Starkboy is usually pretty objective with maybe just a sprinkle of shade (same for Mark Rih but with a bit more than just a sprinkle of shade ), so don't go too hard on them! Chromatica is doing well and it is indeed in part – but not completely – because of the bundles, there's no shame in realizing that. If anything, it's about time Gaga decided to play the game.

21 minutes ago, Mariano said:

nice try  

 

You act unbothered here, but then you and Starkboy run in SYG to circle jerk with the OGH  

The cute exposé

phoebe getting a #1? i'm kinda shocked but congrats to her

10 minutes ago, Pop Art said:

Starkboy is usually pretty objective with maybe just a sprinkle of shade (same for Mark Rih but with a bit more than just a sprinkle of shade ), so don't go too hard on them! Chromatica is doing well and it is indeed in part – but not completely – because of the bundles, there's no shame in realizing that. If anything, it's about time Gaga decided to play the game.

Nobody is denying it. But why single out Gaga and then say you don't mean it in a bad way 

Just now, Hot Volcano said:

Nobody is denying it. But why single out Gaga and then say you don't mean it in a bad way 

I...don't think they were singling out Gaga in a thread primarily about her though.  Trust, I'm the first to call out OGH BS, but I didn't get that vibe from Starkboy's posts in here (or in most other threads bar a few light drags in SYG).

29 minutes ago, Mariano said:

nice try  

 

You act unbothered here, but then you and Starkboy run in SYG to circle jerk with the OGH   Anyway I honestly don't care, u do u, just wanted to say that what you said was hypocritical imo, if it's okay that it's selling bundles, then it shouldn't matter enough for u to single them out. They don't even make 50% of the total units  

The clock 

the mess in here. 

I've ALWAYS underlined bundles impact on charts, on both singles and albums department and about everyone. Never been a fan, never will. I've "criticized" The Weeknd's tactics (as @Mark Rih mentioned) cause yeah his first month sales were always influenced by new bundles each week. I've "protested" about Kenny Chesney's bundles and so on.

I'm not gonna bother finding those posts but if you want to accuse me of "pointing out Gaga in a shady way" you should make a quick research on the previous charts threads before. 

it wasn't a problem then now it's a problem cause it's Gaga? so now I'm not allowed to talk about bundles and charts things in a chart thread because of stans insecurities? 

 

The thing is, I wasn't even complaining, starting a war or anything. I was just pointing out that bundles must have been helping. Regardless, I'm gonna keep posting whatever I want and pointing out bundles impact for Gaga and all artists. If you have a problem with it start reporting and stop quoting me.

28 minutes ago, Pop Art said:

I...don't think they were singling out Gaga in a thread primarily about her though.  Trust, I'm the first to call out OGH BS, but I didn't get that vibe from Starkboy's posts in here (or in most other threads bar a few light drags in SYG).

thanks for this. Again I have no idea what SYG posts (which is supposed to be where dumb stans wars happen) have to do this. And we're talking about what? posts where I compare Chromatica's streams to other female albums numbers? Yeah, how OGH of me. 

at this point I believe that member has just a problem with me cause I strongly dislike an artist he stans for (who isn't Gaga)

10 minutes ago, Starkboy said:

the mess in here. 

I've ALWAYS underlined bundles impact on charts, on both singles and albums department and about everyone. Never been a fan, never will. I've "criticized" The Weeknd's tactics (as @Mark Rih mentioned) cause yeah his first month sales were always influenced by new bundles each week. I've "protested" about Kenny Chesney's bundles and so on.

I'm not gonna bother finding those posts but if you want to accuse me of "pointing out Gaga in a shady way" you should make a quick research on the previous charts threads. 

it wasn't a problem then now it's a problem cause it's Gaga? so now I'm not allowed to talk about bundles and charts things in a chart thread because of stans insecurities? 

 

The thing is, I wasn't even complaining, starting a war or anything. I was just pointing out that bundles must have been helping. I'm gonna keep posting whatever I want and start ignoring those posts, feel free to report me I guess.

35 minutes ago, Starkboy said:

the mess in here. 

I've ALWAYS underlined bundles impact on charts, on both singles and albums department and about everyone. Never been a fan, never will. I've "criticized" The Weeknd's tactics (as @Mark Rih mentioned) cause yeah his first month sales were always influenced by new bundles each week. I've "protested" about Kenny Chesney's bundles and so on.

I'm not gonna bother finding those posts but if you want to accuse me of "pointing out Gaga in a shady way" you should make a quick research on the previous charts threads before. 

it wasn't a problem then now it's a problem cause it's Gaga? so now I'm not allowed to talk about bundles and charts things in a chart thread because of stans insecurities? 

