ALIEN SUPERSTAR is a masterpiece so that! You should've made a poll 

There's not one Gaga song that comes close to any song from RENAISSANCE in terms of quality imo.

alien superstar is best song on the album but G.U.Y is a WAY better song 

GUY bridge alone demolishes + that last chorus takes you to heaven + the synth 

a masterclass in pop writitng i fear 

Alien Superstar of course.

G.U.Y is cute and one of the best on Artpop, but lets be real here   

G.U.Y i have no clue why alien superstar is placed higher than better bops on Renaissance. 

Edited July 31, 20223 yr by L.B GAGA

not people saying 'GUY is generic' as if Alien Superstar was experimental or something  and I say that as someone who's had AS on repeat since Friday

 

both great songs, I obviously listen to AS a lot more so I'll have to see how they compare when the novelty wears off, can't decide right now

They are nothing alike wtf is this random comparison 

What is this comparison  Another proof of swifties being mento

4 hours ago, Blue Rose said:

I dont think there’s a Gaga song that can compete against the masterpiece that is Alien Superstar 

This tbh  And if there is it’s certainly not off of FARTPOP 

Alien Superstar; the other is just noise.

G.U.Y. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

The one by the songwriter and not just performer. 

Guy is a bit stronger song, but neither is worthy of acclaim.

Alien Superstar is really interesting. Chile G.U.Y. is a really good pop song, it brings nothing new. AS.

Let's be real for just a sec, Alien Superstar is kinda better than anything Lady has ever done

12 hours ago, terrorblade said:

GUY sweetie

x2

GUY is one of the fewer listenable tracks on Artpop, however it can't compete with Alien Superstar's greatness. 

Alien Superstar sweetie 

Alien superstar, sweetie 

If you put it up against Venus I might consider it but GUY is so basic. Alien Superstar.

Neither, they both suck