bcs IU is very close with SM artists and Taeyeon’s friends (Sulli, Yeri, Jonghyun) and while Miss Taeyeon is pretty reserved she’s always supporting her fellow peers like Sunmi and Heize but never IU.  

The fact that none of these top females soloists have collaborated together yet :deadbanana4:!

 

14 minutes ago, FACT said:

Please vote her on Weverse if you can There is only 2 days left 

If you didn’t pick your final 6 Please consider Jeemin, Jiwoo, Ruka and Yunah We have to help these beautiful talented ladies make it into the final group 

I haven’t saw Yunah, Ruka and Jeemin performances yet? 

 

So far the ones who stood out in the first episode were:

 

 

Yougsoo 

 


Loved her tone! Plus Hybe love their white mixed English speakers :cm: 
 

9 minutes ago, Flomik said:

She knew she had to serve cvnt :jonny5:

Why she got into low level is a mystery to me

For her storyline and people can root for her now! She got the most screen time for this episode, and was ranked #5 on Hybe evaluation. I think they want her 

4 minutes ago, Adama said:

The fact that none of these top females soloists have collaborated together yet :deadbanana4:!

 

I haven’t saw Yunah, Ruka and Jeemin performances yet? 

 

So far the ones who stood out in the first episode were:

 

 

Yougsoo 

 


Loved her tone! Plus Hybe love their white mixed English speakers :cm: 
 

For her storyline and people can root for her now! She got the most screen time for this episode, and was ranked #5 on Hybe evaluation. I think they want her 

Please these beautiful talented ladies deserve everything :superman: The voting system will be down in two days so please :jonnycat:

 

 

Itzy is average at vocals but it's okay since every popular K-pop group has average/ below average vocals except for nmixx and sm groups. 

I do think it’s a little weird we’ve never had any huge female soloist collabs. 
 

Taeyeon and IU would be legendary but at this point don’t think it will ever happen. 
 

Would have been nice to even have a Taeyeon and Sunmi big collab single at some point but… 

39 minutes ago, Flomik said:

The gap between everyone else and Ruka's views :rip:

Fearnots are really getting her back :clap3:

HYBE knew what they were doing by not editing her out of Le Sserafim's documentary... We love strategy! :clap3:

 

 

being a lsrf reject will carry her but most of the girls are washing her 

4 minutes ago, Gaia said:

I do think it’s a little weird we’ve never had any huge female soloist collabs. 
 

Taeyeon and IU would be legendary but at this point don’t think it will ever happen. 
 

Would have been nice to even have a Taeyeon and Sunmi big collab single at some point but… 

I wonder what’s the reason? Bc how can you make a collaboration with Jpark or JYP, AMBER PARK, Zico when they could slay us with a powerful females duet :redface:

Even Hyuna and Jessi who were on the same label never collaborated together but they did it with Dawn like who asked??

4 hours ago, Sorecer said:

Rumor says this is 4 SMNGG singing to SNSD ITNW 

 

the voices are from 

Ouju, Jiwoo , Haram and Jueun

 

 

This sounds amazing and just like the original :jonny5: 

3 hours ago, CrisPop said:

 

I thought this was good. Yeji and Chaeryeong were my favorite parts. I see everyone’s dragging Yeji, but this sort of song really does not suit Yuna.

2 hours ago, Hazy said:

imagine saying youtube and spotify streams are fraudalent and fueled by bots, but then insisting on album sales and units being the valid and main success and popularity metric when some companies don’t even report them to IFPI even though they allegedly have millions of those :rip:

We don’t need to imagine. We watched Life Is Good‘s run on YouTube. We saw TiDAL faking hundreds of millions of streams. We know that people are faking streams left and right and it’s gotten to the point where Spotify themselves have joined an anti-fraudulence coalition. Blinks are literally faking streams for Money now (look at the massive filtering from Spotify official) and HYLT Dance Practice. 

 

Also, IFPI literally started equivalent units back in 2000 so not exactly sure what you’re trying to argue there. But if you really think a $10 album should be worth less in consumption than 20,000+ streams per device per day that nobody is listening to, well… :michael: 

31 minutes ago, Adama said:

I wonder what’s the reason? Bc how can you make a collaboration with Jpark or JYP, AMBER PARK, Zico when they could slay us with a powerful females duet :redface:

Even Hyuna and Jessi who were on the same label never collaborated together but they did it with Dawn like who asked??

I think it's so hard to make it as a female soloist that they've been conditioned to view each other as competition. They can like each other, but to work together would help strengthen the other person's brand and I fully believe they've been trained to view that as a bad thing.

 

I don't think it's the companies forbidding it :rip: 

itzy new song is good. Hopefully they can pull out a top 10 hit this era

34 minutes ago, Antunes said:

being a lsrf reject will carry her but most of the girls are washing her 

I have to agree. At least 10 girls are better than her. :coffee2:

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.