I'm open for other lineups reuniting for fun little gigs... but I would love for Heidi to be back in some kind of capacity. Sugababes 2.0 just feels nostalgic.

If she ever comes back with Heidi and Jade I hope they come up with a different name and do their own thing cause they never were nor will they be the Sugababes. I wish them luck though.

7 minutes ago, ChooseyLover said:

If she ever comes back with Heidi and Jade I hope they come up with a different name and do their own thing cause they never were nor will they be the Sugababes. I wish them luck though.

They deserve their flowers

 

 

 

54 minutes ago, Wonbin said:

They deserve their flowers

 

 

 

Honestly I would be 100% fine with them coexisting with the OGs and it would be cool if they were the camp counterpart. 

Edited August 6, 20242 yr by ChooseyLover

MKSA is coming 

no thank you. we don't wait this chick... x

I do enjoy her voice and her time in Sugababes likely constitutes the best days of her life and she will always have a place in their legacy.
 

I don't know why but I do feel her time in Sugababes may not be completely over and as she is not represented by Crown Media and Talent (the group's former management) that does create scope for the very slight possibility she may return in some capacity in the dim and distant future.

 

Would fans accept a lineup that contains both her and Mutya? (I don't know) and whilst that's unlikely to happen any time soon, I still feel it's a more likely prospect than the return of Heidi (for as long as she remains represented by Crown at least).

Stay away from them fat

1 hour ago, ChooseyLover said:

If she ever comes back with Heidi and Jade I hope they come up with a different name and do their own thing cause they never were nor will they be the Sugababes. I wish them luck though.

If we put output aside Amelle was more of a Sugababe than Siobhan or even Mutya.

 

Mutya left as soon as she got her solo deal, she stopped contributing artistically after Three.

 

Amelle stayed even after her mental breakdown.

 

And Heidi is more of a Sugababe than Siobahn and Mutya combined. 

 

 

For me forever real Sugababes line-up will be Keisha, Mutya , Heidi

 

Who's gonna tell her they would only be up to receiving Heidi

10 minutes ago, NoAngelus said:

If we put output aside Amelle was more of a Sugababe than Siobhan or even Mutya.

 

Mutya left as soon as she got her solo deal, she stopped contributing artistically after Three.

 

Amelle stayed even after her mental breakdown.

 

And Heidi is more of a Sugababe than Siobahn and Mutya combined. 

What I meant is that them as a trio never carried the Sugababes successfully. The group became something completely different without any founding member.

 

Some fans need to get over it and realize Sugababes 2.0 or 3.0 will never be a thing again. And I personally couldn't be happier for that. I adore Siobhán as a solo artist and as part of the group
 

 

Edited August 6, 20242 yr by ChooseyLover

4 minutes ago, ChooseyLover said:

What I meant is that them as a trio never carried the Sugababes successfully. The group became something completely different without any founding member.

 

Some fans need to get over it and realize Sugababes 2.0 or 3.0 will never be a thing again. And I personally couldn't be happier for that. I adore Siobhán as a solo artist and as part of the group
 

 

I think 'fans' like YOU need to get over the fact that Amelle and Heidi deserve their flowers and were Sugababes as much as Mutya and Siobahn or even more.

 

And 1.0 is doing everything but honoring legacy of Sugababes and its past members. 

 

2.0 and 3.0 will never happen, but 1.0 also didn't happen. Album bombed, they didn't even sell out one single arena show that was promoted for full year. Everything they've been doing was cheap cash grab in. They are doing festivals and 99% of festival goers can't even name them just like they don't notice when one Atomic Kitten member performs with 2 hired back up singers. 

 

GP on social media thinking 'red one' is actually Heidi pretty much says it all. 

2 minutes ago, NoAngelus said:

I think 'fans' like YOU need to get over the fact that Amelle and Heidi deserve their flowers and were Sugababes as much as Mutya and Siobahn or even more.

 

And 1.0 is doing everything but honoring legacy of Sugababes and its past members. 

 

2.0 and 3.0 will never happen, but 1.0 also didn't happen. Album bombed, they didn't even sell out one single arena show that was promoted for full year. Everything they've been doing was cheap cash grab in. They are doing festivals and 99% of festival goers can't even name them just like they don't notice when one Atomic Kitten member performs with 2 hired back up singers. 

 

GP on social media thinking 'red one' is actually Heidi pretty much says it all. 

Cope.

She seems sweet.

 

I would LOVE Heidi & Amelle to do stuff together.

3 hours ago, ChooseyLover said:

If she ever comes back with Heidi and Jade I hope they come up with a different name and do their own thing cause they never were nor will they be the Sugababes. I wish them luck though.

But they will have no other choice anyway since the original trio legally owns the name now, right ?

6 minutes ago, Zaynsus said:

But they will have no other choice anyway since the original trio legally owns the name now, right ?

Yeah, fortunately that's right. I just hope they do their own thing and the OGs can keep doing theirs without any drama   

What happened to her face? 

5 hours ago, NoAngelus said:

I think 'fans' like YOU need to get over the fact that Amelle and Heidi deserve their flowers and were Sugababes as much as Mutya and Siobahn or even more.

 

And 1.0 is doing everything but honoring legacy of Sugababes and its past members. 

 

2.0 and 3.0 will never happen, but 1.0 also didn't happen. Album bombed, they didn't even sell out one single arena show that was promoted for full year. Everything they've been doing was cheap cash grab in. They are doing festivals and 99% of festival goers can't even name them just like they don't notice when one Atomic Kitten member performs with 2 hired back up singers. 

 

GP on social media thinking 'red one' is actually Heidi pretty much says it all. 

You do realize their debut album is what made them such a respected band, right? That album is what separated them from the Atomic Kittens and Girls Alouds of the time and gave them actual artistic credibility. I'm not a very big One Touch fan, but there's no denying that it literally built the foundation that the Sugababes were able to use and grow from. Without that album there would be no Sugababes 2.0, 3.0, or 4.0, and I need you to put some respect on it (and Siobhan's) name.

I don't think Jade would ever come back. If Amelle and Heidi want to do perform songs the other 3 aren't then why not.  

It'd be messy if they also chose to use the Sugababes name though. 

My Sugababes lineup ranking

 

1. Mutya, Keisha & Heidi

2. Keisha, Heidi & Amelle

3. Heidi, Amelle & Jade

4. Mutya , Keisha & the other girl

People can hate on me for this, but I actually loved Sugababes 4.0, so I'm so here for this. Amelle was and still is so underrated as a Sugababes member. 

They can join UK The Masked Singer

 

55 minutes ago, LovaticSwiftie said:

People can hate on me for this, but I actually loved Sugababes 4.0, so I'm so here for this. Amelle was and still is so underrated as a Sugababes member. 

I loved them