1 hour ago, MusicFan98 said:

So you are implying that it is possible for IVE and NMIX to sell half a million with 2 songs and half the exposure aespa has had? But aespa can't despite debuting top 20 on billboard last year and getting the most influential kpop song of their gen? Like who are IVE fans aside from Wonyoung stans? If Giselle and NingNing are flops let's not get started on Lesseo, Rei, Gaeul and the other faceless members, same goes to Nmixx and their vocalist wannabe member  

Lol people also said NMIXX numbers are fishy and that JYPee bought the albums himself.

As for IVE Wonyoung is the gen4 no1 IT girl and more popular than any of Aespa member and they had big Izone fanbase to support them so 500k is undersandable.

A 4 member group with 2 Hyoyeon in it and only 2 relevant members selling on par with top tier global groups is clearly fishy

17 minutes ago, IvyTower said:

The irony  that aespa is SM'S take on BP which was supposed to be YG's 2NE1-inspired take on SNSD (which the female take on Suju which was SM's take on Johnny's groups)

   

17 minutes ago, IvyTower said:

The irony  that aespa is SM'S take on BP which was supposed to be YG's 2NE1-inspired take on SNSD (which the female take on Suju which was SM's take on Johnny's groups)

I don’t think Blackpink was model after 2ne1 ? Aside from them having 4 members, they are nothing a like. Blackpink are more like SNSD, beautiful and talented. 2ne1 is something different. 

1 minute ago, gugunikko said:

I don’t think Blackpink was model after 2ne1 ? Aside from them having 4 members, they are nothing a like. Blackpink are more like SNSD, beautiful and talented. 2ne1 is something different. 

I mean YG did literally say BlackPink is 2ne1 just pretty. 

Love them or hate them, Aespa always bring the kii to this thread 

 

 

4 minutes ago, OrionHwang said:

Lol people also said NMIXX numbers are fishy and that JYPee bought the albums himself.

As for IVE Wonyoung is the gen4 no1 IT girl and more popular than any of Aespa member and they had big Izone fanbase to support them so 500k is undersandable.

A 4 member group with 2 Hyoyeon in it and only 2 relevant members selling on par with top tier global groups is clearly fishy

 Why are you acting like aespa didnt just have 3 back to back hits. (4 if we count stepback) Stop being dumb 

2 minutes ago, sunmimi imfurst said:

Love them or hate them, Aespa always bring the kii to this thread 

 

and tears

4 minutes ago, Gypsy Guy said:

I mean YG did literally say BlackPink is 2ne1 just pretty. 

YG said a lot of thing 

18 minutes ago, OrionHwang said:

Lol people also said NMIXX numbers are fishy and that JYPee bought the albums himself.

As for IVE Wonyoung is the gen4 no1 IT girl and more popular than any of Aespa member and they had big Izone fanbase to support them so 500k is undersandable.

A 4 member group with 2 Hyoyeon in it and only 2 relevant members selling on par with top tier global groups is clearly fishy

Ive's last comeback Wonyoung Cbar bought 98k and Karina cbar has been updated to 105K, and you  spread lies that she is more popular than any Aespa member 

Why are the girls fighting what happened 

 

22 minutes ago, gugunikko said:

I don’t think Blackpink was model after 2ne1 ? Aside from them having 4 members, they are nothing a like. Blackpink are more like SNSD, beautiful and talented. 2ne1 is something different. 

As a fan of BLACKPINK:

2016-2017 BLACKPINK is very 2NE1, and multiple tracks were 2NE1’s in the first place.

2018-2020 BLACKPINK is less 2NE1 and more “western friendly”.

 

3 hours ago, MusicFan98 said:

You are brave talent stan so I know you will serve taste...

 

I like this 

6 minutes ago, Weeaboo said:

Ive's last comeback Wonyoung Cbar bought 98k and Karina cbar has been updated to 105K, and you  spread lies that she is more popular than any Aespa member 

Clearly Karino bar saw that Wonyoung did better than Karino and were bitter so they try to break record this time.

Speaking of this WY bar pre-ordered 98k copies and the group did about 600k total and they had 7 members. 

Karino bar pre-oredered 100k but somehow they already had 1M preorders despite having less members, one is called visual hole and one is hated Chinese member.Hmmm...

7 minutes ago, OrionHwang said:

Clearly Karino bar saw that Wonyoung did better than Karino and were bitter so they try to break record this time.

Speaking of this WY bar pre-ordered 98k copies and the group did about 600k total and they had 7 members. 

Karino bar pre-oredered 100k but somehow they already had 1M preorders despite having less members, one is called visual hole and one is hated Chinese member.Hmmm...

 

Ive x Mys barely even beef  for Karina cbar to be bitter about Wonyoung or Ive so i dont know what fanfic you're talking about. But I mean yes, just because korean fans is being xenophobic doesnt mean the rest of the fandom is. And no one is called a visual hole get off of pann maybe then someone will like you back. 

aespa ALBUM SELLERS 

aespa 1M sellers  

 

-

 

also this is so good?? she ate this concept DOWN

 

 

 

5 hours ago, Lost In Paradise said:

I miss the mess of GP999. when is the next big group creation show??

 

I think I-LAND 2 is next

it's the girls turn since S1 formed ENHYPEN so a new GG will be formed at the end.

 

39 minutes ago, Vrx. said:

Why are the girls fighting what happened 

 

Aespa is smashing so people are of course pressed about it.

7 minutes ago, lauvender said:

aespa 1M sellers  

 

-

 

also this is so good?? she ate this concept DOWN

 

 

 

The IZ*ONE girlies have all really been eating since disbanding. It seems the “produce curse” was a fluke. 

1 hour ago, Gypsy Guy said:

I mean YG did literally say BlackPink is 2ne1 just pretty. 

What the creator says followers most vehemently deny 

 

the continued exponential rise in album sales is still so wild to me, like  

13 minutes ago, lauvender said:

aespa 1M sellers  

 

-

 

also this is so good?? she ate this concept DOWN

 

 

 

one of the best titles this year 

 

 

Wow I just saw this IVE is officially a million-seller group! 4th gen leaders 

ADSpa biggest gg  I knew their kind of music genre would attract fangorls money

The never ending fight of SM/JYP/YG fans. 

Aespa is clearly the #1 of the 4th Generation. IVE and LS will come close in the near future. These three groups have everything, sales, succesful singles, IT Girls, strong fan bases, views, streaming, etc.

Groups like NMIXX, StayC and Kep1er lack in at least one of those fields. 

 

"musical agenda is extremely crowded" 

I smell bought