smartalek22

That isn't even part of the wildest borders of the "promised" land even if we take that Bible verse by face value?

As admin of the secret XTina discord, I can confirm this is true. I token Stan flops like Ava max and Poppy to hide my REAL fav legend x to stir up fan wars between Little Monsters and Britney army.

I just know the evil evil Britney Spears & Lady Gaga fans on atrl and twitter sabotaged her

Yes, inactivity alone cannot possibly explain it.

You can say it's because she hasn't been active, but is Katy Perry being active really beneficial to her catalogue streams instead of those streams being high in spite of her embarrassing herself every time she pops up? No matter what, the streams from the 21 and 25 hits should be much higher given how much bigger those eras were at the time than every hit that outstreams them now.

Wait who is this blonde girl she's hot af

She was global up till charmbracelet. By TEOM she even lost Japan, which is surprising. After that each new era became more and more US-centric in the percentage of their sales. And I believe Memoirs was her last era of international promo in any capacity, so we now have 15 years+ of her focus being exclusively in the USA. Not even other Anglo countries. It would make sense most users on here and Twitter won't remember living through an era of hers in their country regardless of what the historical numbers show. The Christmas song itself is also clearly bigger than the artist.

Apparently not acting like a caricature = "respectability politics" so you can't argue with these people

I think it's been like that at the top of their chart for a while When was the last time an international sound crossover type song was a big hit there maybe Billie?

No

What's the difference between the two concepts?

Time to put on a classy suit and cosplay Adele again

So superstition ?

I speak on behalf of all Katycats and Fighters when I say Jack productions are too quiet, bland and underproduced and all Jack clients have weak, bland, colourless voices who make extremely unexciting music

None

Discourse, long paragraphs and USA media articles don't translate into real world General Public consuming your music

I can pass the jonas brothers around too

But does Mr Beast have to translate into your dated definition of a "star" if he's made hundreds of millions doing what he does?

This is pretty much what most "Gaga antis" think tbh

They knew they had to end GaGa that day

sauce of image?

@Kayseri Mantisi

I would say that is a Twitter/internet only standard, but then again so is this "outrage" about this Beyonce news so we're back to square one. In any case this won't have any effect on Beyoncé's success so that's that

And miley was correctly labeled a culture vulture so

She's been lipping her big English hits for ages now and those will be as usual. But this residency being in France is interesting because she actually rarely lipped French songs.