10 minutes ago, Pikachoo said:

Joanne

 

when i say the GP has taste for once its what that abomination deserves, heck shouldn't even be charting

Quranne is an alternative/indie/underground album, y'all wouldn't get it

 

 

It wasn't something to be liked it was something to be understood from an academic perspective, obviously y'all aren't academics

 

 

Toucanne is a cute girl but she’s worn out on me over the years

 

I kinda like Jopanned for some reason.  Maybe it's the folk elements idk, but she's a cute girl. 

Edited September 22, 20223 yr by Blade Runner

Bombanne is not bad, but it is so basic and boring compared to every other Gaga era (even CHARTDROP feels more ambitious and interesting). It truly drags and, in my opinion, doesn't feel really genuine.

 

Not even PI, DH, JW and DiC could save it.

 

Edited September 22, 20223 yr by Artur

Sorry but Joanne is better than ARTPOP & even Chromatica on some days. I just wish she went more Fleetwood Mac direction with her HAC album instead of HAG 

 

TFM

BTW

TF

J

Chrome 

AP

 

at the moment 

 

Joanne remains Gaga's worst album to date by a country mile (no pun intended). I can appreciate what she was trying to do, and I mean no disrespect to what she was going through when creating it, but it's by far her most uninspired and bland sounding album to date. It's not even that it's not dance-pop, as A Star Is Born (primarily) wasn't either and didn't have that problem (and ironically it was actually the dance-pop songs on A Star Is Born that had that problem).

TFM = BTW

TF = C

AP

J

 

 

It just hit me that her two best albums' names have 3 words

 

I think I’ve realized that Gaga’s voice is just made for EDM and electronic music. She is just too powerful to be convincing on indie songs which are more suited for people who have softer, more feminine voices. Gaga could pull off rock too, but EDM just suits her perfectly.

The way C worded album never charted in US with those US date, wtf? 

Which is Gaga’s least successful solo pop album? Joanne or ARTPOP? 
 

4 minutes ago, Vroom Vroom said:

Which is Gaga’s least successful solo pop album? Joanne or ARTPOP? 
 

What's a solo pop album? 

 

9 minutes ago, Vroom Vroom said:

Which is Gaga’s least successful solo pop album? Joanne or ARTPOP? 
 

Joanne. Artpop has developed a cult narrative and is having a critical reappraisal. And Applause was legitimately very big and feels like one of her signature songs (bar her obvious classics). People still use "live for the applause" jokes. 

5 hours ago, EnigmaticAndroid said:

Ranking her collabs! 

 

Jewels N Drugs

Cheek to Cheek (album)

Hey Girl

Sine From Above

DWUW ft. Xtina

Chillin

Love For Sale (album)

DWUW ft. R Kelly

Video Phone ft. Lady Gaga 

Just Dance 

Starstruck

I'll Never Love Again (Film Version)

Telephone

Sour Candy

Bradley Cooper's Shallow ft. Lady Gaga

Rain on Me

Find Yourself ft. Lady Gaga

#1. Big Girl Now  

 

 

i always forget that JD & Starstruck were collabs

 

Joanne is very near ARTPOP’s pure sales in the US, and it was released 3 years later.

outside US, Artpoop is bigger because of Joanne’s Americana sound.

well I’m saying that but after asib smashed harder outside US and same for Hold My Hand ☠️

1 hour ago, Phoenixstar said:

The way C worded album never charted in US with those US date, wtf? 

US = trash wbk

Just Dance / Shazam

 

 

#50 Belarus (-3)

#62 Ukraine (+7)

#79 Poland (-2)

#97 Czech Republic (+9)

#120 Hungary (+9)

#122 Finland (+21)

#125 Mexico (+30)

#130 Norway (+3)

#135 Australia (+4)

#137 Worldwide (+24)

#139 Germany (+13)

#144 New Zealand (NE)

#149 Kazakhstan (+22)

#154 Austria (+23)

#155 Canada (+8)

#159 Sweden (+14)

#177 Switzerland (+22)

#190 United States (+9)

I like Joanne but I mean I wouldn’t have been mad if she gave us a disco album instead

 

3 hours ago, Vroom Vroom said:

Which is Gaga’s least successful solo pop album? Joanne or ARTPOP? 
 

Joanne is her least successful overall.

I am glad Joan is forgotten and the gp pretends it doesn’t exist. 

Joanne is def her least successful album. It’s a good thing it won a Grammy tho.  

1 hour ago, Bhabylon said:

I like Joanne but I mean I wouldn’t have been mad if she gave us a disco album instead

 

I would love a mashup of disco, dance, r&b elements. 

I'm a Joanne stan, but yeah lets not have any more of that anytime soon. Maybe LG10.