Which one do you like more? Did the cover surpass the original? Did Britney do the song justice?

 

Discuss! 

 

 

Edited May 27, 20224 yr by lovemehateme

Bobby’s. Britney's version flopped and is forgotten.

Just now, D.M.F said:

Bobby’s. Britney's version flopped and is forgotten.

This thread has nothing to do with chart performance but thank you very much for your input.

My Prerogative is one of my favourite Britney songs so hers. 

I know Bobby's is the original but I LOVE what Britney did with it, the sexy vibe she added to it, the video is so hot too.

Yes britney like her faves mariah and whitney completely makes her covers her own and better than the OG

 

MP

I love rock n roll

satisfaction 

 

14 minutes ago, D.M.F said:

Bobby’s. Britney's version flopped and is forgotten.

Britney has 3 known and loved covers but xtina has 0. Why?

3 minutes ago, dirrtydiana said:

Britney has 3 known and loved covers but xtina has 0. Why?

Cause if you want a screamed/yelled cover, you go to a karaoke for free.

 

-

 

They are honestly completely different  Bobby’s is better I guess, but I listen to Britney’s way more. If that makes sense.

Edited May 27, 20224 yr by Popboi.

25 minutes ago, D.M.F said:

Bobby’s. Britney's version flopped and is forgotten.

Right, and Bobby’s went Top 10 in 7 countries while Britney’s went Top 10 on 20+ countries, if you really think USA is the only metric your head is smaller than I thought 

 

OT: Britney’s but Bobby’s remains iconic

Edited May 27, 20224 yr by hector.adriel

Britney!

I prefer Bobby's version because of that classic 80s sound, but Britney's version is nice as well.  She put her own spin on it.

Britneys by far. 

6 minutes ago, Kavish said:

I prefer Bobby's version because of that classic 80s sound, but Britney's version is nice as well.  She put her own spin on it.

Right? And the lyrics still fit perfectly to her life, it's like it was written by/for her. I honestly get chills when I listen to it. 

39 minutes ago, D.M.F said:

Bobby’s. Britney's version flopped and is forgotten.

Nah it did great ww i was hearing this song all over Asia and middle east. In fact it was one of the first songs i ever heard from Britney and made me a massive fan instantly. U.S doesn't always represent the world . 

 

Ot : Britney's version. I bought MP:GH When i heard this song and Toxic. I really hope Britney collaborates with Bloodshy and avant again. 

Britney's. But I like Bobby's too

Britney made the song her own 

Brit version so dirrty & sexy 

Britney DID THAT! 

Britney's MP is a masterpiece 

I really liked Britney's production

before that, it was just another song from the 80s for me, so it didn't really hit

but when Britney did it - I mean yea..I am a fan...but this was just something that moved even the fans. The friking Video SLAYAGE

 

 

Anyways...even if it's Bobby's original and a classic, Britney's is still pretty much relevant on its own

According to WW charts, it was Much more Global..from the figures we have, it even Outsold it maybe (or matched it)

Same YT views for both of them, not even a 10m streams difference on Spotify

 

Even today's stars be singing it:

so it's known for sure

bobby by far! britney is too karaoke

She marries K fed in the video and thats not something one should do but the song is a bop. Brits.

1 hour ago, GoodGuyGoneGhetto said:

What? 

Bobby obviously. But Britney did well too.