3 minutes ago, Mel. said:

Where were they on the charts?

REALLY REALLY is bigger than all 3 of those songs combined

Nobody knows Winner like that, let's be real. GOT7 are bigger and probably sold more, let's be real and have more songs Kpop fans worldwide would recognize.

The members of GOT7 are also more famous like:

Jackson, Bambam, Mark, JB, Jinyoung >>>>>> anyone from Winner

Edited September 21, 20224 yr by Pluto2022

Just now, Dark Horse said:

everyone knows they're disbanding after this album, smash or not

I braced myself in 2021 so I could laugh at how terrible YG is instead of being sad - and it worked.

 

I said, NO, not 2NE1 again - my heart wont tolerate it!

 

 

Regardless of the lashings I've given them, those girls deserve better - assuming they actually want to release music. If they're happy being ad-girls then the fans still supporting them can choke!

 

 

 

 

 

Wait, YG stocks actually fell?? Isn't that weird? How is it possible, this is their biggest release since 2020. It doesn't make sense.

So is Garam the idol with the shortest time from debut to OUT?

5 minutes ago, Pluto2022 said:

Nobody knows Winner like that, let's be real. GOT7 are bigger and probably sold more, let's be real and have more songs Kpop fans worldwide would recognize.

The members of GOT7 are also more famous like:

Jackson, Bambam, Mark, JB, Jinyoung >>>>>> anyone from Winner

 

Winner is bigger than GOT7 no doubt, and Treasure are pulling a Stray Kids with their career. They could easily beat SK with a viral song.

 

Edited September 21, 20224 yr by MusicFan98

6 minutes ago, Mel. said:

Not you gagging me

WINNER still have the hits and TREASURE outsold in their debut year

The only reason Treasure was able to sell more in their debut year compared to SKZ is because of the general growth of the Kpop market though. 

 

SKZ in their 2nd year: Blew up with "God's Menu" and "Back Door"

Treasure in their 2nd year: Losing 2 members 

3 minutes ago, Dark Horse said:

not aespa selling pretty much the same pure with GIRLS

 

And without stock prices falling

 

7 minutes ago, Pluto2022 said:

Nobody knows Winner like that, let's be real. GOT7 are bigger and probably sold more, let's be real and have more songs Kpop fans worldwide would recognize.

The members of GOT7 are also more famous like:

Jackson, Bambam, Mark, JB, Jinyoung >>>>>> anyone from Winner

We're not talking about who's more famous

we're talking about HITS and GOT7 have none...

2 minutes ago, MusicFan98 said:

 

Winner is bigger than GOT7 no doubt, and Treasure are pulling a Stray Kids with their career. They could easily beat SK with a viral song.

 

GOT7 are generally bigger than Winner, let's not lie to ourselves   BTS, EXO, SVT, GOT7 were the top boy groups among the 3rd gen, now let's be real. 

I can't to hear this live on tour

 

 

 

2 minutes ago, Mel. said:

We're not talking about who's more famous

we're talking about HITS and GOT7 have none...

Isn't "Just Right" a boy group classic?  

Just now, Pluto2022 said:

Isn't "Just Right" a boy group classic?  

a classic in fans eyes doesn't mean it was a hit record 

yeah, it's probably their most recognizable song, but it wasn't a hit song

Do ppl outside of Korea know what a WINNER is? 

Aside from Lisards that probably recognize that guy from dancing with LISA in a few tiktoks?

 

Is that not Jisoo singing background on "Hard To Love"?

I know I hear her

 

but anyways, it should've been a vocal line song

but Rosé BODIED

Just now, DanyelP23 said:

Do ppl outside of Korea know what a WINNER is? 

Aside from Lisards that probably recognize that guy from dancing with LISA in a few tiktoks?

 

Ummm...yes they do 

they had a successful tour in the US and other countries 

and since you mentioned it, they're actually in the US right now for a K-Pop festival happening 

Just now, Mel. said:

a classic in fans eyes doesn't mean it was a hit record 

yeah, it's probably their most recognizable song, but it wasn't a hit song

"Just right" is more known and has more streams than "Really Really" which is Winner's biggest hit. 

 

Winner are local while GOT7 are more recognized worldwide.

The power Got7 has in South East Asia alone like...

being a LV queen and also a Pizza one  

 

 

When you have no chance at debuting at #1

so you team up with another fanbase to try and block the success of women

and that's why NCT 127 will continue to be flops, I'm also not surprised ARMY are involved

 

God don't like ugly  

 

 

31 minutes ago, Dark Horse said:

not aespa selling pretty much the same pure with GIRLS

 

This is a trip. 

 

44 minutes ago, Pluto2022 said:

 

I feel like these are bigger than all of Winner songs, but then again I don't know much about Winner tbh.

I feel like Winner are just  "there" 

None of these made any waves in Korea at all. GOT7 had something of a decent following internationally and were largely carried by that support. The best-received attempt they’d probably ever made in Korea was with Just Right, and I’m still not even sure that ever charted.

 

Really, Really was perhaps one of the very few national hits achieved by a BG in the third gen (I’d even put it on par with Love Scenario), and they had one or two big hits that followed, as well. It’s no competition at all. The reason GOT7 probably felt bigger was because they had a few popular members.

Edited September 21, 20224 yr by Rhythm

BLACKPINK really be having multiple fandoms mad by simply existing 

the power they hold 

Crazy how IVE & WJSN are from the same company. 

YG is really struggling these days. They are lucky to have BP and somewhat TREASURE, otherwise they would've gone bankrupt. Winner and ikon are over and BP alone cannot feed a whole company I fear. The only way for YG to build a strong roster again is to bring back 2NE1 and BIGBANG and debut Baemon as fast as possible and disband the actual flops of the company. Like I can't believe YGLY really disbanded 2NE1 while holding on to Winner and iKon for his dear life who are nowhere near the level of 2NE1  This man truly hate women I swear, and he probably hates the fact that he has to rely on BP so much, since they are the main bread winners.

The fact that we all know that if he had to pick between BP and TREASURE he would pick TREASURE over BP any day with his ungrateful misogynistic a$$.

We should've expected the downfall of the company ever since he disbanded 2NE1 and would rather keep some mid boy groups instead of actual legends. 

 

Imagine if YG consisted of Blackpink + 2NE1 + BIGBANG + Treasure + Baemon 

Edited September 21, 20224 yr by Pluto2022

 

 

12 minutes ago, Rhythm said:

This is a trip. 

 

None of these made any waves in Korea at all. GOT7 had something of a decent following internationally and were largely carried by that support. The best-received attempt they’d probably ever made in Korea was with Just Right, and I’m still not even sure that ever charted.

 

Really, Really was perhaps one of the very few national hits achieved by a BG in the third gen (I’d even put it on par with Love Scenario), and they had one or two big hits that followed, as well. It’s no competition at all. The reason GOT7 probably felt bigger was because they had a few popular members.

NOBODY OUTSIDE OF KOREA KNOWS WINNER

Idk why yall keep bringing up aespa with BLACKPINK's sales but

 

Born Pink regular album is $50 and the digipacks are $20

aespa digipacks are $11 and the regular albums are $20

 

you also can't tell me aespa are more known in the West than BP  I love both but please be serious

 

and as for TWICE outselling them, this will forever be a mystery to me

 

blackpink might really be flopping in the west but its what YG deserves for always bragging about the pinks but is the most incompetent company out there  

 

 

 

Edited September 21, 20224 yr by MonsterNavy