In theory watching a Swift album get torn apart in a rate should be a hoot, but only Achilles and greento ever show up for the Swifties so it's never that much fun. 

 

 

We do need to get one of her good albums in a rate again soon though... 2012MTW mayhaps?

 

Edited November 14, 2025Nov 14 by Graves

16 minutes ago, Graves said:

In theory watching a Swift album get torn apart in a rate should be a hoot, but only Achilles and greento ever show up for the Swifties so it's never that much fun. 

 

 

We do need to get one of her good albums in a rate again soon though... 2012MTW mayhaps?

 

Red vs. Born to Die vs. The Idler Wheel vs. Devotion vs. Kiss vs. Visions would be fun

 

Stick all the pop/slop in a part 2.

 

Warrior, Unapologetic, Roman Reloaded, Girl on Fire, The Truth About Love, The Spirit Indestructible.

 

 

EDIT: Completely forgot about MDNA

Edited November 14, 2025Nov 14 by conatus

4 minutes ago, conatus said:

Red vs. Born to Die vs. The Idler Wheel vs. Devotion vs. Kiss vs. Visions would be fun

 

Red still being a bottom 2 album here 

 

2 minutes ago, conatus said:

Stick all the pop/slop in a part 2.

 

Warrior, Unapologetic, Roman Reloaded, Girl on Fire, The Truth About Love, The Spirit Indestructible.

 

 

EDIT: Completely forgot about MDNA

Worst rate of all time confirmed.

 

Just now, Eeveelution said:

Red still being a bottom 2 album here 

 

Unfortunately I have to disagree. Swifties won this round.

 

1 minute ago, Eeveelution said:

Red still being a bottom 2 album here 

 

Maybe but State of Grace outmogs all of them.

 

4 minutes ago, conatus said:

Red vs. Born to Die vs. The Idler Wheel vs. Devotion vs. Kiss vs. Visions would be fun

 

These MAGAs, only M.I.A. is missing.

 

Just now, Graves said:

Worst rate of all time confirmed.

 

Laugh react about to go crazy in that one

 

3 minutes ago, conatus said:

Stick all the pop/slop in a part 2.

 

Warrior, Unapologetic, Roman Reloaded, Girl on Fire, The Truth About Love, The Spirit Indestructible.

 

 

EDIT: Completely forgot about MDNA

TSI sweeping

 

Just now, conatus said:

Laugh react about to go crazy in that one

 

Honestly, my 2010 idea from a while back got shut down but I think it could be fun to lean into the trash of it all. A race to the bottom rate.

 

4 minutes ago, conatus said:

Stick all the pop/slop in a part 2.

 

Warrior, Unapologetic, Roman Reloaded, Girl on Fire, The Truth About Love, The Spirit Indestructible.

 

 

EDIT: Completely forgot about MDNA

You also forgot Glassheart by your fave Leona

 

Edited November 14, 2025Nov 14 by Eeveelution

Just now, California said:

TSI sweeping

 

Rihanna and the White Rihanna (Nelly) top 2 showdown

 

1 minute ago, Graves said:

Honestly, my 2010 idea from a while back got shut down but I think it could be fun to lean into the trash of it all. A race to the bottom rate.

 

Refresh my memory

 

1 minute ago, Eeveelution said:

You also forgot Glassheart by your Leona

 

Well we have to give the other girls a chance

 

1 minute ago, conatus said:

Rihanna and the White Rihanna (Nelly) top 2 showdown

 

though The Truth About Lesbians has some classics

 

3 minutes ago, Graves said:

Maybe but Sad Beautiful Tragic outmogs all of them.

 

1 minute ago, conatus said:

Refresh my memory

 

Something like Pink Friday, Loud, Teenage Dream and the two Kesha albums. Those awful P!nk GH singles maybe. Multiple 0s on offer. 

 

Just now, California said:

though The Truth About Lesbians has some classics

 

Whatever we do, we won't look at the OldTRL signup thread at things I've hosted because...

 

Spoiler

True.

 

Just now, Graves said:

Something like Pink Friday, Loud, Teenage Dream and the two Kesha albums. Those awful P!nk GH singles maybe. Multiple 0s on offer. 

 

And if I said I would kind of be getting my life. Oh to be [redacted] years old again and still experiencing joy.

 

Just now, conatus said:

Whatever we do, we won't look at the OldTRL signup thread at things I've hosted because...

 

you're not that important so we sure won't

 

Just now, California said:

you're not that important so we sure won't

 

And to think, I carried you to a rate win

 

Just now, conatus said:

And if I said I would kind of be getting my life. Oh to be [redacted] years old again and still experiencing joy.

 

That was the vision, sister. A hedonistic trip through a trashy (yet nostalgic) era of pop. 2010 Makes The Prostitute. 

 

Just now, Graves said:

That was the vision, sister. A hedonistic trip through a trashy (yet nostalgic) era of pop. 2010 Makes The Prostitute. 

 

We should throw in Can't Be Tamed too for shits and giggles. Her Like a Virgin.

 

2018 MtW smashing means there's demand for rates with bad albums. Someone needs to make 2010 and/or 2012 happen