Not me coming back to three new pages of girls still going on about the auto pen.

1. Mature

2. Tell Me That Won't Happen

3. Future Tripping

4. Weather For Tennis

5. We Don't Talk

6. Roommates

7. Adult Size Medium

8. Growing Up

9. Holiday Party

10. The Optimist

11. You, From The Honeymoon

I think this is my ranking of the album.

Edited February 22Feb 22 by ithinkheknowsoutsold

has anyone been able to find the Walmart CD in stores?

Do you think the production of the main tour will be bigger than her previous tours? I hope it's more than just a basic stage set up with the band and her, hopefully we get some visuals, lifts, etc like a lot of female artists have been doing in recent years.

5 minutes ago, Aaron said:

has anyone been able to find the Walmart CD in stores?

No, it's not going to be in stores, lol.

20 minutes ago, Stepfon said:

Not me coming back to three new pages of girls still going on about the auto pen.

Gurl, we're allowed to be upset.

21 minutes ago, Stepfon said:

Not me coming back to three new pages of girls still going on about the auto pen.

I was contemplating buying her signed CD but so glad I did not

also as someone who ordered a singed vinyl, I really don't care about the autopen thing. yes, it's kinda ridiculous that Taylor Swift hand signs everything yet Hilary who has 100x less demand than her couldn't be bothered, but all autographs ordered online are lowkey meaningless anyway. if the artist didn't sign it personally for you, in person, then it's not like the signature really matters unless you're trying to resell it

1 minute ago, Cherish said:

Gurl, we're allowed to be upset.

Honestly does not make me feel like to listen to the album anymore, once and done lol

I do not find myself going back to this album right now. I'm at home with my audiophile headphones and I can't shake how the quality is. It's 2026. Who ******* does this? The spectograms are appaling. The Mine songs must have not been exported by Matthew because they're in actual high quality.

2 minutes ago, Cherish said:

No, it's not going to be in stores, lol.

the concept of Walmart making an exclusive CD and not even bothering to stock it is… lol

especially since it just sold out online

Just now, Aaron said:

also as someone who ordered a singed vinyl, I really don't care about the autopen thing. yes, it's kinda ridiculous that Taylor Swift hand signs everything yet Hilary who has 100x less demand than her couldn't be bothered, but all autographs ordered online are lowkey meaningless anyway. if the artist didn't sign it personally for you, in person, then it's not like the signature really matters unless you're trying to resell it

Not really, it's nice knowing an artist you like took the time to sign something for a specific album. At least for me it is

Based on play count alone, here's my ranking:

1. Mature

2. Roommates

3. The Optimist

4. Adult Size Medium

5. Future Tripping

6. Holiday Party

7. We Don't Talk

8. You, From The Honeymoon

9. Tell Me That Won't Happen

10. Weather for Tennis

11. Growing Up

Just now, Aaron said:

also as someone who ordered a singed vinyl, I really don't care about the autopen thing. yes, it's kinda ridiculous that Taylor Swift hand signs everything yet Hilary who has 100x less demand than her couldn't be bothered, but all autographs ordered online are lowkey meaningless anyway. if the artist didn't sign it personally for you, in person, then it's not like the signature really matters unless you're trying to resell it

That's not true at all. I see it as an opportunity to be able to own something hand signed by the artist. I feel lucky with every Taylor signature I own, even if it's not personalized. I do own some personalized signed things though and I'm more happy with them but I still feel lucky to have signed CDs/vinyls.

1 hour ago, BraveNewSeth said:

I love Hilary and I'm not trying to troll here, but I highly doubt she got THAT many signed copy orders that she would need to use autopen. I think it's a valid thing for fans to be upset about, but if the signed CDs were the same price as the regular ones I don't think there's too much to complain about.

