both women have achieved nine hot 100 #1s in their career. which are the best among each matchup (in chronological order in which they occurred)?

 

pick/discuss, and no trolling or flame bait.

 

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

California Gurls vs Shake It Off

Teenage Dream vs Blank Space

Firework vs Bad Blood

E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do

Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan

Part of Me willow

Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version)

Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

Katy for all

Katy for all (girl with real and global hits)

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

California Gurls vs Shake It Off

Teenage Dream vs Blank Space

Firework vs Bad Blood

E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do

Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan

Part of Me willow

Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version)

Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
California Gurls vs Shake It Off
Teenage Dream vs Blank Space
Firework vs Bad Blood
E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do
Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan
Part of Me vs willow
Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version)
Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together 

California Gurls vs Shake It Off 

Teenage Dream vs Blank Space 

Firework vs Bad Blood 

E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do 

Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan 

Part of Me willow 

Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version) 

Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together 

California Gurls vs Shake It Off 

Teenage Dream vs Blank Space 

Firework vs Bad Blood (but secretly neither of these corny songs)

E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do 

Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan 

Part of Me vs willow 

Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version) 

Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together 

California Gurls vs Shake It Off 

Teenage Dream vs Blank Space 

Firework vs Bad Blood 

E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do 

Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan 

Part of Me vs willow 

Roar vs All Too Well

Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

 

6:3

Edited November 6, 20223 yr by Breakdown

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together 

California Gurls vs Shake It Off 

Teenage Dream vs Blank Space 

Firework vs Bad Blood 

E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do 

Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan 

Part of Me willow 

Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version) 

Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together 

California Gurls vs Shake It Off 

Teenage Dream vs Blank Space 

Firework vs Bad Blood 

E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do 

Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan 

Part of Me willow 

Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version) 

Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

 

Taylor wins easy

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
California Gurls vs Shake It Off
Teenage Dream vs Blank Spae
Firework vs Bad Blood
E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do
Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan
Part of Me willow
Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version)
Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

 

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

California Gurls vs Shake It Off

Teenage Dream vs Blank Space

Firework vs Bad Blood

E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do

Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan

Part of Me willow

Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version)

Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together 
California Gurls vs Shake It Off 
Teenage Dream vs Blank Space 
Firework vs Bad Blood 
E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do (both irredeemably awful)
Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan 
Part of Me vs willow (Never heard willow)
Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version) 
Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

Katy for all. Her #1 were organic not fraudulent.

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
California Gurls vs Shake It Off
Teenage Dream vs Blank Space
Firework vs Bad Blood
E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do
Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan
Part of Me willow
Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version) 
Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
California Gurls vs Shake It Off
Teenage Dream vs Blank Space
Firework vs Bad Blood
E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do
Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan
Part of Me willow
Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version)
Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

 

Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

California Gurls vs Shake It Off

Teenage Dream vs Blank Space

Firework vs Bad Blood

E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do

Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan

Part of Me willow

Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version)

Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

 

Katy's are much bigger, but Taylor's are much better overall 

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together 
California Gurls vs Shake It Off 
Teenage Dream vs Blank Space 
Firework vs Bad Blood 
E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do 
Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan 
Part of Me willow 
Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version) 
Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together 
California Gurls vs Shake It Off 
Teenage Dream vs Blank Space 
Firework vs Bad Blood 
E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do 
Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan 
Part of Me willow 
Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version) 
Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

 

katy wins

Taylor sweeps easily 

7 minutes ago, Wizard said:

katy for all except willow 

This 

 

Taylor really does have the worst #1s  

Edited November 6, 20223 yr by Homebrand

I Kissed a Girl vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together 

California Gurls vs Shake It Off 

Teenage Dream vs Blank Space 

Firework vs Bad Blood 

E.T. vs Look What You Made Me Do 

Last Friday Night (TGIF) vs cardigan 

Part of Me vs Willow 

Roar vs All Too Well (Taylor’s Version) 

Dark Horse vs Anti-Hero

 

Katy 8

Taylor 1

Katy without a second thought 

Katy for all obviously 

Teenage Dream vs Blank Space 

Not both of their best #1s being put against each other