Both amazing gems, but which one do you prefer?

 

 

 

Kelly's all the way. the pure emotion in  the vocals alone

Pink's and Lorde's are incredible as well tho.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

and none for Selena's and Demi's 

The thing about Kelly is I have a hard time believing she’s ever not been sober.

Nobody can touch anything from My December 

Kelly’s Sober is one of my favorite songs of all time

 

“Picked all my weeds but kept the flowers” is still so breathtaking

Edited April 24, 20224 yr by Beyonnaise

sober is one of pinks best songs, sober is kellys best song

Insane how both are each artist's best song  

Sober is Kelly's best song. So powerful 

Kelly for all.

 

This and Irvine are some of her best songs. 
 

2 hours ago, BGXKB said:

The thing about Kelly is I have a hard time believing she’s ever not been sober.

Kelly’s Sober isn’t about substance. It’s  about letting a person or people go of your life that aren’t good for you.  “Pick the weeds, but keep the flowers” :-)

i love both but kelly’s is just otherworldly 

never heard the kelly song so Pink wins by default 

Pink, sweetieeee, I’m so sorry 

 

what even is that other thing? 

P!nk. 

Kelly’s “Sober” by faaaar. One of her best!

Kelly’s Sober and it’s not even close. One of my favorite, if not my favorite, song of all time. 

I love both tracks so much, but I have to go with Kelly's, it might be my favorite track by her. 

Both are my favorite songs from both of them but there’s something about Kelly’s that i’ve never felt with other songs..

 

the superior sober me thinks!

Kelly for all

Kelly by leagues and miles. The sudden pink threads dd

Kelly’s, what a song!

A neck and neck poll 

Just listened to Kelly’s. Seems a bit basic? I don’t know. I feel like if Kelly had Pinks sober as her own it would be a fan favourite so yeah Pinks

Kelly’s sober is such a great song. I voted all. Pinks Sober is good. Kelly’s Sober is really breath taking. 

1 hour ago, Pilgs said:

Just listened to Kelly’s. Seems a bit basic? I don’t know. I feel like if Kelly had Pinks sober as her own it would be a fan favourite so yeah Pinks

If you listened in full you wouldn’t call it basic. You clearly missed her vocal performance on the last 33% of the song.