On 6/23/2026 at 1:28 PM, Florence Belch said:

Whew, adding TS to the 2006 MtW rate would mean seeing many hilarious comments and a savage battle for the lowest album score ever, I'm here for it

You always see the vision. Don't let anyone tell you otherwise!

On 7/5/2026 at 6:54 AM, HonourableVomit said:

Trouble took place but PJ Harvey: The Classics has concluded and the winner is:

SPOILER

Rid Of Me!

Well, yes!

16 hours ago, conatus said:

We should do the Madonna discography rate in 3 parts according to phases of her career, then the top 20 songs from each part go on to a part 4 to determine once and for all what the best M song is

I'm thinking 1982 (Everybody) to... 1997 I guess (Another Suitcase in Another Hall ) for part 1, 1998 (Ray of Light) to 2009 (Celebration) for part 2, and everything after that for part 3, which will be a massive kii

1982 - 1991 (Everybody - the Immaculate Collection.)

1992 - 2001 (Erotica to GHV2)

2003 - 2026 (Everything else!)

Please and thank you! And give that third edition unlimited zeroes please. whole albums need to be demolished.

We have five rates going on! Good job @Armani., @conatus, @Florence Belch, @MP2K, and @Solarial

I want MOAR.

6 hours ago, Graves said:

I'm… willing to host an M discography rate if we do it at the end of the year.

I've seen enough - we're redoing 1996 Makes The Woman. (Sorry @madonnas - I luv u 4ever.) Why don't you rejigger the lineup and host that?

7 hours ago, conatus said:

I've changed my mind. We should do it all in one.

Why don't you KILL me.

4 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

I've seen enough - we're redoing 1996 Makes The Woman. (Sorry @madonnas - I luv u 4ever.) Why don't you rejigger the lineup and host that?

Toni, Kim, Fiona, Tori, Céline, Aaliyah please!

Sorry to Sheryl and Foxy. And Bahamadia. And Faye!

9 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

I've seen enough - we're redoing 1996 Makes The Woman. (Sorry @madonnas - I luv u 4ever.) Why don't you rejigger the lineup and host that?

I'm only hosting rates that spark joy, and…

3 minutes ago, conatus said:

Toni, Kim, Fiona, Tori, Céline, Aaliyah please!

Sorry to Sheryl and Foxy. And Bahamadia. And Faye!

This is going to be a pass from me.

Just now, Graves said:

I'm only hosting rates that spark joy, and…

This is going to be a pass from me.

Do it... for Toni.

Sorry, I'm passing on it.

Call me if that M rate ever comes back to the forefront.

5 minutes ago, conatus said:

Toni, Kim, Fiona, Tori, Céline, Aaliyah please!

Sorry to Sheryl and Foxy. And Bahamadia. And Faye!

1 minute ago, Graves said:

I'm only hosting rates that spark joy, and…

This is going to be a pass from me.

1 minute ago, conatus said:

Do it... for Toni.

REAL TALK the length of Tori's album... left me hopeless.

Just now, Graves said:

Sorry, I'm passing on it.

Call me if that M rate ever comes back to the forefront.

Are you down with the three-parter (because I fully intend to skip the last part, but be an active and vocal participant in the first two?)

Or splitting Prince 80s into two like we discussed? Everything until Purple Rain and everything after?

We can work it out.mp3

While we're on the topic, it's already been too long since we had a Makes the Woman. I know I'm going to be hard to top, but come on now.

1 minute ago, conatus said:

While we're on the topic, it's already been too long since we had a Makes the Woman. I know I'm going to be hard to top, but come on now.

@Eeveelution https://youtu.be/wctSPgfhNKc?si=UAUEIlFXJeo5jcgq

Don't make me suggest The 90s Made The Man! Because I will!

3 minutes ago, conatus said:

I know I'm going to be hard to top

6 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Are you down with the three-parter (because I fully intend to skip the last part, but be an active and vocal participant in the first two?)

Or splitting Prince 80s into two like we discussed? Everything until Purple Rain and everything after?

We can work it out.mp3

I'm still open to Princess, I just want you to get that Stevie rate through the gate first.

As for Madeath, I could work with either. I think the girls hate splitting these things up tho.

5 minutes ago, California said:

And where is YOUR rate, beloved?

2 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

And where is YOUR rate, beloved?

the Mylene Farmer discography rate shall commence a month after the release of her upcoming album

see you in December

5 minutes ago, California said:

the Mylene Farmer discography rate shall commence a month after the release of her upcoming album

see you in December

clairo stan be gone

7 minutes ago, California said:

the Mylene Farmer discography rate shall commence a month after the release of her upcoming album

see you in December

1 minute ago, Eeveelution said:

I think you two need to SQUARE UP.

In my next rate? Or @supaspaz's? We shall see!

Clairo discography rate after C4

18 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Don't make me suggest The 90s Made The Man! Because I will!

And this lineup would be Brown Sugar/Grace/Born to Die/All Eyez on Me/Odelay, for anyone wondering!

(XO/Maxwell's Urban Hang Suite/Illmatic/Reasonable Doubt/I've Been Expecting You for part two!)

1 minute ago, Eeveelution said:

Clairo discography rate after C4