4 minutes ago, ViviLittleM said:

Whatever she’ll release, Gaga’s best album will forever be Born This Way

I wouldn’t be so sure. I think it’s very possible she tops it one day.

4 hours ago, sunbathinganimal said:

well it’s over

Me and another user pointed out this just last week that she might have been in the studio not for the album.. when others in here as usual were acting like she was 100% working on the new album with that producer.

 

It was obvious to me she wasn't recording a different project just few weeks before filming Joker, especially knowing that it's a musical (so it would have been logical thinking she was recording for that) and most important all the preparation that she does to get and stay into character, but I gave up on pointing out those things since it would have been triggered the usual copy paste posts of certain users that think to know for sure what she is doing behind the scenes.

 

Keep secretly a collab for other artists is one thing, a whole new album is another, in my opinion in a way or another we will know in advance when and if she has worked on it.

Maybe they wanted the collab to be secret so Andrew didn’t follow her until just a few months ago instead of when they recorded  

1 hour ago, GraceRandolph said:

If Gaga released Replay as a lead instead of SL, most of you would have Chromatica in your top 3 Gaga albums. 

it still would've underperformed commerically like anything from chromatica, so monsters still would trash it. 
SL made the most sense a lead the album is good with Gagas personality littered into and a great listen start to finish.

Rena is still a dance album but it feels released in the 20s, not in the same way of 2010s era. 

 

TF production isn't revolutionary but it literally marked the shift of radio.  If you're gonna go back to something as an artist, it has to be EXTRA EXTRA solid - esp dance/pop music

 

the way she marketed and promoted was good as ever with her one woman soundbite campaigns 'healing in dance'  and the concept and theme was really good and relevant of mental health. 
 

Edited September 29, 20232 yr by Mr. Stratus

39 minutes ago, Funnyfatty said:

Chromatica is Gagas best album even though the topic is very specific. I love the album but “dancing through your pain” kind of triggers me now. I don’t want to touch any of the songs anymore even though i know its one of her bests. Repeating “my biggest enemy is me” everyday during singing a song can cause mental health issues subconsciously. We became what we sing and say so. 
 

still my top 5 is

 

Replay > Alice > 911 with interlude > Rain On Me > Sine From Above (remix) 

omg i thot i was the only one fearing Traumatica would worsen my mental health issues on repeated listens

 

replay + 911 are psychiatrists worst nightmare i fear

now i listen to born this way album for free therapy 

 

911 is honestly healing. It’s one of the best pop songs. 

20 minutes ago, hétérosexuelle said:

omg i thot i was the only one fearing Traumatica would worsen my mental health issues on repeated listens

 

replay + 911 are psychiatrists worst nightmare i fear

now i listen to born this way album for free therapy 

 

I mean the songs have replay value. Its not a song you hear once and be like “oh cool” and never listen again. Thats the problem. Its a pop song about being suicidal or whatever. I think thats why she distanced herself from that album. She is repeating her own mental health problems   
 

i remember i made a girlfriend of mine watch the 911 video. She said the video was fantastic and different but that she never wants to see it or hear it again. She said “i can’t imagine what is happening in the mind of someone who shoots videos like this she is not good in her head” and opened i will never love again  

 

Great album though and deserved much better. 

8 hours ago, Almodusa said:

 

Didn’t put in the readers and read pregnant 

15 minutes ago, G.U.Y. Gaga said:

Didn’t put in the readers and read pregnant 

Her Mary Clayton serve

So what are your top 5 Gaga music videos? Mine:

 

1. Paparazzi

2. You and I

3. Bad Romance

4. Alejando

5. Judas

not them unleashing all 30 variants of vinyl at once  take note ms stefani 

 

 

5 minutes ago, truthteller said:

not them unleashing all 30 variants of vinyl at once  take note ms stefani 

 

 

one variant for each shade 

 

Spoiler

a Rose Gold Shimmer vinyl would be a slay ngl

 

19 hours ago, sunbathinganimal said:

when Pitchfork gives it Best New Track

 

Gaga had awesome vocals on the new track, as always, but like with much of the other stuff she's doing in her career at the moment I'm just not into the old timey vibes.

27 minutes ago, truthteller said:

not them unleashing all 30 variants of vinyl at once  take note ms stefani 

 

 

Not a baseball version

2 hours ago, ViviLittleM said:

Whatever she’ll release, Gaga’s best album will forever be Born This Way

But the absolute serve if she were to ever top it. 

I was told that I would have forgotten SSOH by today, but I'm on my 5th spin of the day. Lies were spoken I fear. 

What I think helps BTW, even if some may be called fillers, is that it’s her longest album thus far with 17 songs/1h13m. That does help make it an experience. Of course the music itself is the most important part but the length aids it me thinks. 

 

 

3 minutes ago, hausofdave said:

 

 

Yeah the concensus is that SSOH is their best song since 1989, Grammys next

17 minutes ago, Almodusa said:

What I think helps BTW, even if some may be called fillers, is that it’s her longest album thus far with 17 songs/1h13m. That does help make it an experience. Of course the music itself is the most important part but the length aids it me thinks. 

Yeah what makes BTW a masterpiece is that it's a long album but full of really good songs. Artpop had the reverse problem where it was a longer album with less-than-stellar songs.

 

I don't think it's impossible for her to top it. Many artists of her caliber have released their best works several eras into their careers. LG7 being rock-inspired and topping BTW would be a funny irony too given the rock influences on the latter.

I will def be listening to their album when it comes out, and it’ll be nice to hear SSOH as part of it 

We really need an industrial album from Gaga one day.

2 hours ago, GraceRandolph said:

So what are your top 5 Gaga music videos? Mine:

 

1. Paparazzi

2. You and I

3. Bad Romance

4. Alejando

5. Judas

I can see paparazzi at number 1, but You and I over bad romance.....

 

My List:

1. Bad Romance (the scene at the end with the red outfit and the clap and twirl )

2. Paparazzi (the metropolis outfit with the crutches )

3. Telehone (that final chorus with Beyonce )

4. Alejandro (second chorus cinematography is masterful)

5. Tied between Poker Face and Love Game (poker face into is legendary, but love game final chorus choreography is the best she's ever danced)

 

 

 

What's your bottom five?

 

My List:

1. DWUW (for obvious reasons- this video would have tanked her career more than ARTPOP was doing at the time)

2. The Edge of Glory (the 15-year-old homosexual in me will never forgive her for the original video w/ Joseph Kahn falling through)

3. Hold My Hand (does this even count?)

4. Eh, Eh (almost forgot about this)

5. G.U.Y (just a mess- she looked gorg and some of it slays but the whole mincraft + jesus/MJ/lennon thing with the legos... what a flop)

Edited September 29, 20232 yr by CoolNebraskaGuy

1 minute ago, CoolNebraskaGuy said:

I can see paparazzi at number 1, but You and I over bad romance.....

 

My List:

1. Bad Romance (the scene at the end with the red outfit and the clap and twirl )

2. Paparazzi (the metropolis outfit with the crutches )

3. Telehone (that final chorus with Beyonce )

4. Alejandro (second chorus cinematography is masterful)

5. Tied between Poker Face and Love Game (poker face into is legendary, but love game final chorus choreography is the best she's ever danced)

 

 

 

You and I is so underrated. It's just so perfect.