song: NTLTC

video: ET

cover: ET

no tears for all

E.T. for all

What an odd set of two songs to compare

NTLTC aged for me so I'm going with E.T.

E.T. for all 

ntltc sweetie...

ntltc

E.T. sweetie

E.T. for all but cover.

 

 

NTLTC for all. It's one of the best pop songs by a MPG and so damn timeless.

 

E.T. had a cute Ye feature I guess. 

 

Overall It's a disgrace to even ask this question. 

What a random pairing

 

E.T. is my fave Katy song, but no tears left to cry is better for all IMO

E.T. WITHOUT Kanye is better than NTLTC

but with Kanye... NTLTC is better lol

 

and yeah NTLTC for cover and MV. the MV is f*cking iconic and her most memorable to me

NTLTC aged horrifyingly even though it’s a cute little bop from time to time. E.T. may be of it’s time but it’s an overall more enjoyable pop song and certainly more iconic than NTLTC. This was Katy at her peak. She was everywhere snagging numbers one left right and center. 

NTLTC for all 3 for me but ET ft Kanye is a great song this was so hard.

 

NTLC > ET ft Ye > ET

Solo ET >

No Tears is next level ethereal bop.

No Tears for all.

4 hours ago, wastedpotential said:

What an odd set of two songs to compare

Both are recognized as one of their best songs to date in their respective catalogues. Both are excellent songs, that's why i'm asking which is better/your preference. 

4 hours ago, Daddy said:

NTLTC for all. It's one of the best pop songs by a MPG and so damn timeless.

 

E.T. had a cute Ye feature I guess. 

 

Overall It's a disgrace to even ask this question. 

The dramatics

NTLTC

Ariana! 

3 hours ago, yeezytaughtme said:

Both are recognized as one of their best songs to date in their respective catalogues. Both are excellent songs, that's why i'm asking which is better/your preference. 

I thought it's becuz of the "no gravity" aspect of both video

ET was a good song. The definition of a classic tbh

Et was bigger and better.