5 minutes ago, Pluto2022 said:

SNSD is the only gg I can think of who rivals Mamamoo in vocals, but at the same time not, cause none of the other SNSD members rivals Taeyeon in vocals while MOTHERMOO has Whee In, Solar and Hwasa who are all on the same vocal tier as Taeyeon. MAMAMOO are the female version of EXO, where they have 3 exceptional vocalists. But yeah it's kinda weird that there isn't really that many girl groups who are stacked with great vocalists. 

 

And speaking of SHINee, I feel like people are sleeping on their vocals (not their music of course), like Onew, Taemin and Key are all top vocalists as well 

Not Taemin being a top vocalist 

1 hour ago, rock4lee said:

I was thinking earlier how SM is known for great vocals, but their girl groups are never as stacked as their BGs. Look at Shinee vs Red Velvet and f(x), both have an elite vocalist (Jonghyun, Luna, Wendall), but Seulgi/Joy and Krystal( who is my single ultimate k-pop bias but I will admit the girl can’t really sing) just can’t support a song the way Onew, Taemin and Key can. Is there any SMGG song with 3 minutes of screaming like Sorry Sorry Answer, What is Love or Symptoms? Or really any 3rd/4th gen GG besides mamamoo?

 

#bringbackvocalists2k23

Everybody forgets about them but these ******* pulled off one of the most unnecessarily difficult songs to sing in the k-pop canon. Their main vocal, Lina, is the best female vocalist SM ever had but the group was sadly kind of a flop and I think she's a musical actress now

 

 

6 minutes ago, Witnessed ET said:

Not Taemin being a top vocalist 

I'd like to see a 3rd gen group vocalist not From EXO or NCT rival him at all.

6 minutes ago, Witnessed ET said:

Not Taemin being a top vocalist 

He was at one point, though. Currently not so much but in like 2012 - 2013...whew. The way he went off on the Misconceptions albums was wild considering how he sang when he was younger.

1 hour ago, cloudbusting said:

mamamoo are so talented but a lot of their music just doesn’t click for me 

 

like on paper I should love them but I only just sometimes enjoy 

you don't like HIP? that's literally one of the best kpop songs ever 

4 minutes ago, Witnessed ET said:

Not Taemin being a top vocalist 

Wait wasn't he the main vocalist of SuperM along with Baekhyun? He is probably the idol who have improved the most in Kpop, where he went from not having any lines, to being to able to belt and support Onew. 

4 minutes ago, MusicFan98 said:

I'd like to see a 3rd gen group vocalist not From EXO or NCT rival him at all.

 

3 minutes ago, Blueberry Kisses said:

He was at one point, though. Currently not so much but in like 2012 - 2013...whew. The way he went off on the Misconceptions albums was wild considering how he sang when he was younger.

 

3 minutes ago, Pluto2022 said:

Wait wasn't he the main vocalist of SuperM along with Baekhyun? He is probably the idol who have improved the most in Kpop, where he went from not having any lines, to being to able to belt and support Onew. 

I mean he was good yes. But I’m not sure about being one of the “top” vocalists compared to other SM top male vocalists 

Edited August 27, 20224 yr by Witnessed ET

Just now, Witnessed ET said:

 

 

I mean he was good yes. But I’m not sure about being one of the “top” vocalists compared to other SM male vocalists 

Taemin is in interesting case. He had what was probably at the time the most developed mix out of any male in SM except for maybe Kyuhyun but he had no lower register and no upper register. Only the middle was really good  If he'd been that good across the board he would've been one of the best pop singers of all time.

 

Peep the fully supported sustained B4 at 2:10:

 

 

This was in 2013 when he was at his vocal peak and he definitely can't do that anymore, but that's something that maybe...3 or 4 guys in k-pop have ever done. Kyuhyun, Ryeowook, and Sandeul are the only ones that come to mind (though I'm probably forgetting some). No other part of Taemin's voice was that developed so I wouldn't call him great overall but he pulled off some really impressive stuff during that time period.

24 minutes ago, Pluto2022 said:

SNSD is the only gg I can think of who rivals Mamamoo in vocals, but at the same time not, cause none of the other SNSD members rivals Taeyeon in vocals while MOTHERMOO has Whee In, Solar and Hwasa who are all on the same vocal tier as Taeyeon. MAMAMOO are the female version of EXO, where they have 3 exceptional vocalists. But yeah it's kinda weird that there isn't really that many girl groups who are stacked with great vocalists. 

