1 minute ago, conatus said:

We should throw in Can't Be Tamed too for shits and giggles. Her Like a Virgin.

 

Well, I was more thinking of albums that were actually popular in 2010...

 

we have a winner

 

 

1 hour ago, conatus said:

Red vs. Born to Die vs. The Idler Wheel vs. Devotion vs. Kiss vs. Visions would be fun

 

I was literally thinking of this the other day

 

i know Taylor would still get torn apart just because of how she's viewed atm despite Red being a masterpiece, but it would still be a fun one

2 minutes ago, greento said:

I was literally thinking of this the other day

 

i know Taylor would still get torn apart just because of how she's viewed atm despite Red being a masterpiece, but it would still be a fun one

I mean, if you factor in BTD not feeling as beloved now as Lana's later work (among her fanbase at least), Grimes being... what she is in 2025, and Devotion not seeming to be as liked among Jessie Ware fans compared to her 2020s work, I do think Taylor would probably fare better than we might expect. Could also make a case for people not caring as much for Kiss post-E•MO•TION. That's 5 of those albums having some kind of "strike" against them. (Fiona innocent, though I've personally cooled a lot on The Idler Wheel over time.) I agree though, would still be fun.

 

Spoiler

I think most of those albums feel tied to 2012 in a bad way, but Red has kind of remained evergreen.

 

 

Realising I'm kind of the Achilles of Lana stans and Born to Die would be dragged in that rate 

 

1 hour ago, conatus said:

Red vs. Born to Die vs. The Idler Wheel vs. Devotion vs. Kiss vs. Visions would be fun

 

Cut out Carly and that's the exact lineup I'm thinking.

 

Unapologetic v. Lotus v. Kiss v. Warrior v. MDNA for part two!

10 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Cut out Carly and that's the exact lineup I'm thinking.

 

Unapologetic v. Lotus v. Kiss v. Warrior v. MDNA for part two!

How could I forget about LOTUS by Best New Artist Grammy Winner Legend X?

 

Can't wait to give my 11 to Red Hot Kinda Love.

 

13 minutes ago, Eeveelution said:

Realising I'm kind of the Achilles of Lana stans and Born to Die would be dragged in that rate 

 

I wish I could say I would drag it too but I know as soon as I hear those opening notes of This is What Makes Us Girls...

 

13 minutes ago, Eeveelution said:

Realising I'm kind of the Achilles of Lana stans and Born to Die would be dragged in that rate 

 

Love you, but I'm already sharpening my knives with glee.

 

 

11 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Cut out Carly and that's the exact lineup I'm thinking.

 

Unapologetic v. Lotus v. Kiss v. Warrior v. MDNA for part two!

Oh, now HERE'S the worst rate of all time. Looks like fun.

Feels unfair sticking Kiss there considering it was reasonably acclaimed (it made the P&J list!) and had a monster hit but I guess it beats having to relisten to Roman Reloaded or Girl on Fire in 2025 (probably 2026)

 

3 minutes ago, Graves said:

Love you, but I'm already sharpening my knives with glee.

 

 

Oh, now HERE'S the worst rate of all time. Looks like fun.

It'll be nice to shut your brain off for once!

 

And give CRJ all your tens!

11 hours ago, MP2K said:

hm, I could rock with this before or after the Darkchild rate. 

Are we sure we're setting this SOMBR guy up for success though? 

He is the guy that would do the best there - could sub him out for GOAT Lola Young tho...

I guess I'll come prepared with BTD's streaming stats

 

 

Just now, Ace Reject said:

He is the guy that would do the best there - could sub him out for GOAT Lola Young tho...

Nobody wants the twink. Technically cheating but Bird's Eye by Ravyn could work? Released in 2024 but breakout hit was this year.

 

I wonder what the absolute worst MTW line-up we could come up with is. Which year had pretty much nothing to offer?

 

Just now, Eeveelution said:

Nobody wants the twink. Technically cheating but Bird's Eye by Ravyn could work? Released in 2024 but breakout hit was this year.

 

Here's how we can actually sneak Jae Stephens in

 

Lotus and MDNA being two of the most poorly-mixed albums of all time. Our poor ears!

 

1 minute ago, Graves said:

Lotus and MDNA being two of the most poorly-mixed albums of all time. Our poor ears!

 

Excited for people who have never heard Xtina's Make the Eardrums Burst to experience that for the first time

 

Just now, conatus said:

Excited for people who have never heard Xtina's Make the Eardrums Burst to experience that for the first time

 

Fat, nasty & broke drag queen era X save me.

 

3 minutes ago, conatus said:

Here's how we can actually sneak Jae Stephens in

 

I'm shocked you didn't sneak Sellout into your conatus-core albums rate

 

Just now, Eeveelution said:

I'm shocked you didn't sneak Sellout into your conatus-core albums rate

 

I'd be lying if I said I wasn't tempted

 

Had to wait and see what Total Sellout was actually going to be though

 

The concept of FKA twigs and Erika being conatus-core...

 

8 minutes ago, conatus said:

The concept of FKA twigs and Erika being conatus-core...

 

I forgot you were an OFKAH. Sad!

 

Just now, Eeveelution said:

I forgot you were an OFKAH. Sad!

 

If you host TW2025, I apologise in advance for what I will be doing to Eusexua.