On 5/21/2025 at 8:21 PM, penguintim said:

I've been thinking (once I request and receive permission from the mods of course) about organizing a Carly Ra(t)e for a while now and even spending an inordinate amount of time yesterday designing graphics when I should've been working. The conundrum is do we try doing it before CRJ8 drops, wait until it drops so we can conclude it, or wait even longer in case we get another companion album shortly after and we can include that?

I think you should do one now and then we can do CRJ8 album survivor

Where are my I'll Be Your Girl stans

 

Any new album announced? I enjoyed The Loneliest Time so much,  The Loveliest Time not so much so it feels like the last album was in 2022

4 minutes ago, politeone said:

Any new album announced? 

she was finishing it few weeks ago and teased Ice Cream Cone

 

 

6 hours ago, Kern said:

she was finishing it few weeks ago and teased Ice Cream Cone

 

Sounds cool, I like this less maximalist sound on here. It's just bare bones instruments and voice and great song writing 

 

 

 

Provisional final song list for the upcoming rate, is there anything you think is missing fellow carly fries?

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1QfvXUUHNKCvr9KhVTybEGsp2TAF27ov55Ea0xOHt-04/edit?usp=sharing

a carly rate would be too hard for me. everything will be 8+ 

This is the last song I'm having trouble deciding whether to include bc she's not credited, but she is all over the backing vocals... help me out fellow carly fries do we include it or not?

7 hours ago, penguintim said:

This is the last song I'm having trouble deciding whether to include bc she's not credited, but she is all over the backing vocals... help me out fellow carly fries do we include it or not?

Well yes because it's a good song and more Carlenesties need to be exposed to the excellent sings on Gone Now 

9 hours ago, penguintim said:

This is the last song I'm having trouble deciding whether to include bc she's not credited, but she is all over the backing vocals... help me out fellow carly fries do we include it or not?

No, we need a rate with less Jack Ingmeoff 

 

Edited June 20, 20251 yr by Curaga

On 6/19/2025 at 12:04 AM, penguintim said:

Provisional final song list for the upcoming rate, is there anything you think is missing fellow carly fries?

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1QfvXUUHNKCvr9KhVTybEGsp2TAF27ov55Ea0xOHt-04/edit?usp=sharing

Oh wow, I never knew there were extra songs on Dedicated Side B... and I see Super Natural, so this list looks good to me!

julien for number one 

 

4 hours ago, Katamari said:

julien for number one 

 

Not with that egregious beep/mixing error between 2:00–2:01 

 

 

cute song otherwise

11 hours ago, hoax said:

Well yes because it's a good song and more Carlenesties need to be exposed to the excellent sings on Gone Now 

 

9 hours ago, Curaga said:

No, we need a rate with less Jack Ingmeoff 

 

ok

Happy B-day to her best album 

 

 

 

4 hours ago, BlahBlahBlah said:

Happy B-day to her best album 

 

 

 

Put it to Rest is a godtier song..........like the motherquakes that happened flattened cities

we got Rufus Wainwright on Drag Race Canada before Carly 

she's coming

@PenguinTim just came here to post this stuff! New ATRL Moderator, youre doing amazing, sweetie (.mp3)!!

Also- can I redo my rates. I started falling deeply in love with a lot of the Kiss album (finally) and kinda feel wrong about some of my scores. Poor, This Kiss…she deserved a 9.5

we can redo the rate to put Disco Darlene on #1

Just noticed that this is available on Spotify thanks to some gay at Interscope uploading this video there

Okay girls it's time to hold our noses and make this go viral!