Like an album or era? No tbh. Like a 4-minute type hit? Yes.

Madonna has countless comebacks left. All she needs is the right material!

No. Even collabing with the hottest names didn't help her,while it worked for Elton John.

Sadly, in her current state I don’t think so. She has had such a ground breaking and next level career though, so can do whatever she wants without worrying about it smashing. There will always be an audience for Madonna, but I just don’t see her getting a number 1 again by herself. 

I love her so much, but with her current behaviour I don't think so.

I know she think she´s breaking some kind of barrier with those IG picks and edgy behaviour, but she´s not.

She need to drop the obsession with regaetton or whatever is the kind of music Tosicka makes.

4 hours ago, Mitsouko said:

Neither ROL or COADF were comebacks so this would be her first. And no, won’t happen.

This is an absolute lie

I was ready to say no but Elton had a cute revival 

1 hour ago, Badger said:

This is an absolute lie

Outselling a preceding album =/= a comeback. Madonna was in the Top 10, often the Top 5, every year of the 90s before ROL. And American Life was a success with several hit singles in the UK and Europe so

Now that's she's back with Warner, I do believe she can have one more successful era. Maybe one more top 40 hit and a highly successful GH tour. She has to play her cards right through and actually embrace her legacy. 

Honestly, I think her voice would make this impossible. There’s basically no way to make her current nails on a chalkboard tone enjoyable or even listenable. Plus, she doesn’t understand or accept what people actually want from her.

If the awful remixes are an indication of where she is at musically then absolutely not.

Maybe with one of her old songs but I don’t think she’ll have a hit with new music. 

No, and there’s nothing wrong with that.

I would hope not, she isn't looking to have a comeback. If it happens then, so be it but Madonna is quite contempt with her life right now. Save that energy for the other girls that need public opinion and notoriety to be happy.

No. She'll always be able to tour like the Rolling Stones or Bon Jovi, but she won't have another successful era. 

On 12/19/2022 at 3:31 PM, Rican said:

If the awful remixes are an indication of where she is at musically then absolutely not.

You're not a fan and wouldn't be listening/buying anyway, so WTF do you care?

 

Edited September 6, 20233 yr by GlamSlam

On 12/19/2022 at 11:40 AM, eli's_rhythm said:

Honestly, I think her voice would make this impossible. There’s basically no way to make her current nails on a chalkboard tone enjoyable or even listenable. Plus, she doesn’t understand or accept what people actually want from her.

This, specially the second point. Shes been making lots of questionable career moves so it would be more hard to "hit the target" with her intentionally being messy, it would be impossible actually. People give her the hardest time even when she get things right... in a way i understand why she gave up trying, lol. Too much work for fewer results.

maybe with an old song like what happened with RUTH

 

but i don't see it for new music unless she hires a ghost singer and starts releasing good music 

Queen rising on the hot 100 as we speak. This thread shaking.

On 12/19/2022 at 3:40 PM, eli's_rhythm said:

Honestly, I think her voice would make this impossible. There’s basically no way to make her current nails on a chalkboard tone enjoyable or even listenable. Plus, she doesn’t understand or accept what people actually want from her.

She hasn't sounded as inoffensive on a recording as on Popular in many, many years. Whoever did the vocal production on it:

On 12/19/2022 at 9:24 AM, GlamSlam said:

I'd love to say yes, but I can't see it happening unless she gets her sh** together.

She needs to come off social media, remove the implants, either go on a GHs tour or hand the biopic over to someone else, then lock herself in the studio with Pat Leonard and Stuart Price to make another brilliant album, but she probably wouldn't  even entertain that.

Well well well. 

 

Here we are nine months later....the implants have gone, she's going on a GH's tour, and she's been in the studio with Stuart Price.

 

Edited September 6, 20233 yr by GlamSlam

Maybe as a featured/sampled artist. Or if an old song takes off on tiktok