Even if it is the same price it does not justify selling a "signed" item to then shell it out as autopenned signatures. People buy signed promos/albums with the intention of it being authentically signed. If this was not the case, people would not buy it in the first place

1 minute ago, Aaron said:

the concept of Walmart making an exclusive CD and not even bothering to stock it is… lol

especially since it just sold out online

Do most Walmarts even have a CD section anymore? Mine is reduced to one side. She should've done Target but I bet they were asking for more demands. I think she chose Walmart because it's a little cheaper and they don't ask for as much for demands. I think this way Mine songs could've gotten on streaming easier. Or maybe the vinyl coming out made them say no.

Anyways

Gagged at her implying she's already itching to record more music + do more re-records

She truly is BACK for real

Just now, zach said:

Anyways

Gagged at her implying she's already itching to record more music + do more re-records

She truly is BACK for real

I'm happy she's back. If she's back, maybe we'll get a second album within 5 years I know this hoe hates the Math but what if she did an updated version of it? The song isn't a total loss, tbh and the production on it originally was killer.

I just wish she had her masters :'( She could bring so much out from the vault.

43 minutes ago, Tom_X said:

She also mentioned the tour will be bigger, with more outfit changes and more songs overall

Yeah I thought that too. But she specifically said M&G, unlike the official package description that mentions "3) Group Photo with Hilary Duff and all other VIP attendees". I mean, it could be either!

I can see it just being a casual sort of situation where she goes around and chats with everyone, but who knows. Even being in her presence is worth it to me

1 minute ago, Cherish said:

I'm happy she's back. If she's back, maybe we'll get a second album within 5 years I know this hoe hates the Math but what if she did an updated version of it? The song isn't a total loss, tbh and the production on it originally was killer.

I wouldn't mind if she did a new album every five years. I mean, it's better to actually HAVE something to say vs. just putting something out just to put it out. I hope we do get a deluxe at least with a few more songs in the meantime.

I can see her doing it based off the fan demand (nnn inb4 The Math (Mine) [Fan Demanded Version]), but I personally don't care if she does. Yeah, the song is a serve of course, but so is (almost) every other song in her discography. I'd like to see more self-titled, Dignity and BIBO rather than just having it be all about Metamorphosis. 4/7 re-records are already from 2003.

re: 2005/6 repress of her self-titled, I think her doing the repress was a way of playing the label game at first. Remember when she went behind their backs and worked with Joel? I wonder if she got Joel to update the production or some of it but left his name off. It's way more rock oriented compared to the pop it had. Granted I think the label hit the hammer on the head properly but also watching her old interviews (especially during the Girl Can Rock era), she really wanted a rock-ish album and Hollywood didn't want her to.

1 minute ago, zach said:

I wouldn't mind if she did a new album every five years. I mean, it's better to actually HAVE something to say vs. just putting something out just to put it out. I hope we do get a deluxe at least with a few more songs in the meantime.

I can see her doing it based off the fan demand (nnn inb4 The Math (Mine) [Fan Demanded Version]), but I personally don't care if she does. Yeah, the song is a serve of course, but so is (almost) every other song in her discography. I'd like to see more self-titled, Dignity and BIBO rather than just having it be all about Metamorphosis. 4/7 re-records are already from 2003.

I would love a new album every 5 years. Gives her time to watch her kids grow up and still rest.

The Math (Mine) [Fan Demanded Version] kills me But yeah, I want a Dangerous to Know (Mine), Rock this World (Mine), Weird (Mine) and maybe even I Can't Wait (Mine). Hell, I'd love Outlaw (Mine)!

damn yall still going?

anyways chile listening to her discography again makes me wish that Most Wanted was a full album Imagine an album full of Wake Ups, Break My Hearts and Beat of My Hearts???!! Ugh she knew better to scrap it because the girls were NOT ready

Just now, Bussea said:

damn yall still going?

anyways chile listening to her discography again makes me wish that Most Wanted was a full album Imagine an album full of Wake Ups, Break My Hearts and Beat of My Hearts???!! Ugh she knew better to scrap it because the girls were NOT ready

Didn't her and Joel break up and that's what brought Dignity out? Though I am curious what else was left in the Most Wanted era... I still can't believe they (Joel and his brother) produced Material Girls... that ******* production is top-notch.