On 6/17/2020 at 3:10 AM, SignificantOther said:

She's lucky so few new albums are debuting. It's making her chart-run look better. 

The album still has ~0% drop... are u dense honey? 
 

OT: Queen of pop. 

It is a sign which is a very good stable

 

 

 

 

 

9 hours ago, Yanko said:

the troll i quoted has been trying it the entire chromatica era to discredit its success boo

couldnt care less about savage tbh 

-

a stable hold

So you chose to inaccurately discredit the success of something else?

Not this thread at the eleventh page and OGH still trying

11 minutes ago, swissman said:

So you chose to inaccurately discredit the success of something else?

i didnt discredit anything  your beyhive friend is the one acting all brave and discrediting gagas success 

now move

-

Stable legend 

no fads allowed!

yeah tons of pure sales must be coming from bundles, she's not even #1 on iTunes and #1 on itunes must be selling very few copies (a random girl is #1 right now, not on HDD top20 prediction)

31 minutes ago, Starkboy said:

yeah tons of pure sales must be coming from bundles, she's not even #1 on iTunes and #1 on itunes must be selling very few copies (a random girl is #1 right now, not on HDD top20 prediction)

Candy Lover her power!

Extremely stable which is a good sign

Edited June 18, 20206 yr by ScarletWitch

44 minutes ago, Yanko said:

i didnt discredit anything  your beyhive friend is the one acting all brave and discrediting gagas success 

now move

-

Stable legend 

no fads allowed!

All I was saying was that even without bundles, Savage (Remix) would have went to #1 as it would have debuted at #1 if it had not been for the bundles of another song.

 

But yes let's move on... maybe even move on from holding every Hive member accountable for what someone else said to you?

 

OT: Congrats Gaga!

1 hour ago, Marioland said:

Why Beyonce stans are so pressed? Gaga contributed in Bey's legacy with telephone and we have 1 of the best female collaborations ever with these 2 legendary ladies...

1 hour ago, Starkboy said:

yeah tons of pure sales must be coming from bundles, she's not even #1 on iTunes and #1 on itunes must be selling very few copies (a random girl is #1 right now, not on HDD top20 prediction)

She was for most of the week. Then new releases happened.

8 hours ago, sadnews said:

 

 

thanks to new 11 merch bundles.

 

 

5 hours ago, sadnews said:

who is pressed? lol 

the album is stable because she released more bundles. that's all. duh.

 

4 hours ago, sadnews said:

her US shop was opened last week. and restock her signed cd multiple times.

 

 

HDD predicted 17~20k pure sales on their Tuesday prediction.

Billboard predicted 55k SPS on their Wednesday prediction.

 

gaga released new bundles on Wednesday to Thursday.

4 merchandise and signed poster exclusive to US, her sales rose to 30k pure/64k sps.

(I didn't know US exclusive singed poster.. wow)

 

 

 

and yes, she did promote her bundles through her emailing and twitter.

 

 

 

so considering her last minute bundles pulled big numbers last week. challenging lil baby, so HDD had to delay their chart to make sure it's correct.

 

and the fact tkat their last Tuesday prediction was 17~20k pure while this week is 25~30k pure indicate that their know the bundles. 

 

I'm simply discussing simple reason of 0% stability, this thread is making all about. this is chart thread after all. lol

The obsession   

 

Her store was shut down for more than half of her first week. OGH are so ****ing lucky that Gaga didn’t release Chromatica in normal circumstances... she would’ve smashed a lot harder and y’all would’ve been on suicide watch. 

1 hour ago, Starkboy said:

yeah tons of pure sales must be coming from bundles, she's not even #1 on iTunes and #1 on itunes must be selling very few copies (a random girl is #1 right now, not on HDD top20 prediction)

She was #1 in iTunes this week though. 

33 minutes ago, ViviLittleM said:

She was for most of the week. Then new releases happened.

 

6 minutes ago, Cherry123 said:

She was #1 in iTunes this week though. 

Friday-Saturday: #1 Chloe and Halle

Sunday-Tuesday: #1 Chromatica

Wednesday: #1 Stray Kids

Thursday (until now): #1 Candy Lover

 

right now: Phoebe Bridgers 

 

The point is, these nobodies are topping itunes, iTunes sales must be a nightmare for everybody, I'm not coming for Gaga. like 500 copies would be enough to top it.

for example Chloe and Halle are selling 5k pure sales all week despite spending 2 days at #1 (and that counts pre-orders, physical copies etc.). 

 

out of these 30k pure sales, iTunes sales could be 10k at the very best (and I'm being generous), otherwise Chromatica would have stayed at #1 easily all week and above these random artists.

CLEARLY IT WAS BECAUSE OF THE SUPERBOWL

26 minutes ago, Starkboy said:

 

Friday-Saturday: #1 Chloe and Halle

Sunday-Tuesday: #1 Chromatica

Wednesday: #1 Stray Kids

Thursday (until now): #1 Candy Lover

 

right now: Phoebe Bridgers 

 

The point is, these nobodies are topping itunes, iTunes sales must be a nightmare for everybody, I'm not coming for Gaga. like 500 copies would be enough to top it.

for example Chloe and Halle are selling 5k pure sales all week despite spending 2 days at #1 (and that counts pre-orders, physical copies etc.). 

 

out of these 30k pure sales, iTunes sales could be 10k at the very best (and I'm being generous), otherwise Chromatica would have stayed at #1 easily all week and above these random artists.

If you were not trying to shade Gaga, you wouldn't even bother to participate in this discussion 

 

Gaga is a known huge physical seller, the way you think just a bunch of her stans keeps buying thousands of copies every week. I-

 

iTunes is only for digital sales, there's Amazon aswell and other services. Her website is the 1st result when you google "buy lady gaga album" or anything similiar to that. 

