Which song is superior ?

I was shook when I first head Shallow

HMH is great, and vocally it's arguably even more on point

but I still feel like it doesn't have that magic that Shallow has

It took me 3 years to appreciate Swallow, Hold My Hand feels more instant... But i don't know how it shall grow on me.

Shallow but it's too early to tell i guess.

Shallow, sweetie... 

Shallow

shallow

Shallow instantly felt huge. Everyone moved.  The other song was released. 

The first time I heard Shallow it sounded like an absolute classic. The storytelling on the chorus alone is gorgeous. Hold My Hand is aggressively fine and has some really cliche/boring lyrics but is enhanced by Gaga's performance. 

Shallow was just an instant classic.

Shallow 

Hold My Hand. I HATE Shallow, i cant listen to that song

Shallow because of the bridge and final chorus.

Definitely Shallow, but I love Hold My Hand.

love both, but Hold My Hand instantly clicked with me.

Hold My Hand easily, Shallow will always be one of her most overrated song will never get the appeal

Shallow by eons

shallow is horrible

Shallow, hands down.

Neither 

24 minutes ago, Winged said:

Neither 

The CORRECT answer.

Always Remember Us This Way 

I knew that shallow was going to become a classic ever since I first heard it in the ASIB trailer 

Hold My Hand

 

It's 80s power ballad excellence, Shallow is too country'd

Hold My Hand

it’s just way more interesting