Which album is better?

Positions vs eternal sunshine

shut up vs intro (end of the world)

34+35 vs bye

motive (with Doja Cat) vs don't wanna break up again

just like magic vs Saturns Returns Interlude

off the table (with The Weeknd) vs eternal sunshine

six thirty vs supernatural

safety net (feat. Ty Dolla $ign) vs true story

my hair vs the boy is mine

nasty vs yes, and?

west side vs we can't be friends (wait for your love)

love language vs i wish i hated you

positions vs imperfect for you

obvious vs ordinary things (feat. Nonna)

pov vs intro (end of the world) - extended

someone like you - interlude vs twilight zone

test drive vs warm

34+35 Remix (feat. Doja Cat, Megan Thee Stallion) vs dandelion

worst behavior vs past life

main thing vs Hampstead

es sweetie

shut up vs intro (end of the world)
34+35 vs bye
motive (with Doja Cat) vs don't wanna break up again
just like magic vs Saturns Returns Interlude
off the table (with The Weeknd) vs eternal sunshine
six thirty vs supernatural
safety net (feat. Ty Dolla $ign) vs true story
my hair vs the boy is mine
nasty vs yes, and?
west side vs we can't be friends (wait for your love)
love language vs i wish i hated you
positions vs imperfect for you
obvious vs ordinary things (feat. Nonna)
pov vs intro (end of the world) - extended
someone like you - interlude vs twilight zone
test drive vs warm
34+35 Remix (feat. Doja Cat, Megan Thee Stallion) vs dandelion
worst behavior vs past life
main thing vs Hampstead

Yeah Positions is the clear winner for me

Both 10/10 albums but Godsitions > Eternal Godshine

It's Positions even though some of the ES highs are very very high!

Both miles better than thank u, next

shut up vs intro (end of the world)

34+35 vs bye

motive (with Doja Cat) vs don't wanna break up again

just like magic vs Saturns Returns Interlude

off the table (with The Weeknd) vs eternal sunshine

six thirty vs supernatural

safety net (feat. Ty Dolla $ign) vs true story

my hair vs the boy is mine

nasty vs yes, and?

west side vs we can't be friends (wait for your love)

love language vs i wish i hated you

positions vs imperfect for you

obvious vs ordinary things (feat. Nonna)

pov vs intro (end of the world) - extended

someone like you - interlude vs twilight zone

test drive vs warm

34+35 Remix (feat. Doja Cat, Megan Thee Stallion) vs dandelion

worst behavior vs past life

main thing vs Hampstead

Edited May 10May 10 by Mocha

Positions has the better bops. Eternal Sunshine is more of a cohesive project

shut up vs intro (end of the world)
34+35 vs bye
motive (with Doja Cat) vs don't wanna break up again
just like magic vs Saturns Returns Interlude
off the table (with The Weeknd) vs eternal sunshine
six thirty vs supernatural
safety net (feat. Ty Dolla $ign) vs true story
my hair vs the boy is mine
nasty vs yes, and?
west side vs we can't be friends (wait for your love)
love language vs i wish i hated you
positions vs imperfect for you
obvious vs ordinary things (feat. Nonna)
pov vs intro (end of the world) - extended
someone like you - interlude vs twilight zone
test drive vs warm
34+35 Remix (feat. Doja Cat, Megan Thee Stallion) vs dandelion
worst behavior vs past life
main thing vs Hampstead

truly love both, voted ES, but let's see just for fun:

shut up vs intro (end of the world)

34+35 vs bye

motive (with Doja Cat) vs don't wanna break up again

just like magic vs Saturns Returns Interlude

off the table (with The Weeknd) vs eternal sunshine

six thirty vs supernatural

safety net (feat. Ty Dolla $ign) vs true story

my hair vs the boy is mine

nasty vs yes, and?

west side vs we can't be friends (wait for your love)

love language vs i wish i hated you

positions vs imperfect for you

obvious vs ordinary things (feat. Nonna)

pov vs intro (end of the world) - extended

someone like you - interlude vs twilight zone

test drive vs warm

34+35 Remix (feat. Doja Cat, Megan Thee Stallion) vs dandelion

worst behavior vs past life

main thing vs Hampstead

9 vs 10

This is hard

shut up vs intro (end of the world)

34+35 vs bye

motive (with Doja Cat) vs don't wanna break up again

just like magic vs Saturns Returns Interlude

off the table (with The Weeknd) vs eternal sunshine

six thirty vs supernatural

safety net (feat. Ty Dolla $ign) vs true story

my hair vs the boy is mine

nasty vs yes, and?

west side vs we can't be friends (wait for your love)

love language vs i wish i hated you

positions vs imperfect for you (tie)

obvious vs ordinary things (feat. Nonna)

pov vs intro (end of the world) - extended

someone like you - interlude vs twilight zone

test drive vs warm

34+35 Remix (feat. Doja Cat, Megan Thee Stallion) vs dandelion

worst behavior vs past life

main thing vs Hampstead

eternal sunshine: 13
positions: 7

Edited May 10May 10 by swtamira

shut up vs intro (end of the world)

