Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.
ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues
ATRL’s Search Is Back

Electra Heart vs Rebel Heart

smoore95GAGA
in The Lounge

Featured Replies

Very similar titles. Both now have 19 tracks on the deluxe editions. So let’s compare them girlies and determine which is the better album!

 

1. Bubblegum B**** vs Living for Love

2. Primadonna vs Devil Pray

3. Lies vs Ghosttown

4. Homewrecker vs Unapologetic B****

5. Starting Role vs Illuminati

6. The State of Dreaming vs B**** I’m Madonna

7. Power & Control vs Hold Tight

8. Living Dead vs Joan of Arc 

9. Teen Idle vs Iconic

10. Valley of the Dolls vs HeartBreakCity

11. Hypocrates vs Body Shop

12. Fear and Loathing vs Holy Water

13. How to Be a Heartbreaker vs Inside Out

14. Radioactive vs Wash All Over Me

15. Sex Yeah vs Best Night

16. Buy the Stars vs Veni Vidi Vici

17. Lonely Hearts Club vs S.E.X.

18. E.V.O.L. vs Messiah

19. Electra Heart vs Rebel Heart

Edited by smoore95GAGA

  • Replies 26
  • Views 1.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

What kind of stupid comparison??? :ahh: 

 

Electra Heart is a staple indie pop album so that all day, any day. Primadonna alone outweighs everything Madonna has put out post-2010 (except Killers Who Are Partying)

electra heart for all 

 

we don't use rebel heart (joan of arc is beautiful though) 

  • Author

1. Bubblegum B**** vs Living for Love

2. Primadonna vs Devil Pray

3. Lies vs Ghosttown

4. Homewrecker vs Unapologetic *****

5. Starring Role vs Illuminati

6. The State of Dreaming vs ***** I’m Madonna

7. Power & Control vs Hold Tight

8. Living Dead vs Joan of Arc 

9. Teen Idle vs Iconic

10. Valley of the Dolls vs HeartBreakCity

11. Hypocrates vs Body Shop

12. Fear and Loathing vs Holy Water

13. How to Be a Heartbreaker vs Inside Out

14. Radioactive vs Wash All Over Me

15. Sex Yeah vs Best Night

16. Buy the Stars vs Veni Vidi Vici

17. Lonely Hearts Club vs S.E.X.

18. E.V.O.L. vs Messiah

19. Electra Heart vs Rebel Heart

 

Electra: 16

Rebel: 3

 

giphy.gif

  • Author
6 minutes ago, Pendulum said:

What kind of stupid comparison??? :ahh: 

 

Electra Heart is a staple indie pop album so that all day, any day. Primadonna alone outweighs everything Madonna has put out post-2010 (except Killers Who Are Partying)

I just thought it was interesting that they have similar titles and both have 19 tracks, it’s incredibly obvious which one is the better album. You don’t have to come for me this much girl :gaycat6:

Edited by smoore95GAGA

Bubblegum B**** vs Living for Love

Primadonna vs Devil Pray

Lies vs Ghosttown

Homewrecker vs Unapologetic B****

Starring Role vs Illuminati

The State of Dreaming vs B**** I’m Madonna

Power & Control vs Hold Tight

Living Dead vs Joan of Arc 

Teen Idle vs Iconic

Valley of the Dolls vs HeartBreakCity

Hypocrates vs Body Shop

Fear and Loathing vs Holy Water

How to Be a Heartbreaker vs Inside Out

Radioactive vs Wash All Over Me

Sex Yeah vs Best Night

Buy the Stars vs Veni Vidi Vici

Lonely Hearts Club vs S.E.X.

E.V.O.L. vs Messiah

Electra Heart vs Rebel Heart

 

Electra Heart obviously wins, but Rebel Heart does have a few amazing and severely underrated songs on it. Devil Pray, Ghosttown, Unapologetic B****, Illuminati, B**** I'm Madonna, Holy Water and Inside Out are honestly all great. 

51 minutes ago, Pendulum said:

What kind of stupid comparison??? :ahh: 

 

Electra Heart is a staple indie pop album so that all day, any day. Primadonna alone outweighs everything Madonna has put out post-2010 (except Killers Who Are Partying)

Not indie :bibliahh:

1. Bubblegum B**** vs Living for Love

2. Primadonna vs Devil Pray

3. Lies vs Ghosttown

4. Homewrecker vs Unapologetic B****

5. Starring Role vs Illuminati

6. The State of Dreaming vs B**** I’m Madonna

7. Power & Control vs Hold Tight

8. Living Dead vs Joan of Arc 

9. Teen Idle vs Iconic

10. Valley of the Dolls vs HeartBreakCity

11. Hypocrates vs Body Shop

12. Fear and Loathing vs Holy Water

13. How to Be a Heartbreaker vs Inside Out

14. Radioactive vs Wash All Over Me

15. Sex Yeah vs Best Night

16. Buy the Stars vs Veni Vidi Vici

17. Lonely Hearts Club vs S.E.X.

18. E.V.O.L. vs Messiah

19. Electra Heart vs Rebel Heart

 

Electra Heart: 12

Rebel Heart: 7

Bubblegum B**** vs Living for Love

Primadonna vs Devil Pray

Lies vs Ghosttown

Homewrecker vs Unapologetic B****

Starring Role vs Illuminati

The State of Dreaming vs B**** I’m Madonna

Power & Control vs Hold Tight

Living Dead vs Joan of Arc 

Teen Idle vs Iconic

Valley of the Dolls vs HeartBreakCity

Hypocrates vs Body Shop

Fear and Loathing vs Holy Water

How to Be a Heartbreaker vs Inside Out

Radioactive vs Wash All Over Me

Sex Yeah vs Best Night

Buy the Stars vs Veni Vidi Vici

Lonely Hearts Club vs S.E.X.

