I think this website NEEDs a Christina Aguilera discography rate asap

4 hours ago, Frappucino said:

I think this website NEEDs a Christina Aguilera discography rate asap

Will that be the first rate where the winning song doesn't even break a 7.0 average?

Trouble took place but PJ Harvey: The Classics has concluded and the winner is:

SPOILER

Rid Of Me!

We should do the Madonna discography rate in 3 parts according to phases of her career, then the top 20 songs from each part go on to a part 4 to determine once and for all what the best M song is

I'm thinking 1982 (Everybody) to... 1997 I guess (Another Suitcase in Another Hall ) for part 1, 1998 (Ray of Light) to 2009 (Celebration) for part 2, and everything after that for part 3, which will be a massive kii

Her discog is already segmented for us.

Immaculate Collection Years.

GHV2 Years.

Celebration Years.

The rest.

56 minutes ago, conatus said:

We should do the Madonna discography rate in 3 parts according to phases of her career, then the top 20 songs from each part go on to a part 4 to determine once and for all what the best M song is

I'm thinking 1982 (Everybody) to... 1997 I guess (Another Suitcase in Another Hall ) for part 1, 1998 (Ray of Light) to 2009 (Celebration) for part 2, and everything after that for part 3, which will be a massive kii

This drag race all-stars format

2 hours ago, conatus said:

We should do the Madonna discography rate in 3 parts according to phases of her career, then the top 20 songs from each part go on to a part 4 to determine once and for all what the best M song is

I'm thinking 1982 (Everybody) to... 1997 I guess (Another Suitcase in Another Hall ) for part 1, 1998 (Ray of Light) to 2009 (Celebration) for part 2, and everything after that for part 3, which will be a massive kii

What ever happened to full discography rates of artists with more than 5-6 albums. No one wants to work anymore huh?

3 hours ago, That Bad Eartha said:

What ever happened to full discography rates of artists with more than 5-6 albums. No one wants to work anymore huh?

So when are you hosting

4 hours ago, Graves said:

Her discog is already segmented for us.

Immaculate Collection Years.

GHV2 Years.

Celebration Years.

The rest.

Hm what's that song split looking like in terms of number of songs because I tried to factor that in too so it wasn't lopsided in one direction

4 hours ago, Eeveelution said:

This drag race all-stars format

It's what the queen of all queens deserves

18 minutes ago, conatus said:

So when are you hosting

I'd do it in the fall after the Jessie Ware one (that will be launching in the next couple days) ends if no one else wants to do it. But I did her essentials rate back in the day though, so I don't want to hog the Madge rates if someone else is wanting to host a big one for her.

But either way, we def need to wait and give a proper refractory period for post-Confessions II nut clarity to set in because how tf did Devil Pray and Veni Vidi Vici manage to crack the top 10 of that essentials rate

1 hour ago, That Bad Eartha said:

I'd do it in the fall after the Jessie Ware one (that will be launching in the next couple days) ends if no one else wants to do it. But I did her essentials rate back in the day though, so I don't want to hog the Madge rates if someone else is wanting to host a big one for her.

But either way, we def need to wait and give a proper refractory period for post-Confessions II nut clarity to set in because how tf did Devil Pray and Veni Vidi Vici manage to crack the top 10 of that essentials rate

LTTWM, Mer Girl, and Waiting all making top 10 balances it out though kinda. The taste that was demonstrated...

Couldn't even tell you what VVV sounds like off the top of my head though, I'll be honest.

8 hours ago, conatus said:

We should do the Madonna discography rate in 3 parts according to phases of her career, then the top 20 songs from each part go on to a part 4 to determine once and for all what the best M song is

I'm thinking 1982 (Everybody) to... 1997 I guess (Another Suitcase in Another Hall ) for part 1, 1998 (Ray of Light) to 2009 (Celebration) for part 2, and everything after that for part 3, which will be a massive kii

I've changed my mind. We should do it all in one.

42 minutes ago, conatus said:

I've changed my mind. We should do it all in one.

How else will we know how Jimmy Jimmy stacks up against Killers Who Are Partying

32 minutes ago, That Bad Eartha said:

How else will we know how Jimmy Jimmy stacks up against Killers Who Are Partying

I just wanted the kii of seeing which random 2010s songs filled the four spots of the top 20 that Confessions II wouldn't fill but yeah. The I'm Going Bananas vs. Spanish Lesson showdown is also too good of an opportunity to pass up.

I'm… willing to host an M discography rate if we do it at the end of the year.

we getting Spanish Lesson in the top 30

11 hours ago, conatus said:

We should do the Madonna discography rate in 3 parts

BOOT

5 hours ago, That Bad Eartha said:

But either way, we def need to wait and give a proper refractory period for post-Confessions II nut clarity to set in because how tf did Devil Pray and Veni Vidi Vici manage to crack the top 10 of that essentials rate

That rate was caaaamp I remember it so fondly

Edited July 7Jul 7 by HonourableVomit

My 11 was Borrowed Time

Just now, HonourableVomit said:

My 11 was Borrowed Time

4 minutes ago, HonourableVomit said:

BOOT

.

I think that was during my Hard Candy phase… blunder years.

Let's hope mother herself doesn't send a ballot…

5 hours ago, California said:

we getting Spanish Lesson in the top 30

“Yo te quiero” means “it’s finishing last”

On 7/4/2026 at 6:34 PM, Kabrona said:

I want a grunge rate idgaf if only 5 people participate

Nirvana vs Pearl Jam vs Hole vs Soundgarden vs Alice in Chains vs Avril Lavigne

ALMOST.

The four male bands - throw in STP please!