Which lineup is the best one?

 

1.0 (Siobhan, Mutya and Keisha)

 

2.0 (Heidi, Mutya and Keisha)

 

3.0 (Amelle, Heidi and Keisha)

 

4.0 (Jade, Amelle and Heidi)

 

2.0 had the most success but 1.0 are easily the most talented. Their voices harmonise so well. Heidi can't sing yet some fans won't respect Keisha's wishes and constantly ask for her back. She doesn't want to work with someone who went behind her back and sided with management to kick her out the group she founded. Rightfully so.

Edited August 3, 20233 yr by babycomeround

9 minutes ago, babycomeround said:

2.0 had the most success but 1.0 are easily the most talented. Their voices harmonise so well. Heidi can't sing yet some fans won't respect Keisha's wishes and constantly ask for her back. She doesn't want to work with someone who went behind her back and sided with management to kick her out the group she founded. Rightfully so.

basically this

/end thread

Keisha, Mutya, Siobahn >>>>
 

Their harmonies and vocal magic are what made Sugababes special. 

(Heidi, Mutya and Keisha)  

Keisha the bully and Mutya the QAnon supporter are two of the scummiest girlband members of all time, so really it needs to be 4.0. 

Yea 1.0 was just so good, authentic, unexpected…

 

But 2.0 had some f*cking BOPS 

As much as I love Heidi, I have to go with 1.0. Siobhan is just so right in the Sugababes, she fits in a way that Heidi never could. Heidi was always too polished to ever be in a group like that. 

1.0 had the talent, vocals and charisma.

no one misses that other girl at all 

The first one 

2.0 with Heidi Vocal Range ofc

 

 

It will always be with Siobhan vocally. Heidi was hired for her looks lbr 

2.0 made Sugababes. I love 1.0 but they had a career thanks to the second line up.

For me the real Sugababes are 2.0 

who voted 4

The ones with hits from Freak Like Me till Ugly

 

That is how I remember Sugababes from my childhood

 

4.0 I Love Jade Ewen so much 

The Originals.

I stan Denial tho. I want to hear a version with Mutya and Siobhan 

Edited August 3, 20233 yr by HASHTAGPOW

Which ones vote for 4.0 

2 hours ago, Kanye West said:

First line-up has the best vocals but the second line-up had much better music. Push The Button is their best song, although Keisha is practically solely responsible for writing it with Dallas Austin. While I find One Touch kinda dull, The Lost Tapes is one of the best Sugababes albums with standout tracks such as Boys, Summer of 99, and Victory which are all on par with 2.0's best material.

 

The less said about 3.0 and 4.0, the better.

Catfights was a very solid album, and I love a lot of tracks from Change

9 minutes ago, reymiu said:

Which ones vote for 4.0 

me

First lineup 

2.0 wins for nostalgia, but 1.0 is the BEST

I think a lot of people will say 2.0 because of the music, but as an actual lineup, 1.0 work so well together and I would love to see an alternate version of reality where Siobhan never left.

Imagine her vocals instead of Heidi!