E.V.O.L. vs Messiah

Electra Heart vs Rebel Heart

 

Marina: 9

Madonna: 10

 

honestly didn't expect Madonna to win this, I still kinda prefer Electra Heart as it feels less bloated and has no songs as bad as Best Night or Body Shop

I like / love a lot of the songs from Rebel Heart (especially songs from the EP  like Borrowed Time and Beautiful Scars) but Electra Heart is that ***** and easily bodies the entire thing. 
 

a17e0092cbc848b19cc80cda1d891b37.gif

4. Homewrecker vs Unapologetic *****

6. The State of Dreaming vs ***** I’m Madonna

 

The rest goes to Merna.

1. Bubblegum B**** vs Living for Love

2. Primadonna vs Devil Pray

3. Lies vs Ghosttown

4. Homewrecker vs Unapologetic B****

5. Starting Role vs Illuminati

6. The State of Dreaming vs B**** I’m Madonna

7. Power & Control vs Hold Tight

8. Living Dead vs Joan of Arc 

9. Teen Idle vs Iconic

10. Valley of the Dolls vs HeartBreakCity

11. Hypocrates vs Body Shop

12. Fear and Loathing vs Holy Water

13. How to Be a Heartbreaker vs Inside Out

14. Radioactive vs Wash All Over Me

15. Sex Yeah vs Best Night

16. Buy the Stars vs Veni Vidi Vici

17. Lonely Hearts Club vs S.E.X.

18. E.V.O.L. vs Messiah

19. Electra Heart vs Rebel Heart

 

EH: 14

RB: 9

:ihype:

Electra sweetie... I'm so sorry they won't let you rest in peace. Must be rolling in her grave because of this thread 

hmmm... Ghosttown did that :clap3: 

 

1. Bubblegum B**** vs Living for Love

2. Primadonna vs Devil Pray

3. Lies vs Ghosttown

4. Homewrecker vs Unapologetic B****

5. Starring Role vs Illuminati

6. The State of Dreaming vs B**** I’m Madonna

7. Power & Control vs Hold Tight

8. Living Dead vs Joan of Arc 

9. Teen Idle vs Iconic

10. Valley of the Dolls vs HeartBreakCity

11. Hypocrates vs Body Shop

12. Fear and Loathing vs Holy Water

13. How to Be a Heartbreaker vs Inside Out

14. Radioactive vs Wash All Over Me

15. Sex Yeah vs Best Night

16. Buy the Stars vs Veni Vidi Vici

17. Lonely Hearts Club vs S.E.X.

18. E.V.O.L. vs Messiah

19. Electra Heart vs Rebel Heart

1. Bubblegum B**** vs Living for Love

2. Primadonna vs Devil Pray

3. Lies vs Ghosttown

4. Homewrecker vs Unapologetic B****

5. Starting Role vs Illuminati

6. The State of Dreaming vs B**** I’m Madonna

7. Power & Control vs Hold Tight

8. Living Dead vs Joan of Arc 

9. Teen Idle vs Iconic

10. Valley of the Dolls vs HeartBreakCity

11. Hypocrates vs Body Shop

12. Fear and Loathing vs Holy Water

13. How to Be a Heartbreaker vs Inside Out

14. Radioactive vs Wash All Over Me

15. Sex Yeah vs Best Night

16. Buy the Stars vs Veni Vidi Vici

17. Lonely Hearts Club vs S.E.X.

18. E.V.O.L. vs Messiah

19. Electra Heart vs Rebel Heart

Marina: 13

Madonna: 6

1. Bubblegum B**** vs Living for Love

2. Primadonna vs Devil Pray

3. Lies vs Ghosttown

4. Homewrecker vs Unapologetic B****

5. Starting Role vs Illuminati

6. The State of Dreaming vs B**** I’m Madonna

7. Power & Control vs Hold Tight

8. Living Dead vs Joan of Arc 

9. Teen Idle vs Iconic

10. Valley of the Dolls vs HeartBreakCity

11. Hypocrates vs Body Shop

12. Fear and Loathing vs Holy Water

13. How to Be a Heartbreaker vs Inside Out

14. Radioactive vs Wash All Over Me

15. Sex Yeah vs Best Night

16. Buy the Stars vs Veni Vidi Vici

17. Lonely Hearts Club vs S.E.X.

18. E.V.O.L. vs Messiah

19. Electra Heart vs Rebel Heart

 

RH - 11 

EH - 10

 

 

I miss Marina when she's not pretentious and actually made great bangers

Go to topic listing

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications
Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.