Both highly successful albums, but which ones has the edge? 

 

Edited May 13, 20242 yr by Aethereal

Confessions for both. B'Day was bigger in the US though

 

Hung Up, Sorry, Get Together, Jump  - the 1-2-3-4 punch of excellence

I have never enjoyed B'Day. I have tried to enjoy it three times.

Get Together feels like meth.

Edited May 13, 20242 yr by selena_lavigne

B'Day for both, but of course the gays are gonna choose Confessions On a Dance Floor

B'day like most of Beyonce's albums is complete filler. COAD wins with ease

Filter after filter vs one of the best dance pop albums of the 2000s?

 

 

Queen of Pop of course

Confessions sweetie

Pls this is like comparing Hard Candy vs Lemonade 

Confessions was bigger and definitely better. B'day isn't a bad album, but it's not perfection like Confessions.

Girl pls...

COADF has ZERO skips. I'll say that. 

It's always Beyoncé vs. 

 

she truly is the standard 

Madonnas international appeal cannot be compared. Confessions was a worldwide smash. Bday was revived with  irreplaceable and beautiful liar. Going with Madge on this 

I voted B'Day, which is one of my favorites. My initial listen of Confession was so overhyped. I got into Madonna's discography very late in life, and everyone was hyping up Confessions. For me, it didn't meet the expectations people were hyping it to be. I think I enjoyed 4 tracks. 

Get Together and Forbidden Luv >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Bigger Star: Madonna 

Bigger era: Madonna's 

Better album: Madonna's 

bday was better, cod was bigger

Bday was better

madonnas was bigger

 

i never could get the hype for confessions. I tolerated hung up when it came out and still kinda like it but hated the rest of the album. 

1 hour ago, Mtjjproducer said:

Bday was better

madonnas was bigger

 

i never could get the hype for confessions. I tolerated hung up when it came out and still kinda like it but hated the rest of the album. 

This!!!

 

Confessions doesn't have a Freakum Dress so the better album HAS to be B'Day

Edited May 14, 20242 yr by king_queen

3 hours ago, Carla Rosón said:

Pls this is like comparing Hard Candy vs Lemonade 

and Hard Candy would win! 

22 hours ago, LatinFreak said:

COADF has ZERO skips. I'll say that. 

I love New York has a cringe lyrics however the rest of album was a crafted masterpiece from head to toe. It would been even been bigger if US did not have an anti-Madonna bias..  

I prefer B'day

Give it to Madonna.