54 minutes ago, pieuxvu said:

The Gaga fans in here sreaming " stable"  and attack people that provide information.

 

1-2-2 , extremely stable indeed..

 

98-OUT can't relate

1 minute ago, pieuxvu said:

Bundles helped. You can't deny it.

- Albums with bundles, dropped more the week later.

- Chromatica droped 80-90% in pure sales last week and increases this week.

Without bundle, the album SPS wouldn't be -0% and you know that.

 

 

Who said BUNDLES didnt help???

1 minute ago, Cryptique said:

1-2-2 , extremely stable indeed..

 

98-OUT can't relate

1-2-2-2 : extremely stable indeed...

1-5-10-1x can't relate 

2 minutes ago, Cryptique said:

Who said BUNDLES didnt help???

All the users that screamed " stable". 

Can't wait to see next week numbers.

3 minutes ago, pieuxvu said:

1-2-2-2 : extremely stable indeed...

1-5-10-1x can't relate 

98-OUT can't relate more 

 

Let the ANGER Out

 

1 minute ago, pieuxvu said:

All the users that screamed " stable". 

Can't wait to see next week numbers.

And those users are correct.. extremely stable indeed 

 

Y'all also said that after the 2nd week 

2 minutes ago, pieuxvu said:

All the users that screamed " stable". 

Can't wait to see next week numbers.

it’s always “let’s see next week numbers” with Gaga, but every week. 

3 minutes ago, Cryptique said:

98-OUT can't relate more 

 

Let the ANGER Out

 

And those users are correct.. extremely stable indeed 

 

Y'all also said that after the 2nd week 

Extremely stable indeed. Only -90%

Good for her standard 

 

1 minute ago, pieuxvu said:

Extremely stable indeed. Only -90%

Good for her standard 

 

274 -> 64 is 77% drop

204 -> 29 is 86% drop

 

thank u for confirming that you should not be taken seriously with numbers

19 minutes ago, pieuxvu said:

Bundles helped. You can't deny it.

- Albums with bundles, dropped more the week later.

- Chromatica droped 80-90% in pure sales last week and increases this week.

Without bundle, the album SPS wouldn't be -0% and you know that.

Please tell me where I said bundles didn't help. Quickly.

1 hour ago, Pop Art said:

Bundles or no bundles, how is a ~0% drop not stable like you're implying?  Are YOU stable sis?

 the OGH are so unstable, it’s not a good sign  

1 hour ago, pieuxvu said:

1-2-2-2 : extremely stable indeed...

1-5-10-1x can't relate 

that's actually pretty stable for a #1 debut in the streaming era. No matter what a song always needs to build on radio. Anything else?

6 hours ago, Pop Art said:

The unbiased truth, as someone already pointed out, is that even if bundles are helping a lot, there's no way to know what the album's "true" sales would be without them because trying to just remove them entirely isn't accurate either since those who bought the album via a bundle very well could have done so without the bundle. It's like how you guys defend Lemonade's pure sales when people argue they would be lower without the Tidal exclusive deal/with the album being available on all streaming platforms – it's all "what ifs" and to parade those around as if they're receipts is foolish. Yes you can definitely argue Chromatica's pure sales would be lower without the bundles (just as one can argue Lemonade's would be lower if it was available more widely), but not to the extent of trying to find the sales minus bundles and presenting that as the "real" sales. Now THAT is sad.

Well said

7 hours ago, Before the Dawn said:

This is the HDD thread, the Rolling Stone charts are a different thing. 

 

I think miss @Timber is derailing the thread with OFF TOPIC discussions. Wouldn't you agree @Yanko @Mariano @Cryptique @perfectillusion? 

You do know that HDD and RollingStone both use numbers from buzz angle right? They’re the same thing.

If the numbers are accurate, it's really impressive

HDD is over. Predictions are so inaccurate these days.

 

 

64K to 44K is a -31% drop. Why does the OP title say ~0% ?

 

 

 

Just now, ViviLittleM said:

HDD is over. Predictions are so inaccurate these days.

when everyone is using bundles like what do you expect its a prediction for a reason

8 hours ago, Before the Dawn said:

This is the HDD thread, the Rolling Stone charts are a different thing. 

 

I think miss @Timber is derailing the thread with OFF TOPIC discussions. Wouldn't you agree @Yanko @Mariano @Cryptique @perfectillusion? 

Yes i agree hee need to move already 

-31%
extremely stable

 

Even with a 31% drop these are still good numbers 

 

Gaga stays winning

How did the 0% go to -31%  Aren’t HDD usually so on point with these predictions 

5 minutes ago, Fnooky said:

Maybe the CHROMATICA briefs, thongs, jockstraps, the Rain On Me umbrellas and boots as well as the Sour Candy face masks didn't sell as much as expected.

 

16 minutes ago, istan4badgalriri said:

 

 

64K to 44K is a -31% drop. Why does the OP title say ~0% ?

 

 

 

the fact you ran is embarrassing  

1 minute ago, infrared said:

the fact you ran is embarrassing  

OP ran faster than me with that swift title change  

 

OT: Stable, great sign

23 minutes ago, istan4badgalriri said:

 

 

64K to 44K is a -31% drop. Why does the OP title say ~0% ?

 

 

 

Congrats on being so fast, sis. I'm sure it made your day 

 

More good numbers for Gaga