34+35 vs bye

motive (with Doja Cat) vs don't wanna break up again

just like magic vs Saturns Returns Interlude

off the table (with The Weeknd) vs eternal sunshine

six thirty vs supernatural

safety net (feat. Ty Dolla $ign) vs true story

my hair vs the boy is mine

nasty vs yes, and?

west side vs we can't be friends (wait for your love)

love language vs i wish i hated you

positions vs imperfect for you

obvious vs ordinary things (feat. Nonna)

pov vs intro (end of the world) - extended

someone like you - interlude vs twilight zone

test drive vs warm

34+35 Remix (feat. Doja Cat, Megan Thee Stallion) vs dandelion

worst behavior vs past life

main thing vs Hampstead

This wasn't even close

Positions is so underrated. It's like a classic Ariana album for me. I think eternal sunshine is certainly up there and probably the better album from a holistic standpoint when you consider everything, but I'd always reach for Positions over eternal sunshine. Its the album I'm most likely to listen to if I'm gonna be listening to Ariana.

14 minutes ago, Just a Gay on ATRL said:

shut up vs intro (end of the world)

34+35 vs bye

motive (with Doja Cat) vs don't wanna break up again

just like magic vs Saturns Returns Interlude

off the table (with The Weeknd) vs eternal sunshine

six thirty vs supernatural

safety net (feat. Ty Dolla $ign) vs true story

my hair vs the boy is mine

nasty vs yes, and?

west side vs we can't be friends (wait for your love)

love language vs i wish i hated you

positions vs imperfect for you

obvious vs ordinary things (feat. Nonna)

pov vs intro (end of the world) - extended

someone like you - interlude vs twilight zone

test drive vs warm

34+35 Remix (feat. Doja Cat, Megan Thee Stallion) vs dandelion

worst behavior vs past life

main thing vs Hampstead

This wasn't even close

This but I prefer Safety Net.

Positions in light ears. I didn't like ES at all

34+35 vs bye

motive (with Doja Cat) vs don't wanna break up again

just like magic vs Saturns Returns Interlude

off the table (with The Weeknd) vs eternal sunshine

six thirty vs supernatural

safety net (feat. Ty Dolla $ign) vs true story

my hair vs the boy is mine

nasty vs yes, and?

west side vs we can't be friends (wait for your love)

love language vs i wish i hated you

positions vs imperfect for you

obvious vs ordinary things (feat. Nonna)

pov vs intro (end of the world) - extended

someone like you - interlude vs twilight zone

test drive vs warm

34+35 Remix (feat. Doja Cat, Megan Thee Stallion) vs dandelion

worst behavior vs past life

main thing vs Hampstead

shut up vs intro (end of the world)
34+35 vs bye
motive (with Doja Cat) vs don't wanna break up again
just like magic vs Saturns Returns Interlude
off the table (with The Weeknd) vs eternal sunshine
six thirty vs supernatural
safety net (feat. Ty Dolla $ign) vs true story
my hair vs the boy is mine
nasty vs yes, and?
west side vs we can't be friends (wait for your love)
love language vs i wish i hated you
positions vs imperfect for you
obvious vs ordinary things (feat. Nonna)
pov vs intro (end of the world) - extended
someone like you - interlude vs twilight zone
test drive vs warm
34+35 Remix (feat. Doja Cat, Megan Thee Stallion) vs dandelion
worst behavior vs past life
main thing vs Hampstead

So um, 3 versus 16, so... and I LOVE Positions lmao, it's just that Eternal Sunshine is her best album and one of the best of the decade!

eternal sunshine but Positions would be stronger competition if it didn't sound so homemade. That run from off the table to nasty is excellent however

Edited May 10May 10 by rebeltwat

Eternal sunshine is better executed in my opinion. But if you take out the duds from positions and replace them with some of the deluxe tracks, I think it would come out the better record of the two.

Her two best albums!

shut up vs intro (end of the world)

34+35 vs bye

motive (with Doja Cat) vs don't wanna break up again

just like magic vs Saturns Returns Interlude

off the table (with The Weeknd) vs eternal sunshine

six thirty vs supernatural

safety net (feat. Ty Dolla $ign) vs true story

my hair vs the boy is mine

nasty vs yes, and?

west side vs we can't be friends (wait for your love)

love language vs i wish i hated you

positions vs imperfect for you

obvious vs ordinary things (feat. Nonna)

pov vs intro (end of the world) - extended

someone like you - interlude vs twilight zone

test drive vs warm

34+35 Remix (feat. Doja Cat, Megan Thee Stallion) vs dandelion

worst behavior vs past life

main thing vs Hampstead

ES cleared with 11 out of 19 as predicted

Edited May 10May 10 by RobDeWittBukater