 

And speaking of SHINee, I feel like people are sleeping on their vocals (not their music of course), like Onew, Taemin and Key are all top vocalists as well 

Yeah SNSD isn’t as bad about it, but even with Jessica I wouldn’t put their vocal line on par with SJ or EXO. Even though they don’t reach the highs of their peers, I think Aespa is better in this regard in that it’s only 4 of them all of them are solid to strong vocalists. They need a true and blue R&B song. Maybe Baemon will save us . 

I see people here are still writing essays about PV not being no.1 on melon, the pathetic 

24 minutes ago, MusicFan98 said:

I'd like to see a 3rd gen group vocalist not From EXO or NCT rival him at all.

WINNER's Yoon

easily.

WINNER's Yoon seats a lot of your favs

but no one's ready for that conversation 

 

he's the idol with the most crowns on "Masked Singer" for a reason 

he seated so many girlies during his reign 

38 minutes ago, Selenasworld said:

you don't like HIP? that's literally one of the best kpop songs ever 

Hip is one of the few that clicked with me! an eternal spot on my running and driving playlists 

7 minutes ago, cloudbusting said:

Hip is one of the few that clicked with me! an eternal spot on my running and driving playlists 

What about "Egotistic"? It's literally the best kpop song of all time

 

Chaeyoung looks so cute with that hair lol.

2 hours ago, MusicFan98 said:

Let me quote you back with my faves by them so far

 

 

Taste. Their Japanese debut TT was a bop even though some part was lowkey similar to Boys with Luv nnn

 

And not them already scheduled to embark their first Latin America and US tour around September-October despite just debut last year.

 

Edited August 27, 20224 yr by discreetinside

11 minutes ago, sunmimi imfurst said:

Chaeyoung looks so cute with that hair lol.

I have a feeling we’re getting a Studio Choom performance with these outfits. 

9 hours ago, Butters said:

Of course the NONCEJEAN stan is gonna call girl groups "washed up" for not recruiting their members off playgrounds during recess time. **** right off don't speak on **** you know absolutely nothing about you cretin

Wait this actually is fun to watch. Has anybody watched this thing entirely? I know there are a lot of episodes.

 

 

1 hour ago, Pluto2022 said:

SNSD is the only gg I can think of who rivals Mamamoo in vocals, but at the same time not, cause none of the other SNSD members rivals Taeyeon in vocals while MOTHERMOO has Whee In, Solar and Hwasa who are all on the same vocal tier as Taeyeon. MAMAMOO are the female version of EXO, where they have 3 exceptional vocalists. But yeah it's kinda weird that there isn't really that many girl groups who are stacked with great vocalists. 

 

And speaking of SHINee, I feel like people are sleeping on their vocals (not their music of course), like Onew, Taemin and Key are all top vocalists as well 

Please! The Grace’s Lina alone can obliterate mamamoo. Mamamoo are good as a group but individual they lost out to the likes of taeyeon, Wendy, Luna. 
 

 

Ever wonder what would have happen if SNSD’s The Boys actually charted top 10 on Billboard and thier un-finished English Album was completed. And they became as big in the west as BTS and BlackPink are Now? Honestly the could have had a more stable Career then Little Mix or Fifth Harmony, given the right producers. They were supposed to get More Kesha and Britney Spears Demos in late 2011, but the album never materialized due to thier demand in Japan and Korea.  That sound of music is dated now, but in 2011-2012 they could have smashed with a contemporary pop song before Psy hit the scene

Edited August 27, 20224 yr by Gorjesspazze9

2 hours ago, Blueberry Kisses said:

Everybody forgets about them but these ******* pulled off one of the most unnecessarily difficult songs to sing in the k-pop canon. Their main vocal, Lina, is the best female vocalist SM ever had but the group was sadly kind of a flop and I think she's a musical actress now

 

 

Wait, Highkey need Aespa to pull a DCT again but with this song, imagine Winter going off pitch in every high note, 4th gen heaven

Oncers what’s up 

 

Gone 

When we were kids 

Basics 

Trouble 

Queen of Hearts

Talk that Talk

Brave

 

On 8/25/2022 at 6:29 PM, Witnessed ET said:

She is IVE’s Jeongyeon. So no logical explanation I fear. 

Why is it always the most talented member. 

Hype boy finally taking over