 

The thing is, I wasn't even complaining, starting a war or anything. I was just pointing out that bundles must have been helping. Regardless, I'm gonna keep posting whatever I want and pointing out bundles impact for Gaga and all artists. If you have a problem with it start reporting and stop quoting me.

ikr. 

40 minutes ago, Starkboy said:

thanks for this. Again I have no idea what SYG posts (which is supposed to be where dumb stans wars happen) have to do this. And we're talking about what? posts where I compare Chromatica's streams to other female albums numbers? Yeah, how OGH of me. 

at this point I believe that member has just a problem with me cause I strongly dislike an artist he stans for (who isn't Gaga)

Who is this artist ?

1 hour ago, Starkboy said:

thanks for this. Again I have no idea what SYG posts (which is supposed to be where dumb stans wars happen) have to do this. And we're talking about what? posts where I compare Chromatica's streams to other female albums numbers? Yeah, how OGH of me. 

at this point I believe that member has just a problem with me cause I strongly dislike an artist he stans for (who isn't Gaga)

or maybe a have a crush on you  

 

oh please, everyone here hates Camila including half of Gaga's fans and yet I communicate with them on a daily basis

 

OT : can't wait for HDD to reveal the final chart on Friday! Gaga having another 60k+ week would be such a pleasent thing to see

On 6/16/2020 at 6:39 PM, mcohen said:

Stable. She won 

We love when female pop stars win. 

2 hours ago, Pop Art said:

Starkboy is usually pretty objective with maybe just a sprinkle of shade (same for Mark Rih but with a bit more than just a sprinkle of shade ), so don't go too hard on them! Chromatica is doing well and it is indeed in part – but not completely – because of the bundles, there's no shame in realizing that. If anything, it's about time Gaga decided to play the game.

 

but yeah I give her credit when it's due. Chromatica debut was good and she's holding up nicely even if she's using bundles

 

2 hours ago, Starkboy said:

the mess in here. 

I've ALWAYS underlined bundles impact on charts, on both singles and albums department and about everyone. Never been a fan, never will. I've "criticized" The Weeknd's tactics (as @Mark Rih mentioned) cause yeah his first month sales were always influenced by new bundles each week. I've "protested" about Kenny Chesney's bundles and so on.

I'm not gonna bother finding those posts but if you want to accuse me of "pointing out Gaga in a shady way" you should make a quick research on the previous charts threads before. 

it wasn't a problem then now it's a problem cause it's Gaga? so now I'm not allowed to talk about bundles and charts things in a chart thread because of stans insecurities? 

 

The thing is, I wasn't even complaining, starting a war or anything. I was just pointing out that bundles must have been helping. Regardless, I'm gonna keep posting whatever I want and pointing out bundles impact for Gaga and all artists. If you have a problem with it start reporting and stop quoting me.

Amen.

2 hours ago, Starkboy said:

I strongly dislike an artist he stans for (who isn't Gaga)

Don’t leave us hanging sis who is the artist?? 

2 hours ago, Wewee said:

Who is this artist ?

 

33 minutes ago, Miss Anthropocene said:

Don’t leave us hanging sis who is the artist?? 

Starts with a C and rhymes with payola tequila.

29 minutes ago, Pop Art said:

 

Starts with a C and rhymes with payola tequila.

 

No shade actually, I loved her debut 

5 hours ago, Hot Volcano said:

MTE, you took the words out of my mouth.

 

I think @Starkboy was implying in a shady way the bundles are the only reason the album is doing this good as if it's a cheap tactic to use bundles to inflate your sales

He always does this glad you guys are finally seeing this lol 

Even without bundles she would probably still be doing 40-45k ish, so still placing #2. 

On 6/17/2020 at 2:10 AM, Mystic Boy said:

OGHs since the last 3 weeks :

 

OT : This is truly impressive

This is so ****ing true 

Without promo and without her lifting a finger! Not everybody has that!

Thanks Gaga!

4 hours ago, SignificantOther said:

Even without bundles she would probably still be doing 40-45k ish, so still placing #2. 

Oh wow.. you spilled

 

Even without bundles she'll still be no.2 and that's a massive WIN considering ATRLers are expecting her to fall out of top10 this week

Queen of Pop

the way it will probably stay in the top 10 longer than any of her albums if she starts promoting more 

1 hour ago, perfectillusion said:

the way it will probably stay in the top 10 longer than any of her albums if she starts promoting more 

Didn't The Fame do like 53 weeks?