Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (â‹®) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

BGKC

ATRL Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by BGKC

  1. Taylor Swift probably should have lip-synced more throughout her career. I know she isn't entirely unfamiliar with it, but clearly not enough to sustain the demands of such an extensive touring schedule, particularly when you factor in whatever bad habits she may have behind the scenes. Vocal preservation is an art form… not to say Taylor had much of a voice to preserve, but the decline is pretty bad (and she's still relatively young)
  2. I voted Blackpink as the best and Bey as the worst by mistake it was the other way around, obviously.
  3. A lot of it doesn't age well, but overall she's a fine artist. There's some songs that I love, but I'm not in love with her catalog as a whole.
  4. BGKC replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    IASF do be hittin around this time of year. The I Am side anyway. I just had a therapy session in my car while listening to Disappear while watching the last of the leaves blow off the nearly barren trees
  5. What's ironic is that she was the first female artist to have four albums with over 1 billion Spotify streams towards the end of the 2010s bc of how strong her 2000s catalog was. Now we have 2010s nostalgia playlists performing exceptionally well on Spotify, serving as the new nostalgia cycle that's benefiting so many of her newer contemporaries. This is what puts Bey at a disadvantage on streaming bc she moved anway from pop radio and ATRL runs with that as if their favs will ever be as iconic or culturally relevant as Beyoncé is after 30 years.
  6. Iconic. Elevated when performed live. Great harmonies! It can feel repetitive and unserious, but it was a bold choice nonetheless that only Beyoncé could have pulled off.
  7. i just want him to open up with Public Service Announcement. It feels inevitable though. Bonnie And Clyde with Bey will have to be a nice middle set and then end it with Empire State Of Mind with Alicia (who chooses to lip synch). Lots can be done in between tho!
  8. I doubt it, but even if he does, that's an attack on planet earth and both Trump and Netanyahu should be put to death for it.
  9. Good for her. Who wouldn't want a vapid JLo dance floor bop? Not the gays.
  10. I mean I'd add it to my Halloween playlist too.
  11. This type of cherry picking is just ridiculous. Like Abra is outstreaming Joanne, Artpop, and Chromatica (pretty much half of her own discography btw)… why? read the room
  12. A very solid pop album that most MPG's would want (commercial wise) 15+ years into their career?
  13. It's the way she plays the game, it's just vastly different, but that's just taken as an excuse. I'm not denying there's a decline in her recent streaming performance, but how bad is it really? Renaissance was still one of the most streamed female albums of 2022. I mean Motomani is pulling pretty much the same numbers as of now (which was very successful) What really is the problem other than people standing by her being overrated and convincing themselves that's it's all smoke and mirrors? She's 30 years deep and doing fine is all.
  14. She could have, but there's no use explaining that to those who've been preying on her downfall tbh. Like BMS is clearly on the floor, but hey, Alien Superstar is pulling similar streams without any single treatment at all. It's nothing crazy, but her deep cuts do pull their own weight and that's for a lot of her albums. She doesn't need to extend the commercial lifeline of a single for her to maintain a decent presence on streaming. Even songs like Haunted and All Night have been outstreaming the singles from those respective albums. Again, nothing crazy, but people are consuming her discography in full.
  15. She does have that too. It's just not all she has. I didn't know the threshold was to have 1M daily streams per hit for someone to have classics (I guess most R&B hits mean nothing to the average brain dead ATRLer). The gap between the height of her career with DC and the height of her commercial peak as a solo artist (with IASF) are 10 years apart. Two very different eras. Then there's Self Titled, one of the most streamed female albums of that year, then came Lemonade as one of the best selling albums of that year. Can you please define longevity for me, sweaty? I've already established the polarization behind projects like Rennie and CC have, but we're talking 30 years later atp. The commercial decline is valid (nor is it even that bad when we're looking at 90% of her peers (being generous btw)
  16. Beyoncé's streaming longevity isn't exclusively nostalgia-driven like 90% of MPG's you compare her to and yall have been desperately trying to make that a bad thing for quite some time now Her streaming numbers reflect an audience that extends far beyond the conventional boundaries of most MPGs. It's also very clear that many listeners/fans aren't particularly satisfied with her artistic trajectory and prefer her earlier sounds, but those type of listeners are more of a hindrance than anything else. Bey can move from contemporary R&B to pop to house to disco to country to Americana etc and still generate substantial interest. She doesn't need every listener to approve of her trajectory either. She just needs enough listeners to remain curious about where she's going while most of her "peers" fade into the distance.
  17. So they're basically just giving him yet another chance to do it again.
  18. BGKC replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    Hey so I really don't care for the live version of Drunk In Love (aside from the Dubai riff). I mean not only are Jay Z's verses are atrocious, but the chorus can feel grating after a few rounds. So for his sake, if he/they are actually performing, I rather them not perform that at all. Welcoming Bey to the halftime stage during Bonnie and Clyde though That song has already been taking off on streaming as of late, so they might as well take the opportunity to make it an even bigger classic.
  19. You Don't Know My Name is definitely worthy of the top 5, but she has so many more classics that can take up at least 3 spots overall. I mean "Fallin" alone as her debut single became an instant classic. I can let some of her other gems slide, but not including Fallin or If I Ain't Got You is just odd. Not including Be Without you by MJB is also weird. I also find it funny that Single Ladies of all songs is thrown in there. Like why not Crazy In Love instead? That falls more in line with R&B.
  20. depends on their track record. It's bad enough to be a republican, but if it's a local representative who doesn't really engage in culture wars or openly airs out his anti-LGBT views, then whatever. Even if he's cheating on his wife. I don't feel bad for women who marry republicans, let alone closeted ones.
  21. Yea I've heard it being used for dramatic edits on TikTok a few years back
  22. BGKC replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    Why did I stream Creole on AM more than all of yall combined on Spotify tho?
  23. I guess she just feels her "worth" is exceptionally high. Given all the discourse around her and how influential and polarizing she's become just adds to that effect. The security she requires is a lot more critical than most celebrities for example. Like she's become a historical figure in music that goes beyond the vapidness of most pop stars of the moment in time, so whatever she's overcharging now can be sold for A LOT more later down the line.
  24. BGKC replied to DivaCup's topic in Base
    Yea I saw Love On Top doing 800k daily and was like huh? Makes sense.
  25. Did you really just cherry pick the 2006 deluxe version while OG B'Day and the reissue is doing millions more on the side? The reissue did a solid 4M yesterday Go worry about Irreplaceable alone being older than Gaga's career with more daily stream than half of Gaga's solo albums and then maybe we can talk about complete discographies aging like milk. And the fact that Bruno/DWAS is saving Gaga from having 12M daily streams, which is what Beyoncé was doing 2 weeks ago if you took away Crazy In Love. ABYSMAL (according to yall) Like Monsters need to give it up by now, the gap is not even that big between the two for y'all to keep pushing this narrative so brazenly.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.