10 hours ago, naval23 said:

I love Nelly but Dirrty takes this phone for me I love her roaring vocals 

 

10 hours ago, naval23 said:

I love Nelly but Dirrty takes this phone for me I love her roaring vocals 

 

10 hours ago, naval23 said:

I love Nelly but Dirrty takes this phone for me I love her roaring vocals 

Both great songs, but I'm gonna go with Maneater.

 

Maneater

 

But Dirrty has an iconic video 

This is hard. But this time xtina wins.

Maneater is not bad tbh but Dirrty is by far superior. the anti-establisment of Xtine was unparalleled

maneater, one of the greatest pop songs ever

Maneater. 

both noisy and overrated. not even top 10 singles by either of them.

Maneater >>>

honestly Dirrty is kinda noisy to me, its good though too

 

Maneater

Maneater, Nelly ate.  

Maneater has a class to it

Dirrty is vulgar and tastless 

Dirrty

I like both but Dirrty is all raw energy so the point goes to xtina.

Edited June 13, 20224 yr by gm4567

Dirrty 

Both good 

But I prefer Maneater

On 6/12/2022 at 11:38 PM, LeMésTragique said:

Maneater has a class to it

Dirrty is vulgar and tastless 

spill the tea

Maneater, that song is up there with the greats.

I love Maneater, but the breakdown in Dirrty is just godly  

Dirrty by miles. I've never been able to connect to Loose.

This is hard but Dirrty

Maneater has aged like fine wine