who would GP recognize from their songs alone?

What do the streaming stats say?

7 minutes ago, selena_lavigne said:

What do the streaming stats say?

They're both outstreaming Selena Gomez

Katy

Beyonces only classic is the song that says put a ring on it

Edited January 19Jan 19 by Supernatural94

katy has more gp friendly and recognizable songs

1 minute ago, Supernatural94 said:

Katy

Beyonces only classic is the song that says put a ring on it

It's doing 250k streams daily, so I fear Single Ladies can't be considered a classic!

Katy.

Beyonce has like what, 4 classics and even that is a stretch: Telephone, Halo, Single Ladies and maybe Crazy In Love.

Edited January 19Jan 19 by TayDuaStan

I honestly think Katy has more

Firework, I kissed a girl, California girls, Dark horse, Hot n Cold, Teenage dream, Roar, Last Friday night

vs:

Crazy in love, Irreplaceable, Telephone, Single ladies, Cuff it?

Kathrine wins

5 minutes ago, Summer Boy said:

It's doing 250k streams daily, so I fear Single Ladies can't be considered a classic!

It doesn't matter Single ladies is a classic

Just now, Toxic Love said:

They're both outstreaming Selena Gomez

Good to know! Just seeing the prettiest name in the world and 3 of my favorite capital letters makes up for her floppage.

1 minute ago, HardBambi said:

It doesn't matter Single ladies is a classic

disease by gaga is also a classic in this case

Well what do the album/single sales and tour grosses say ?

1 minute ago, Rith said:

disease by gaga is also a classic in this case

Why? Not at all, Single Ladies was once a hit

1 minute ago, HardBambi said:

It doesn't matter Single ladies is a classic

Based on vibes ? The only Beyoncé songs the GP remembers, as shown by daily streams, are Crazy In Love, Halo and Telephone. I don't even care like that about Katy, but she has so many remembered hits. A classic can't be forgotten... Just because Single Ladies was a smash when it was released doesn't mean it stood the test of time. And tbh, Singles Ladies is unlistenable in 2026. It's legit awful.

4 minutes ago, period sis said:

Well what do the album/single sales and tour grosses say ?

katy perry is still early in her career compared to beyonce who according to her fans started her career with destinys child in 1920 or something. we can't compare katy's tour success with that

1 minute ago, Rith said:

katy perry is still early in her career compared to beyonce who according to her fans started her career with destinys child in 1920 or something. we can't compare katy's tour success with that

Katy is more late in her career than early

Say My Name, Bootylicious, Survivor, Independent Woman, Crazy in Love, Baby Boy, Irreplaceable, If I Were A Boy, Single Ladies, Halo, Diva, Run the World, Partition, Flawless, Formation >>>

I Kissed a Girl, California Girls, Teenage Dream, Firework, Roar, Dark Horse

Edited January 19Jan 19 by sugarysunflower

Katy has way more tracks with over a billion streams each but Beyonce's hits are more spaced out across her albums so both are up there

14 minutes ago, sugarysunflower said:

Say My Name, Bootylicious, Survivor, Independent Woman, Crazy in Love, Baby Boy, Irreplaceable, If I Were A Boy, Single Ladies, Halo, Diva, Run the World, Partition, Flawless, Formation >>>

I Kissed a Girl, California Girls, Teenage Dream, Firework, Roar, Dark Horse

these sneaks

Edited January 20Jan 20 by Rith

Katy

28 minutes ago, sugarysunflower said:

Crazy in Love, Single Ladies Formation

I Kissed a Girl, California Girls, Teenage Dream, Firework, Roar, Dark Horse, Hot & Cold

Sry, this is correct.

Bey has classic albums

Katy would be the easy choice since its pure pop and radio friendly. But I think it's Beyoncé in various communities. Her classics are unmatched compared to Katy.

I Kissed a Girl, Firework, Last Friday Night

Crazy in Love, Single Ladies

Katy wins, although LFN is a bit All I Want for Christmas'd

YONCÉ

1. Say My Name

2. Survivor

3. Crazy In Love

4. Irreplaceable

5. Single Ladies

6. Halo

7. Love On Top

8. Drunk In Love

9. Formation

10. CUFF IT

KAT

1. I Kissed A Girl

2. Teenage Dream

3. California Gurls

4. Firework

5. LFN

6. ET

7. Roar

8. Dark Horse