BRANDY

The Boy Is Mine

Almost Doesn't Count

Sittin' Up In My Room

Top Of The World

I Wanna Be Down

What About Us?

Have You Ever

Full Moon

Afrodisiac

 

TONI BRAXTON

Un-Break My Heart

You're Makin' Me High

He Wasn't Man Enough

You Mean The World To Me

Another Sad Love Song

Just Be A Man About It

Breathe Again

Spanish Guitar

Stupid

 

who u got…?

Toni Braxton, and it's not even close.

 

The Boy Is Mine vs. Un-Break My Heart 

Almost Doesn't Count vs. You're Makin' Me High

Sittin' Up In My Room vs. He Wasn't Man Enough 

Top Of The World vs. You Mean The World To Me 

I Wanna Be Down vs. Another Sad Love Song (TIE)

What About Us? vs. Just Be A Man About It 

Have You Ever? vs. Breathe Again (TIE)

Full Moon vs. Spanish Guitar

Afrodisiac vs. Stupid

 

Uuuugggghhhh this was tough 

 

Love both, but love Brandy more. 

Edited April 17, 20242 yr by HarajukuPrincess

Brandy and it's not even close. 

11 minutes ago, Dr. Alexander said:

Toni Braxton, and it's not even close.

 

Just now, Stepfon said:

Brandy and it's not even close. 

oh wow? care to explain. 

 

Toni Braxton BY FAR. Secrets is one of the best albums of all time. 

I like both of them & Toni's got some classics of her own but Brandy's discography clears so she wins.

This is 100% Toni's to take but Brandy's no slouch. Her albums are good though I wish they didn't sound as dated.

Toni might have a chance here if you add Yesterday (solo version, not the awful Trey Songz duet) 

Edited April 17, 20242 yr by nostalgic

BRANDY, and it's not even close.

This is so hard. 

I love Brandy but You're Making Me High just does something to me 

 

I don't see this on your list sir 

 

 

OT: ms. Toni B with ease 

The Boy Is Mine vs Un-Break My Heart

Almost Doesn't Count vs You're Makin' Me High

Sittin' Up In My Room vs He Wasn't Man Enough

Top Of The World vs You Mean The World To Me

I Wanna Be Down REMIX vs Another Sad Love Song

What About Us? vs Just Be A Man About It

Have You Ever vs Breathe Again

Full Moon vs Spanish Guitar

Afrodisiac vs Stupid

 

WHEW this was such a good battle but Brandy just barely edged Toni out  I chose the superior version of I Wanna Be Down which put Brandy in the lead.

 

Brandy - 5 

Toni - 4 

Brandy clears with Full Moon alone. Sorry Toni maybe next time go against Mya.

Tough, but Brandy's hits just do it for me!

 

Sittin' Up in My Room, Almost Doesn't Count, The Boy Is Mine, Have You Ever, Full Moon are some of my favorite songs ever

I like more of the Brandy songs but both are legends.

Toni by far. tho i do like i wanna be down and have you ever very much but Miss Braxton has hit after hit. you dont sell 16 million in the US with just two albums and not be that girl.

Living legend Toni Braxton.

easily brandy for me!

53 minutes ago, GreatestLoveofAll said:

you dont sell 16 million in the US with just two albums

Brandy did that with one album

Toni overall . my favorite Brandy song was Brokenhearted  which was not listed .

Toni for all 

Brandy and its not even close. 

BRANDY vs. TONI BRAXTON

The Boy Is Mine vs. Un-Break My Heart

Almost Doesn't Count vs. You're Makin' Me High

Sittin' Up In My Room vs. He Wasn't Man Enough

Top Of The World vs. You Mean The World To Me

I Wanna Be Down vs. Another Sad Love Song

What About Us? vs. Just Be A Man About It

Have You Ever vs. Breathe Again

Full Moon vs. Spanish Guitar

Afrodisiac vs. Stupid