 

And now you will quote me with "Where did I say that?"  when its obvious you are implying the album is stable only because of her fanbase

You know she's winning when there's so much mental gymnastic and failed attempts to downplay her current success

47 minutes ago, Hot Volcano said:

If you were not trying to shade Gaga, you wouldn't even bother to participate in this discussion 

 

Gaga is a known huge physical seller, the way you think just a bunch of her stans keeps buying thousands of copies every week. I-

 

iTunes is only for digital sales, there's Amazon aswell and other services. Her website is the 1st result when you google "buy lady gaga album" or anything similiar to that. 

 

And now you will quote me with "Where did I say that?"  when its obvious you are implying the album is stable only because of her fanbase

lol. this is a chart thread, if you're bothered by my posts analyzing charts things you can always ignore me if iTunes sales are DEAD you expect me to believe Amazon is selling tons of albums out of nothing? 

"known huge physical seller" yeah what happened to that power with Joanne 3rd week sales (when bundles weren't a thing)?  not to mention you were the one screaming there were protests and the virus hurting the album sales and now people are running to shops to buy physical copys? how does it work?

 

I've never said the album is stable only because of bundles, but I've been following charts for a while and right now I believe bundles are playing a part in its stability. 

 

1	NEW	Phoebe Bridgers - Punisher
2	=	Candy Lover - De La Nada
3	-2	Stray Kids - GO LIVE
4	-1	Lady Gaga - Chromatica

this is not an album selling 30k pure copies without bundles imo, not in 2020. No idea why my thoughts on this bother you to begin with, insecure too much?

 

 

29 minutes ago, Starkboy said:

lol. this is a chart thread, if you're bothered by my posts analyzing charts things you can always ignore me if iTunes sales are DEAD you expect me to believe Amazon is selling tons of albums out of nothing? 

"known huge physical seller" yeah what happened to that power with Joanne 3rd week sales (when bundles weren't a thing)?  not to mention you were the one screaming there were protests and the virus hurting the album sales and now people are running to shops to buy physical copys? how does it work?

 

I've never said the album is stable only because of bundles, but I've been following charts for a while and right now I believe bundles are playing a part in its stability. 

 

1	NEW	Phoebe Bridgers - Punisher
2	=	Candy Lover - De La Nada
3	-2	Stray Kids - GO LIVE
4	-1	Lady Gaga - Chromatica

this is not an album selling 30k pure copies without bundles imo, not in 2020. No idea why my thoughts on this bother you to begin with, insecure too much?

 

 

The way you always clock with facts. Beautiful

 

The Weeknd pulled great album sales only thanks to bundles, and Gaga is doing literally the same. I don't know why some have problems admitting this

 

 

2 minutes ago, Mark Rih said:

The way you always clock with facts. Beautiful

 

The Weeknd pulled great album sales only thanks to bundles, and Gaga is doing literally the same. I don't know why some have problems admitting this

 

 

Because it's not "only" thanks to bundles   And if bundles are something completely normal and "not a drag" "don't be insecure" why are y'all emphasizing so much on "Bundles!!1!11"  

The transparency  

Just now, Mariano said:

Because it's not "only" thanks to bundles   And if bundles are something completely normal and "not a drag" "don't be insecure" why are y'all emphasizing so much on "Bundles!!1!11"  

The transparency  

Not only but mostly

 

btw it's just chart commentary. Me, starkboy and others are always here discussing about everyone, it's just that y'all only visit the chart section when your fave is releasing and suddenly we're 'obsessed!!!' for just stating facts (not to mention I said my fave did the same exact thing)

2 minutes ago, Mariano said:

Because it's not "only" thanks to bundles   And if bundles are something completely normal and "not a drag" "don't be insecure" why are y'all emphasizing so much on "Bundles!!1!11"  

The transparency  

MTE, you took the words out of my mouth.

 

I think @Starkboy was implying in a shady way the bundles are the only reason the album is doing this good as if it's a cheap tactic to use bundles to inflate your sales

2 minutes ago, Mark Rih said:

Not only but mostly

 

btw it's just chart commentary. Me, starkboy and others are always here discussing about everyone, it's just that y'all only visit the chart section when your fave is releasing and suddenly we're 'obsessed!!!' for just stating facts (not to mention I said my fave did the same exact thing)

nice try  

 

You act unbothered here, but then you and Starkboy run in SYG to circle jerk with the OGH   Anyway I honestly don't care, u do u, just wanted to say that what you said was hypocritical imo, if it's okay that it's selling bundles, then it shouldn't matter enough for u to single them out. They don't even make 50% of the total units  

Edited June 18, 20206 yr by Mariano

1 minute ago, Mariano said:

nice try  

 

You act unbothered here, but then you and Starkboy run in SYG to circle jerk with the OGH   Anyway I honestly don't care, u do u, just wanted to say that what you said was hypocritical imo, if it's okay that it's selling bundles, then it shouldn't matter enough for u to single them out. They don't even make 50% of the total sales  

I can tell

 

 

We're only stating that the main reason why Chromatica will be #1-2 (and barely dropping in SPS) this week is bundles. Without them it would be still top 10 (maybe even top 5) on the third week which is good for her and better than her previous era (she actually has a hit this time so that helps). This is what I think looking at the stats, you can think what you prefer

 

 

1 minute ago, Mark Rih said:

 

We're only stating that the main reason why Chromatica will be #1-2 (and barely dropping in SPS) this week is bundles.

Why? Why the need to state this? :Fsdg=sdvnj   Don't answer sis let's end this here hihi. 

 

OT: Queen