1 hour ago, aesthetic bih said:

Plus Boy with Luv and that featured Halsey

Their fans stopped caring about My Universe on Week 2 and it's their third longest-running song too (thank you Coldplay).

Fraud. The second the rules changed they lost all potential at debuting at #1. This is how their songs would've performed had there been no bulk buying. The only song I think MAYBE would've debuted at #1 is Dynamite.

The song was awful + their fans only cares about their english stuff

It's a Greatest Hits album

The song is in Korean

It's a midtempo ballad

It does not have 1294674 versions like Butter or Dynamite

It comes with a disbandment announcement

2 hours ago, XtunaStan said:

They don't have any real hits lbr

If they don’t have any real hits then all the Korean Group has zero hits too 

 

OT:

Yet To Come almost on par to Life Goes ON,

the different is Billboard change the rules.

 

with the old rules Yet To Come will debut at #1 and then falls out top 30 just like LGO.

 

but with the current rules YTC only debut #13 and falls to #68

 

there’s nothing wrong.

 

both LGO & YTC are a ballad/mid-tempo korean song and release at the same day with the album.

 

Armys also buying the Album too.

 

and BE & Proof album have similar chart run on BB200 so far 

 

not to mention, Proof is a compilation / greatest hits album with only 3 new songs

it’s doing good.

 

both Dynamite & Butter have their own league

Y'all serious? They're the biggest, most successful boygroup of all time. Nothing went wrong and everything went right. They bowed out gracefully and are about to embark on solo projects and military duty. I hate their fans just as much as anyone else, but the group itself did nothing wrong.

25 minutes ago, LustSpell said:

Fraud. The second the rules changed they lost all potential at debuting at #1. This is how their songs would've performed had there been no bulk buying. The only song I think MAYBE would've debuted at #1 is Dynamite.

Both Dynamite & Butter would have debut at #2 because WAP & Good 4 U are too huge back then. But may debut at #1 if the competition are quite low like today 

 

also Dynamite & Butter debut #2 on RollingStone chart (a chart without mass buying sales)

Billboard rule changes. They would've never gotten a #1 to begin with without fraudulent ways lol

Ageism

billboard finally said NO to fraudulence

They shamelessly milked their fans kpop is just isn't that popular as people think 

BTS fans couldnt pretend any longer music is some sort of masterpiece

1 hour ago, Bang Up said:

Y'all serious? They're the biggest, most successful boygroup of all time. 

um... that would be backstreet boys

 

(i know im shocked too)

all those #1s were all fraudulent. they have zero hits and their new comeback single shows how irrelevant and fraudulent they really are  

They're over. Everything went right.

Yet To Chart was very underwhelming and some fans started to finally realize it's been like 5 or 6 years since they put out a good album.

 

Also Billboard is trying to restrict fraudulent sales. It's hilarious how armys became pressed that a new kpop group topped the albums chart with suspicious sales when that has been the BTS brand since they started to focus on the US market

New rules impacted their performance on the charts

Nothing. Billboard got sick of foreigners topping the Hot 100.

10 minutes ago, omni said:

Nothing. Billboard got sick of foreigners topping the Hot 100.

I don't know if you don't like Asians or billboard 

Intersting to see that BTS without mass buying peaked the same as Blackpink highstest charting song, Ice Cream. 

way more realistic from what i see from the GP if u ask me. 

K-pop, not a thing anymore 

20 minutes ago, Selenasworld said:

I don't know if you don't like Asians or billboard 

They had no problem with one person buying multiple copies until someone who isn't part of the western phonographic industry began to top the charts. It baffles me that it was even allowed at first.

Edited June 29, 20224 yr by omni

Their label successfully exploited loopholes to allow them quick success in the states.  Once the loopholes were closed, the label knew they would not reach the previous success they had achieved and stopped trying.   

wbk they're frauds. and those #1s are frauds.

Y’all are doing too much. Their album is a “greatest hits” album with 3 new songs. And the single is an uninspired ballad that was not sent to radio and is all in Korean. 
 

If they came back as hard as they pushed with Dynamite and Butter, we would be having a different conversation and that’s just a fact.

Edited June 29, 20224 yr by Khamis