I'll start: RedOne. Liddos keep wishing for Gaga to work with him again, when he hasn't produced a good track since 2012.

 

Edited February 18, 20233 yr by Virgos Groove

Max Martin after 2000 and Dr. Luke.

A.G. Cook x

Jack Antonoff

Max Martin 

Jack Antonoff has only produced like two good songs in his career

max martin

Dr Luke but he's only overrated by brainless misogynistic popper gays 

Jack antonoff

Jack Antonoff is both overrated and overhated

Max Martin

 

Billie made her debut before Britney Spears. 
Total copy, zero creativity

Britney Spears' debut sounds like Billie Piper's debut.

 

19 October 1998 - Billie 

January 12, 1999 - Britney Spears

Edited February 18, 20233 yr by Majka Jeżowska

IDK about Max Martin he's underrated currently since he went "out of style" but he has serious potential

 

Jack Antonoff

 

He just won a grmmy for Producer of the Year lmao

24 minutes ago, Sazare said:

Jack Antonoff has only produced like two good songs in his career

No it's just your taste being awful, which makes sense since you stan Carly Rae Jepsen.

Missy Elliott  

Not Jack. He’s quite a versatile producer who deserves the praise. 
 

Dr. Luke is overrated. 

Agree with OP. The stuff ReDone did with Gags is virtually his only good stuff and there's nothing he has artistically that she can't get from other producers atp. 

30 minutes ago, Pandora30012 said:

Jack antonoff

 

Jack Antonoff

How can Jack be overrated when he's literally the most bashed producer on here, Twitter, etc. 

Not everything he touches turns to gold, but he has really elevated the sound of a lot of girlies. He's best when he doesn't do the whole album though imo

BloodPop

 

 

Jack antonoff BY FAR 

 

not only ruining the potential of Taylor, Lorde and every other pop girl who get sucked into cycle of mediocrity but moreover keeping the industry stagnant with his refusal to ever change up his sound or make remotely interesting music 

 

any of u defending him are deaf or brainwashed but probably both 

Edited February 19, 20233 yr by ryoncé

The question is most overrated producer, not who's the most terrible producer who sucks. So it's Jack Antonoff. He's a good producer but an overrated one. He is much better at songwriting than producing. His production work is bare minimum, and the songs he does I usually like them for things other than production

Jack Antonoff (by far)

The Neptunes

will.i.am

 

It's annoying when almost every artist in the music industry uses the same producers for a few years to secure hits. Jack is the perfect example of this.

1 hour ago, Majka Jeżowska said:

Max Martin

 

Billie made her debut before Britney Spears. 
Total copy, zero creativity

Britney Spears' debut sounds like Billie Piper's debut.

 

19 October 1998 - Billie 

January 12, 1999 - Britney Spears

…BOMT was released in September 98’ tho…

 

OT: Jack is good but he has been reusing the same sounds for a while already…

Jack Antonoff and no one comes close to his level of overrated-ness