I wouldn't put it on my playlist now but if it played, I wouldn't mind and would bop to it. So both!

When a song is a classic, it's obviously timeless, regardless of how it sounds

"Timeless" is what a definition of a classic is

I think it still sounds so fresh and new to my ears. I don't listen to it often but when I come back to listen to it, it's actually good 😊

a timeless classic

that intro still gives me goosebumps to this day

Very dated, but iconic.

All of the 2008/2009 electronic songs aged really badly imo The Fame has a lot of better tracks

Timeless

Dated she made to many rara ullala and gaga etc songs

Edited February 5Feb 5 by CherryBay

Dated

Imagine thinking this pop perfection is dated @UnusualBoy

"Dated"! Is such a lazy critique of a song

I won't tell you that I love you, kiss or hug you
'Cause I'm bluffin' with my muffin
I'm not lyin', I'm just stunnin' with my love-glue-gunnin'
Just like a chick in the casino
Take your bank before I pay you out
I promise this, promise this
Check this hand 'cause I'm marvelous

To me Poker Face might be the most dated song in her entire discography. I used to bop to this a lot but I find it unlistenable now :/ It went from my favorite single of TF era to my least favorite one

It sounds 2008 but it still sounds very good

3 hours ago, Ger said:

Imagine thinking this pop perfection is dated @UnusualBoy

These hags don't even know what they're talking about…

On 2/4/2026 at 9:15 PM, Capris Groove said:

Dated for sure, actually probably her most overrated song ever. The verses are so one-note (literally) and the chorus is kinda flat.

Compare to "Paparazzi", "Summerboy", and even "Eh Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)" which all sound fresh, breezy, and timeless.

Not Eh, Eh of all Gaga songs