1 minute ago, little legend said:

You tasteless rat slugs deserve an album full with Stupid Loves, Swines, Dopes and Plastic Trashes. 

That sounds amazing wdym

stay pressed

 

2 minutes ago, Mix said:

Don't you think that maybe some people in here genuinely enjoyed the song? And wanted to share their excitements but some loud minorities decided to parade their "disappointing" a bit too much. We get it, you don't like the song, not your cup of tea and it's fine but move on. 
 

Mindlessly loop something to be a true fans? Lmao that is not the argument here. Some of us and I enjoyed the song. If you don't like it? Fine express it but don't need to be a broken record about it. 

Uhh all I said a few pages back is that the song would have been better, in a production sense, if someone who's experienced with ballads worked on it, like Mark, instead of Bloodpop.

 

This is the base thread, of course we're gonna discuss the song. We're gonna dissect it bit by bit and comment on it. Your enjoyment of the song should not be hindered by what a few online strangers think of the song. Discussion is normal. Excessive hatred on the song with no added discussion is annoying, that I agree with.

1 minute ago, Villanelle said:

Damn y'all hyped this and for what 

 

 

 

The way the swfitie discord remember your melt downs over katy and britney in SYG and dont claim you. embarrassing!

 

Hold My Hand is gaga being asked to come on a big hollywood project, her career didnt end in 2015 yay

 

If the idea of the broken radio was the concept for the intro, I think they could have used Mark Ronson, he could have executed the idea better. 

The way some people are just begging for attention at this point

 

3 minutes ago, Villanelle said:

Damn y'all hyped this and for what 

 

 

 

No one hyped anything to you, maybe besides some grass to touch. Always hyped to touch some grass. Try it sis.

4 minutes ago, Gagacharts said:

Just compare "Hold My Hand" to other pop girls soundtrack singles:

• Spirit
• Beautiful Ghosts
• Don´t Call Me Angel
• No Time To Die
• Just Look Up
• Be Alive

it´s leagues above them. It´s just not that dominating if we compare it to "Shallow" & "ARUTW".

leagues above no time to die? no ma’am 

Lube my hole, everything has been well-cleansed

I heard from your ex that you don't do foreplay

 

8 minutes ago, Diocles said:

@Brooke Candy did we lose sis?

 

IDK, you tell me

 

We kinda did sis, but thank god my expectations were low from the start.

 

Her vocals are everything (of course) but the song just isn’t catchy at all.  Its a cute soundtrack and fits perfect with a movie, but thats it.

 

I only like the intro of the song, its so wierd (in a good way) and crazy which is exactly what i love and like about Gaga in songs.

 

umm ya so i’m just gonna continue to wait for LG7 and just let this song…..die 

 

 

 

You should really compare HMH to TIHTY, another single song she wrote for a movie. ASIB was a once in a career moment, and that's okay, don't hold HMH to those all timer standards just yet

 

But obviously HMH is way better than TIHTY

7 minutes ago, Vrajesh said:

That sounds amazing wdym

stay pressed

 

Your taste, ew 

 These Stupid Bomb fans are really the true evil of our fanbase  

 

 

2 minutes ago, Mr. Stratus said:

The way the swfitie discord remember your melt downs over katy and britney in SYG and dont claim you. embarrassing

I have never had meltdowns over Katy and Britney. You're confusing me with someone else. 

 

 

 

OT: Hold my Hand panned. 

4 minutes ago, little legend said:

You tasteless rat slugs deserve an album full with Stupid Loves, Swines, Dopes and Plastic Trashes. 

 

The GP will make this song a hit cause it's amazing. 

Stay pressed 

All those 4 songs are excellent and **** on Hold My Razzie  

 

some of us just like creativity and art over boring Mariah/Whitney rehashes 

Just now, WildAmerican said:

You should really compare HMH to TIHTY, another single song she wrote for a movie. ASIB was a once in a career moment, and that's okay, don't hold HMH to those all timer standards just yet

 

But obviously HMH is way better than TIHTY

no its not

only when she decides to working with bloopop and no other talented songwriters/producers

 

 

1 hour ago, jijie101 said:

Anyway, when will the MV be released?

soon 
Gonna make such a bad visual for this song, the subreddit will 0 it 

1 minute ago, little legend said:

Your taste, ew 

 These Stupid Bomb fans are really the true evil of our fanbase  

 

 

Stupid Love = Top 5 

 

And HMH? 

Just now, Brooke Candy said:

We kinda did sis, but thank god my expectations were low from the start.

 

Her vocals are everything (of course) but the song just isn’t catchy at all.  Its a cute soundtrack and fits perfect with a movie, but thats it.

 

I only like the intro of the song, its so wierd (in a good way) and crazy which is exactly what i love and like about Gaga in songs.

 

umm ya so i’m just gonna continue to wait for LG7 and just let this song…..die 

 

Your instict was right sis, sadly

 

wait it's not available in Dolby Atmos on Apple Music Bloodpop I HATE you omg 

3 minutes ago, Sombre said:

Uhh all I said a few pages back is that the song would have been better, in a production sense, if someone who's experienced with ballads worked on it, like Mark, instead of Bloodpop.

 

This is the base thread, of course we're gonna discuss the song. We're gonna dissect it bit by bit and comment on it. Your enjoyment of the song should not be hindered by what a few online strangers think of the song. Discussion is normal. Excessive hatred on the song with no added discussion is annoying, that I agree with.

I was implying at some who even quoted the OGH to prove their point in hating the song. It's annoying. I don't mind if someone wanted to discuss in improving since it's always welcomed. Agree with the last sentence!

Stupid Laugh betta enjoy ha final days in Ga's Spotify top 10

it's a great song.

it's serves it's purpose for a soundtrack. if you don't like it, just move on and stop ruining the experience for others.

 

at this point, we should all just be glad to see Gaga showing some sort of excitement around her own music again. feels good 

The way y'all want her to record another Shallow, but would still find something to ***** about if she did.

 

3 minutes ago, little legend said:

Your taste, ew 

 These Stupid Bomb fans are really the true evil of our fanbase  

 

 

2 minutes ago, Villanelle said:

I have never had meltdowns over Katy and Britney. You're confusing me with someone else. 

 

 

 

OT: Hold my Hand panned. 

@ATRL Feedback can we request a threadban for this user? Thank you.

 

-

HMH grows every single listen.

7 minutes ago, Pop said:

All those 4 songs are excellent and **** on Hold My Razzie  

 

some of us just like creativity and art over boring Mariah/Whitney rehashes 

After such comments , I feel so lucky to have such a superior taste. 

Wow sometimes even I , I am really impressed by myself. I am so grateful and thank god every day that i was born with 2 fully functional ears and amazing taste so i won't like Stupid Love. I feel blessed. Now it's time to hear again her next #1 smash Hold My Oscars